Moksha-Dharma

Moksha-Dharma · moksha-dharma, “the dharma of release”

Moksha-dharma (also written Mokshadharma) is the dharma of moksha (liberation). Moksha means freedom from saṃsāra, the endless cycle of birth and death, and dharma here means the teaching and way of life that leads there. Moksha-dharma brings together teachings on the nature of the ātman (the true Self) and of the jīva, on what causes bondage, and on the paths to moksha.

The Agni Purāṇa (Chapter 14) names the mokshadharmas among the teachings that Yudhishṭhira heard from Bhīshma after the war, before he became king.

In the Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Śrī Kṛshṇa tells Uddhava how he once appeared as Haṃsa, the swan, to answer a question of the Sanakādis that Brahmā put to him, and how, at the end of that teaching, he said: “Know me to be Śrī Hari, the form of yajña, who came wishing to teach you the dharma of moksha.” The Bhāgavata also teaches moksha itself at length: it calls moksha the one purpose of the whole Purāṇa, says what moksha is and that Śrī Hari alone grants it, names its means, bhakti above all, with the Name, ātma-jñāna, yoga and the company of the great, tells of those who attained it, and praises the bhaktas who do not seek even moksha.

The Brahma Purāṇa, near its close, gives its own teaching of moksha-dharma: Vyāsa answers the munis’ questions on the ātyantika laya, yoga, sāṅkhya and the jñānīs’ way to moksha, and tells them the old dialogue of Vasishṭha and King Karāla Janaka. He calls moksha-dharma the most ancient dharma, praised by the ṛshis and best of all dharmas, and teaches that as the road to the eastern ocean does not reach the western, the dharma that brings moksha is one. The Purāṇa says that moksha, the final fruit of karma, is won only from the land of Bhārata; that Nārāyaṇa rests in moksha and moksha rests on nothing; and, in its Gautamī Māhātmya, that the Gautamī grants moksha to all who bathe in her, anywhere and at any time, by the command of Bhagavān Śiva.

Per Mahābhārata

In the Mahābhārata, the Mokshadharma Parva is the second large part of the Śānti Parva (Chapters 168–353). It is one of the fullest collections of moksha-śāstra (teaching on moksha) in the whole Mahābhārata. It holds dozens of upākhyānas (stories), saṃvādas (dialogues) and teachings drawn from the full range of Indian thought: Sāṃkhya, Yoga, Vedānta, the Bhāgavata tradition, and the lived wisdom of the jñānī (one who knows the truth).

Structure and Scope

The Mokshadharma Parva does not tell one continuous story. It is a collection of dialogues and upākhyānas told to Yudhishṭhira by Bhīshma. Bhīshma is lying on his bed of arrows, waiting for the auspicious moment of his death, and he draws on the huge store of Vedic, Purāṇic and śāstric (scriptural) teaching that he holds. The Parva moves between teachings on how the world came to be, reasoned argument, life stories of ṛshis, and practical guidance on the path to moksha.

Its subjects include:

  • Sāṃkhya teaching on creation and how the tattvas (basic elements of existence) unfold
  • The nature of kshetra (the field: body, mind and world) and kshetrajña (the knower of the field)
  • How saṃsāra works and what leads to rebirth
  • Answers to the views of the Lokāyata (Cārvāka, the materialists) and the Bauddhas (Buddhists)
  • Japa-yoga (repeating a mantra) as the highest sādhanā (spiritual practice)
  • Dhyāna-yoga (meditation) and the cleansing of the kleśas (afflictions of the mind)
  • Vairāgya (detachment) as the ground of all moksha
  • The dharma of the sthita-prajña (one whose wisdom is steady)

Key Dialogues in Chapters 174–230

These are the main saṃvādas in the second part of the Mokshadharma Parva.

Teachings on Vairāgya and Non-Attachment

  • Brāhmaṇa–Senajit Saṃvāda (Chapter 174): a king struck with grief is taught the nature of karma and suffering
  • Śaṃpāka Gītā (Chapter 176): the ascetic Śaṃpāka teaches that dāridrya (poverty) is better than wealth for spiritual growth, and that tyāga (giving up) is the only path
  • Maṅki Gītā (Chapter 177): the ṛshi Maṅki faces his own kāma (desire) head-on; kāma is born from saṃkalpa (intention); the teaching of the brahmapura
  • Bodhya Gītā (Chapter 178): the six gurus from the natural world of Bodhya Ṛshi: Piṅgalā, the lāṭukika bird, the snake, the bee, the arrow-maker and the maiden with bangles

Teachings on Ajagara-Vṛtti

  • Ajagara–Prahlāda Saṃvāda (Chapter 179): Prahlāda meets the python; ajagara-vṛtti (the “python’s way of life”) as the practice of living without effort and without desire

Dialogues on Creation and Deeper Truths

  • Sṛgāla–Kaśyapa Saṃvāda (Chapter 180): the jackal and Kaśyapa; respect for living beings, and dharma
  • Bhṛgu–Bharadvāja Saṃvāda on Creation (Chapters 182–194): Bhṛgu’s full teaching to Bharadvāja on creation: how the world came to be, how living species arose, the question of varṇa, karma-vipāka (how karma ripens), and the science of the ātman

Japa-Yoga

  • Jāpakopākhyāna (Chapters 196–200): Kauśika’s japa lasting a thousand years, and the debate on whether japa is the highest of all sādhanās

Dharma and Rule

  • Manu–Bṛhaspati Saṃvāda (Chapters 201–206): Manu and Bṛhaspati on the origin of rājadharma (the dharma of kings), why rule is needed, and the duty of the king

The Vārshṇeya-adhyātma Teaching

  • Vārshṇeya-adhyātma Kathā (Chapters 210–217): Vāsudeva as Paramātmā (the Supreme Self); the 16 tattvas; the nava-dvāra-pura (the body as a city of nine gates); the image of the wheel of saṃsāra; vivartavāda (the teaching that the world is an appearance); cleansing the kleśas through dhyāna (meditation)

Pañcaśikha‘s Teaching to Janaka

  • Pañcaśikha–Janaka Saṃvāda (Chapters 218–219): answers to the views of the Lokāyata and the Bauddhas (Saugatas); advaita sarvatyāga (giving up everything in the light of non-duality) as the highest path

Three Dānavas Teach Indra

In these dialogues Indra, king of the devas, is taught by his own enemies, the dānavas (a race of asuras).

  • Śakra–Prahlāda Saṃvāda (Chapter 222): Prahlāda teaches Indra about non-doership (akartṛtva), svabhāva (one’s own nature), and the Supreme Brahman as the source of all
  • Bali–Vāsava Saṃvāda (Chapters 223–225, 227): Bali teaches Indra that kāla (time) is a great ocean and that all greatness passes away; Śrī (the devī of fortune) departs from Bali; the anahaṃkāra-gītā (song of freedom from ego)
  • Śakra–Namuci Saṃvāda (Chapter 226): Namuci teaches Indra about the eka-śāsaka (the one ruler of the universe), bhavitavya (what is bound to happen), and the uselessness of grief

The Glory of Śrī

  • Śrī-Sannidhāna (Chapters 225, 228): Śrī’s four pādas (quarters) and eight companions, and the conditions under which she stays with a person

The Jñānī in the World

  • Jaigīshavya–Asita Saṃvāda (Chapter 229): the dharma of the sthita-prajña; treating insult as amṛta (nectar) and honour as visha (poison); cutting the hṛdaya-granthi (the knot of the heart)
  • Vāsudeva–Ugrasena Saṃvāda (Chapter 230): Nārada as the ideal jñānī; a picture of the complete jñānī who lives in the world without living for it

The Central Teaching

Running through all the many dialogues of the Mokshadharma Parva is one single teaching.

Bondage is false identification: The kshetrajña (the witness-awareness, the ātman) has wrongly taken itself to be the kshetra (the field of body, mind and world). This mistake, and no outer situation, is the only cause of suffering.

Vairāgya is the ground: Undoing this mistake begins with vairāgya, a deep seeing that all passing experience is impermanent. This is not just an idea one holds. It is a living understanding that grows from careful observation.

Jñāna is the tool: The jñāna (knowledge) that ends bondage is not just learning from books. It is viveka-jñāna, direct discernment that tells apart the unchanging kshetrajña from the changing kshetra.

Śānti is the result: One who has let go of the false identification rests in śānti, the natural, unconditional peace of the ātman that knows itself. This śānti cannot be shaken by the ups and downs of outer fortune, as Prahlāda, Bali and Namuci showed in their meetings with Indra.

Per Vishṇu Purāṇa

Chapter 5 of the Shashṭhāṃśa (sixth part) of the Vishṇu Purāṇa gives a detailed and vivid account of why moksha is the only true refuge. It starts from the three tāpas (kinds of suffering) and shows the way through them to ātyantika laya: the complete and permanent ending of the jīva’s seeming separateness.

The Three Tāpas

Parāśara Ṛshi teaches that seeing the tāpatraya, the three kinds of suffering, gives rise to vairāgya (detachment). Vairāgya leads to jñāna (knowledge), and jñāna leads to moksha. The three are:

Ādhyātmika (arising from within oneself): illnesses of the body (fevers, śūla, gulma, skin diseases and many others) and troubles of the mind (kāma, śoka, asūyā, avamāna, īrshyā, mātsarya: desire, grief, envy, humiliation, jealousy and spite).

Ādhibhautika (arising from other beings): the harm and trouble caused by animals, birds, humans, piśācas, serpents and rākshasas.

Ādhidaivika (arising from nature and fate): suffering from cold, wind, heat, rain, lightning and all the forces of nature.

Garbha-Duḥkha: The Suffering of the Womb

The Purāṇa paints one of its most vivid pictures of the pain of saṃsāra in its account of garbha-duḥkha, the suffering in the womb. The jīva enters a womb in a body that is extremely tender and sensitive. It is shut inside the belly, wrapped in a membrane, and pressed together with its spine, neck and bones bent. It is tormented by the very sour, sharp and hot food the mother eats, which causes it great pain. It cannot stretch or bend its limbs freely. It lies in a pool of urine, filth, blood and other waste, bitten by tiny creatures it cannot drive away, breathing with great difficulty, and aware through all of this. It remembers many past births and the karma that has brought it here.

At birth the jīva comes out with its face smeared with urine, filth, blood and fluids. It is squeezed by the winds of birth and comes out head-down in agony, falling to the earth in a daze. Struck by the outside air, it loses awareness. Once born, it cannot move, cannot brush away the insects and ants that bite it, lies in wet and dirty wrappings, gets food only when others choose, and suffers all the ādhibhautika troubles of infancy, completely helpless.

Old age brings its own list of troubles. The body’s strength is gone. The hair turns grey. The eyes grow weak and sink inward. Hair grows from the nose and ears. The neck trembles, every bone stands out, and the back is bent. The digestive fire is gone, so there is little appetite and little strength to act. Rising, sitting and lying down are all hard. Every sense fails. Saliva gathers at the mouth. One depends on servants, children and a spouse who themselves grow impatient, and one remembers the past with longing and regret.

At death the limbs and neck go limp. Clear moments and confusion come and go. There is the pain of Yama‘s messengers binding the jīva with ropes and beating it with sticks, the terrifying sight of the Yamadūtas, and the agony of the yātanā body (the body made for suffering) as it enters the realm of naraka.

In naraka there is being tied with nooses, struck with clubs, cut with saws, crushed with pestles, split with axes and buried alive, sufferings too many to list. Even in svarga (the realm of joy) there is the constant fear of falling, since the merit that brought one there will one day run out. No state that depends on conditions, however high, is a true refuge.

Parā and Aparā Vidyā

The Purāṇa then quotes the Muṇḍaka Upanishad, a text of the Atharva Veda, to set out the two kinds of knowledge (vidyā):

Aparā vidyā (lower knowledge): the Ṛg, Yajur, Sāma and Atharva Vedas, with all their supporting branches (śikshā, kalpa, vyākaraṇa, nirukta, chandas and jyotisha, that is, pronunciation, ritual, grammar, word meaning, metre and astronomy). This whole body of Vedic ritual knowledge is aparā vidyā. It is the path of action and merit, and it brings good things that do not last.

Parā vidyā (higher knowledge): the knowledge that reveals the imperishable Brahman. Its object, Parabrahman, is avyakta (unmanifest), ajara (never ageing), acintya (beyond thought), avyaya (never used up), anirdeśya (beyond description) and arūpa (without form). It has no hands or feet. It is sarvagata (everywhere), satya (true), bhūtayoni (the source of all beings) and vyāpya (both filling all and filled). This highest reality is seen directly only by the śūra, the spiritually brave.

That highest reality (parā-tattva) is Bhagavān Vishṇu himself.

The Definition of Bhagavān Vāsudeva

The chapter ends with the Purāṇa’s most exact definition of Bhagavān Vāsudeva. He is the one who knows the arising and the ending of all beings, their coming and going, their bondage and their freedom: both vidyā (knowledge) and avidyā (ignorance). He is free of every heya guṇa (unwanted quality). He has the six divine qualities: jñāna (knowledge), śakti (power), bala (strength), aiśvarya (sovereignty), vīrya (valour) and tejas (splendour). That supreme reality, the Paramātmā in whom all beings arise and into whom all return, is Vāsudeva.

Per Garuḍa Purāṇa

The last two chapters (48–49) of the Dharma Khaṇḍa of the Garuḍa Purāṇa give the final teaching of the whole Preta Kalpa, the section on what happens after death. Before this, the text describes in great detail the suffering of the preta (the newly departed jīva), the terrors of the Yama-mārga (the road to Yama‘s realm), the pains of naraka (the realms of suffering), and how nothing in this changing world lasts.

Then Bhagavān Vishṇu turns to Garuḍa with the hopeful teaching of moksha-dharma. It explains the true nature of the jīva (the individual self), the nature of saṃsāra, the way out of the cycle, and the highest goal of human birth.

The Jīva as a Part of Brahman

The teaching begins by declaring that the jīva is, in its true nature, an aṃśa (a part, portion or ray) of the Supreme Brahman. Here Brahman is identified with Śiva and Vishṇu as the one reality without a second. Being a part does not mean that the jīva, while caught in saṃsāra, is the same as Brahman. Think of a spark: it is part of the fire, yet it is still a separate spark. In the same way the jīva truly is a portion of Brahman, while for now it appears as a separate, bound being.

The jīva is bound because it is wrapped in the sūkshma-śarīra (subtle body). This subtle body is made of the five tanmātras (subtle elements), the five jñānendriyas (senses of knowing), the five karmendriyas (organs of action), and the manas, buddhi, ahaṃkāra and citta (the mind, intellect, sense of “I”, and memory). It carries all the saṃskāras (deep impressions) gathered over countless past lives, and it is the vehicle in which the jīva passes from one birth to the next. The subtle body is not the self. It is the garment the self wears on the long journey of saṃsāra.

The Eighty-Four Lakh Yonis

Before the jīva reaches human birth, it passes through 84 lakh (8.4 million) yonis, or kinds of birth. This number stands for every possible form of life, from the simplest plant to the most developed animal. They are spread across:

  • Sthāvara (beings that cannot move): rocks, plants and trees, making up most of the lower yonis
  • Jalaja (water-born): fish and water creatures of every kind
  • Kīṭa (insects and worms): all small creatures
  • Pakshī (birds): the beings of the air
  • Paśu (animals): land animals, growing more complex step by step
  • Manushya (human): the highest form in this series

The Dharma Khaṇḍa teaches that each birth in a lower yoni uses up some karma and develops some part of awareness. The fish learns movement and direction. The animal learns to live in a group. The bird learns to reach for the heights. Each yoni is both a cleansing and a lesson.

Human birth comes at the end of this huge journey. It is not the beginning but the fruit of millions of rounds of experience. To waste a human life only on the pleasures of the senses is therefore not just unlucky but deeply foolish. It is like a student who has finished twelve years of hard schooling, reached the gates of the university, and then turned round to play in the dirt.

Human Birth as the Staircase to Moksha

The Dharma Khaṇḍa calls human birth moksha-sopāna, “the staircase to moksha”. The key verse says:

Labdhvā sudurlabham idaṃ bahu-sambhavānte mānushyam arthadam anityam apīha dhīraḥ / tūrṇaṃ yateta na pated anumṛtyu yāvan niḥśreyasāya vishayaḥ khalu sarvataḥ syāt

“Having gained, after many births, this rare human life, which can bring the highest good though it does not last, the wise person should strive quickly, before death comes again. For the pleasures of the senses are found in every kind of birth.”

The point is not that human birth is a goal in itself. It is the only birth in which tattva-vicāra (telling the real from the unreal) is possible. Animals cannot perform yajña (fire offering). Rocks cannot recite mantra. Fish cannot practise vairāgya (detachment). Only a human jīva has all the tools needed for moksha: śravaṇa (hearing the teaching), manana (thinking it over) and nididhyāsana (meditating on it).

Teachings on Impermanence

The closing chapter of the Dharma Khaṇḍa contains a striking series of ślokas (verses) on impermanence. Each gives a vivid picture of how everything in this changing world passes away:

  • “As a bubble on water forms and bursts in a moment, so is human life: seen for an instant, then gone.”
  • “Like a flame in the wind, like dew at dawn, like the tide of a river that rises and falls: such is the life of every changing being.”
  • “The body you have dressed in clothes and jewels will become food for worms. The wealth you gathered with such effort will be shared out by strangers. The family you built will scatter like seeds in the wind. What, then, is truly yours?”
  • “The king who ruled in splendour yesterday is a preta today. The merchant who counted gold this morning has no hands to count with by evening. The young man who mocked old age is old before he has finished mocking.”

These pictures are not meant to cause despair. They are meant to awaken viveka (discernment): the understanding that one’s attention and effort should be given to what lasts (sat) rather than to what passes (asat).

Tattva-Jñāna: True Knowledge

The highest teaching at the end of the Dharma Khaṇḍa is tattva-jñāna, the direct knowledge of reality:

The Real (Sat): Brahman alone is real. It is unborn, unchanging, everywhere, shining by its own light, and beyond the reach of words and ideas.

The Unreal (Asat): The whole world of nāma-rūpa (name and form), including the body, the mind, relationships and everything we experience, comes and goes. So it does not have final reality.

The Jīva: The jīva, in its true nature as a part of Brahman, is real. But the jīva’s belief that it is the body and mind (“I am this body, these relationships, this history”) is the root of saṃsāra.

Moksha: The jīva may come to know its oneness with Brahman through the grace of a guru, through sincere bhakti (loving devotion), and through the practice of tattva-vicāra. Then the gathered saṃskāras dissolve, the subtle body no longer binds, and the jīva rests in its own nature as Brahman. This is moksha. The jīva does not go somewhere new; it recognises what it always was.

The Place of Bhakti

The Dharma Khaṇḍa uses the language of both jñāna (knowledge) and karma-kāṇḍa (Vedic rites) throughout. But its final teaching leans toward a joining of bhakti and Vedānta: the most direct path to moksha is bhakti to Bhagavān Nārāyaṇa. Such bhakti:

  • Loosens the hold of the ego naturally, through love rather than hard tapas
  • Calls down Bhagavān Nārāyaṇa’s grace, which adds to and goes beyond a person’s own limited power to discern
  • Makes sure that at the moment of death, the crucial turning point, the name of Hari is present, turning the departing jīva onto the devayāna (the bright path of the devas)

The teaching ends with Bhagavān Vishṇu‘s promise to Garuḍa: “Those who hear this Dharma Khaṇḍa with understanding will not return to the cycle of birth and death after finishing the karma of their present life. Hearing this teaching is itself a form of bhakti.” This shows the whole Preta Kalpa, with all its fearful accounts of the preta’s suffering, of naraka and of Yama‘s judgment, to be in the end a work of moksha. Its purpose is to turn the listener’s heart toward what lasts.

Per Agni Purāṇa

In the Agni Purāṇa, Agni-deva tells the Mahābhārata in brief. After the war at Kurukshetra, Yudhishṭhira comforted the grieving women and, with Bhīma and his other brothers, performed the funeral rites for all the fallen heroes. Then, from Bhīshma, son of Śantanu, he heard all the dharmas that bring peace: the rājadharmas (the dharma of kings), the mokshadharmas and the dānadharmas (the dharma of giving). Having heard them, he became king.

Source: Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 14

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa

The question of the Sanakādis

Śrī Kṛshṇa tells Uddhava that Sanaka, Sanandana and the other mind-born sons of Brahmā once asked their father about the subtle final limit of yoga: “O Prabhu Brahmā! The mind is attached to the objects such as sound, which are products of the guṇas, and the objects are attached to the mind. For the sādhaka who wishes to cross the ocean of saṃsāra and seeks moksha, what is the means by which they let go of each other?” Brahmā, the Deva of devas, Svayambhū, the creator of beings, thought on it, and could not reach the root of the doubt in the question. Wishing to know the answer, he meditated on Śrī Kṛshṇa, and Śrī Kṛshṇa came to him in the form of a haṃsa, a swan; as a haṃsa separates milk from water, so in his teaching he separated the Ātmā from the guṇas. The Sanakādis came near, bowed at his feet, and with Brahmā before them asked: “Who are you?”

The teaching of Haṃsa

“O maharshis! When the Ātmā is not many, how can this question be fitting? Taking what as my basis should I answer it?” The five bhūtas are the same in all bodies, so the question rests only on the usage of words, not on a real thing. All that is grasped by the mind, by speech, by sight and the other senses is Śrī Hari himself; there is nothing apart from him. The mind enters the objects and the objects enter the mind, but the Ātmā of the jīva is Śrī Hari himself; the mind and the objects are only an upādhi of the jīva, not its nature. So the sādhaka, established in the Ātmā and meditating on him, must give up both.

Waking, dream and deep sleep are only states that arise in the buddhi through the guṇas; the jīva is their witness and is distinct from them. Bondage is the Ātmā’s identification with the wandering buddhi. The Ātmā is the fourth (turīya), beyond the three states; by steadfastness in the Ātmā, freedom comes at once from both the objects and the citta. Ahaṅkāra, pride in the body, is the bondage that spoils the goal of life; the sādhaka should become dispassionate, stand in the Ātmā, and give up the saṅkalpas that bring saṃsāra. As long as the idea that the manifoldness of the world is real does not leave, a person is as if dreaming even when awake. Apart from the Ātmā there are in truth no distinctions such as deva and human, and karma and its lokas such as svarga are imagined for the Ātmā as they are for a dreamer.

The Ātmā is the witness of the three states: as viśva it enjoys the outer world in waking, as taijasa it enjoys in the heart in dream, as prājña it withdraws all into itself in sleep; and the Ātmā that runs through all three as memory is non-dual. Hearing the teachings of the sat-purushas and practising the discrimination of Ātmā and non-Ātmā, the sādhaka sharpens the sword of discriminating knowledge and cuts all doubts, the diseases of the mind, and worships Śrī Hari, who dwells in the heart. The world is momentary, whirling like a firebrand, the play of the mind; the one consciousness appears as many.

One who dwells on the bliss of the Ātmā gives up the hope of enjoyments and does no karma for fruits. As a drunkard does not care whether his cloth is on or has slipped off, so the one steadfast in the Ātmā takes no notice of whether the body, moved by prārabdha karma, sits, stands, goes or comes. The body lasts as long as the karma that made it lasts; the jñānī does not again take up “mine” towards the dream-like world or “I” in the body.

Śrī Hari, the form of yajña

“O maharshis! I have taught you the secret of jñāna-yoga and karma-yoga. Know me to be Śrī Hari, the form of yajña, who came wishing to teach you the dharma of moksha. I am the great support of karma-yoga, jñāna-yoga, satya, the dharma enjoined by the Veda, sweet speech, tejas, wealth, fame and the restraint of the senses, and I am also their fruit. I, who am nirguṇa, have no need of anything; I, who do good to all, am the Ātmā, the treasury of love. Equanimity, non-attachment, satya and all the other virtues serve me.”

So the doubts of the Sanakādis were scattered. With great bhakti they worshipped and praised him, and while Brahmā looked on, Bhagavān Śrī Hari returned to his own dhāma.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13

Moksha, the one purpose of the Bhāgavata

Moksha is the thread of the whole Bhāgavata Purāṇa. Sūta Maharshi, closing it, says that the Upanishads teach the oneness of Brahman and the pratyag-ātmā, that the Bhāgavata is devoted to that truth without a second, and that its one and only purpose is moksha (Skandha 12, Chapter 13). The text also calls it the parama-pada, the place of fearlessness and the kshema (welfare) not bounded by time.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 12, Chapter 13

What moksha is

Śuka Maharshi defines moksha as the cessation of the mind’s constructions (Skandha 10, Chapter 87). Śrī Kṛshṇa tells Uddhava that as the sunrise removes darkness without creating things, realisation removes ajñāna: moksha does not come anew; one’s own nature is moksha (Skandha 11, Chapter 28). Brahmā, praising the child Kṛshṇa, says that bondage and moksha are names born of ignorance and do not exist apart from the ātmā, as night and day do not exist in the Sun (Skandha 10, Chapter 14); and Akrūra says to Śrī Kṛshṇa that in the ātmā there is no birth and no difference, so for him there is neither bondage nor moksha (Skandha 10, Chapter 48). Dattātreya Maharshi, answering Prahlāda, calls moksha becoming one with the Parabrahman who is the ātmā of all (Skandha 7, Chapter 13); Śuka says that in moksha the jīva merges in Īśvara (Skandha 10, Chapter 12). Bhagavān Kapila teaches that the liṅga-śarīra, the subtle body, stays with the jīva until moksha (Skandha 3, Chapter 31), and that moksha is the highest purushārtha (Skandha 3, Chapter 27). Sanatkumāra tells Pṛthu that dharma, artha and kāma are subject to the fear of Kāla and are not eternal, while moksha is eternal and highest (Skandha 4, Chapter 22). The maharshis declare that the moksha attained by those who give up harm and all possessions, calm and equal-minded and doing good to others, is Śrī Hari himself (Skandha 10, Chapter 89), and Prahlāda calls Śrī Hari the bliss of moksha (Skandha 7, Chapter 7).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 3, Chapters 27, 31; Skandha 4, Chapter 22; Skandha 7, Chapters 7, 13; Skandha 10, Chapters 12, 14, 48, 87, 89; Skandha 11, Chapter 28

The giver of moksha

Brahmā tells Nārada that Śrī Hari, imperishable and beyond the perishable fruit of karma, grants moksha, the place of fearlessness (Skandha 2, Chapter 6). When the devas offered Mucukunda a vara, they told him to ask anything but moksha, for only Śrī Hari, who is beyond Time, can give it (Skandha 10, Chapter 51). Pṛthu teaches that there must be one ruler who grants dharma, artha, kāma, the puṇya-lokas and moksha to each by his fitness, and that is Śrī Hari who bears the gadā (Skandha 4, Chapter 21). The ṛtvijas of Nābhi‘s yajña praise him as the one who, like a father, grants both desires and moksha (Skandha 5, Chapter 3); Ṛshabha is the Īśvara who gives svarga and moksha (Skandha 5, Chapter 5). Brahmā tells the devas that Bhagavān Śiva grants moksha to those who act without desire (Skandha 4, Chapter 6), and Bhagavān Vishṇu, at Daksha‘s yajña, declares that the nature of Brahmā, Vishṇu, Rudra and the ātmā of all beings is one, and that one who knows this attains moksha (Skandha 4, Chapter 7). He who grants everything from moksha downward became the son of Devakī (Skandha 10, Chapter 6), and Nalakūbara and Maṇigrīva praise him as the master of the purushārthas, descended for the welfare and moksha of all (Skandha 10, Chapter 10). Again and again Śrī Kṛshṇa is called moksha-pradātā, the giver of moksha: by the gopīs at his departure for Mathurā (Skandha 10, Chapter 39); by Varuṇa, who says that those who take refuge at his feet reach the far shore of saṃsāra (Skandha 10, Chapter 28); by Kuntī, who says that for men who fear saṃsāra there is no protection but his moksha-giving lotus feet (Skandha 10, Chapter 49); and by Rukmiṇī, who asks that his feet be her refuge in the stream of birth and death. Śrī Kṛshṇa answers her that desires directed to him give moksha, not bondage (Skandha 10, Chapter 60).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapter 6; Skandha 4, Chapters 6–7, 21; Skandha 5, Chapters 3, 5; Skandha 10, Chapters 6, 10, 28, 39, 49, 51, 60

The means: bhakti, jñāna and yoga

The Bhāgavata names many means to moksha, and bhakti above all. One who seeks moksha must hear about, sing of and remember Śrī Vishṇu alone, and the elders decided that hari-nāma-saṅkīrtana is the best means for those seeking moksha and those seeking enjoyments alike (Skandha 2, Chapter 1). Whether desireless, desiring all or desiring moksha, a person of lofty buddhi should worship Śrī Hari with intense bhakti-yoga; the company of his devotees gives steady bhakti, which gives moksha, and the mahātmās declare bhakti-yoga the path of moksha (Skandha 2, Chapter 3). Śrī Hari tells Brahmā that the sādhana a person does for śreyas reaches its fulfilment in his darśana (Skandha 2, Chapter 9), and that the moment a man sees him, distinct from the elements, the senses, the guṇas and the antaḥkaraṇa, as the Parabrahma one with the inner self, he is established in the empire of moksha (Skandha 3, Chapter 9).

Bhagavān Kapila teaches Devahūti that ātma-nishṭhā is the means to moksha, giving lasting release from pleasure and pain; that the mind is the cause of both bondage and moksha, binding when attached to enjoyments and freeing when it has bhakti for Parameśvara; and that bhakti is greater even than moksha (Skandha 3, Chapter 25). His jñāna unties the knot of ajñāna in the heart and brings ātma-sākshātkāra and moksha (Skandha 3, Chapter 26); the yogī not attached to siddhis gains moksha and merges into him (Skandha 3, Chapter 27). Jaḍabharata tells Rahūgaṇa that the mind, purified and merged in the ātmā, is the cause of moksha (Skandha 5, Chapter 11). Prabuddha tells Nimi that moksha from ātma-jñāna is the highest good, and that the seeker must take refuge in a guru (Skandha 11, Chapter 3). Viśvāmitra, pleased with Hariścandra‘s truth, gave him ātma-jñāna, which gives the fruit of moksha (Skandha 9, Chapter 7). Śrī Kṛshṇa tells Uddhava that yoga gives the siddhis, but the moksha that yoga gives is not gained by other means (Skandha 11, Chapter 15); that men gain moksha by jñāna, dharma by karma, kāma by yoga and artha by trade and daṇḍanīti, but for Uddhava he himself is all four (Skandha 11, Chapter 29); and that the jīva who conquers the guṇas by bhakti-yoga becomes fit for his svarūpa (Skandha 11, Chapter 25). By kriyā-yoga a mortal gains amṛtatva (Skandha 12, Chapter 11).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapters 1, 3, 9; Skandha 3, Chapters 9, 25–27; Skandha 5, Chapter 11; Skandha 9, Chapter 7; Skandha 11, Chapters 3, 15, 25, 29; Skandha 12, Chapter 11

The Name and the remembrance of Śrī Hari

The holy Name and the remembrance of Śrī Hari open the same door. Śuka Maharshi, closing the account of Ajāmila, says that for seekers of moksha there is no greater means to cut the bond of karma than ceaselessly praising Śrī Hari, for other means leave the mind stained by rajas and tamas; Ajāmila, ready to be thrown into naraka, uttered the name and at once attained moksha, and one who utters Śrī Hari’s name with śraddhā surely gains it (Skandha 6, Chapter 2). For seekers of moksha who hear of and meditate on Ananta, he appears in the heart and uproots the knot of ignorance (Skandha 5, Chapter 25). Whoever sets up Bhagavān Kṛshṇa‘s mūrti in the heart by dhyāna even once is given the moksha of the devotees (Skandha 10, Chapter 12). Uddhava tells Nanda that one who at death fixes the mind on the Paramātmā has his karma burned at once, attains moksha and merges in the self-luminous Parabrahma (Skandha 10, Chapter 46); the yogī who fixes his buddhi on moksha breaks through the brahmarandhra and becomes one with the Paramātmā (Skandha 2, Chapter 2); and Śuka tells Parīkshit, as death nears, to set Śrī Hari firmly in his heart and attain the highest moksha (Skandha 12, Chapter 3).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapter 2; Skandha 5, Chapter 25; Skandha 6, Chapter 2; Skandha 10, Chapters 12, 46; Skandha 12, Chapter 3

The company of the great, svadharma and dāna

The company and service of the great is a door. Pṛthu says that constant service of the knowers of Brahman soon purifies the mind and brings moksha of itself (Skandha 4, Chapter 21). Ṛshabha tells his sons that service of mahātmās is the door to moksha (Skandha 5, Chapter 5). The devas sing that firm company with Purushottama’s devotees makes bhakti for Vāsudeva steady, without thirst for other fruits, and that is the very mark of moksha; such bhakti cuts the knot of ajñāna that gives the jīva its many births. They say too that the people of every varṇa, doing their own duties, may attain moksha (Skandha 5, Chapter 19). Gaya‘s svadharma, offered to Bhagavān Vishṇu, led to moksha (Skandha 5, Chapter 15). Bali‘s gift to Bhagavān Vāmana was the door to moksha, for a dāna made to Śrī Hari with the sense of the ātmā has moksha as its fruit (Skandha 5, Chapter 24). In the purified citta of the paramahaṃsas, the devas say, the doors of ajñāna open and Śrī Hari appears (Skandha 6, Chapter 9). Sunīti tells Dhruva that Svāyambhuva Manu, worshipping Śrī Hari with yajñas, gained the rule of his manvantara, the happiness of svarga and moksha; and Nārada tells him that the devotee with vairāgya should serve Śrī Hari directly, with unbroken loving bhakti, for moksha (Skandha 4, Chapter 8). Dhruva, after his darśana, grieves that he asked for a high position from the Īśvara who gives the empire of moksha, like a pauper begging grains of rice (Skandha 4, Chapter 9). Kardama prays that the enjoyments Śrī Hari spreads by māyā lead him in the end to his grace, which is moksha (Skandha 3, Chapter 21). Brahmā says that one who waits for Śrī Kṛshṇa‘s grace, bears the fruits of past karma and offers himself shares in moksha as a son in his father’s property (Skandha 10, Chapter 14). Vāmana tells Bali that discontent with artha and kāma drives one into saṃsāra, and contentment with what comes by Īśvara’s will leads to moksha (Skandha 8, Chapter 19).

Dattātreya also tells Prahlāda that the human birth is the door to svarga by puṇya, to moksha by ātma-jñāna, to animal births by pāpa and to a human birth again by both (Skandha 7, Chapter 13). Nārada teaches Yudhishṭhira that one who gives up “mine” in what remains attains ātma-sākshātkāra (Skandha 7, Chapter 14); and that even wild-rice food offered to Śrī Hari and given with śraddhā to a worthy person at the right place and time leads to moksha, while the ishṭa and pūrta karmas of the foolish only keep saṃsāra going, as farming does. Nivṛtti dharma gives moksha; by the Devayāna the sādhaka steadfast in the ātmā gains moksha in the Satyaloka and is not born again; and one who worships Bhagavān Vishṇu with bhakti while doing his Veda-enjoined karmas reaches Īśvara’s svarūpa even as a gṛhastha (Skandha 7, Chapter 15).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 3, Chapter 21; Skandha 4, Chapters 8–9, 21; Skandha 5, Chapters 5, 15, 19, 24; Skandha 6, Chapter 9; Skandha 7, Chapters 13–15; Skandha 8, Chapter 19; Skandha 10, Chapter 14

Strive before the body falls

Dattātreya tells King Yadu that the wise should strive quickly for moksha before the body falls, and not waste it on sense-enjoyments, which animals and birds also have (Skandha 11, Chapter 9). Prahlāda tells the asura boys that one who runs after enjoyments cannot reach the feet of Śrī Hari, the giver of moksha, and that a skilful man should strive for moksha before disease takes the body (Skandha 7, Chapter 6). Śrī Kṛshṇa tells Uddhava that, knowing the body to be a means but mortal, one should strive for moksha before death (Skandha 11, Chapter 20); that the true paṇḍita is one who knows bondage and moksha, not one who recites śāstras (Skandha 11, Chapter 19); and that the all-knowing Veda would never set those who do not know moksha back on the road of saṃsāra: its intent is not in kāmya karmas (Skandha 11, Chapter 21). The seeker of moksha, even if reviled, mocked, beaten or bound by the wicked, must lift himself up and not slip from his sādhana (Skandha 11, Chapter 22). The brāhmaṇa of Avanti, in his song, says that the seeker of moksha should keep far from wealth, the root of all calamities; that the human birth is the door to svarga and moksha; and that he will cross the shoreless ocean of saṃsāra only by service to the feet of Śrī Hari, giver of moksha (Skandha 11, Chapter 23). Nārada tells Prācīnabarhis that the gṛhastha deluded into thinking children, wife and wealth are the purushārthas wanders in saṃsāra and does not gain moksha (Skandha 4, Chapter 25); Saubhari says that the seeker of moksha should give up the company of those in married life (Skandha 9, Chapter 6); and the Earth sings that moksha, not the earth, is the fruit of mastering the senses (Skandha 12, Chapter 3). Parīkshit says that among those who practise dharma few desire moksha, and among thousands who desire it only one is freed (Skandha 6, Chapter 14).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 4, Chapter 25; Skandha 6, Chapter 14; Skandha 7, Chapter 6; Skandha 9, Chapter 6; Skandha 11, Chapters 9, 19–23; Skandha 12, Chapter 3

Those who attained moksha

At Parīkshit‘s birth the brāhmaṇas foretold that he would hear ātma-jñāna from Śuka, leave his body on the bank of the Gaṅgā and attain moksha, the unbounded place of fearlessness (Skandha 1, Chapter 12); the ṛshis resolved to stay with him until he reached the loka beyond the three guṇas, and he asked Śuka what one about to die should do who seeks moksha (Skandha 1, Chapter 19). The Pāṇḍavas, their hearts absorbed in Nārāyaṇa‘s feet, attained the goal that those attached to the senses cannot reach (Skandha 1, Chapter 15). Ṛshabha, living as a householder, attained dharma, wealth, fame, progeny and moksha (Skandha 5, Chapter 4), and the purpose of his avatāra was to teach the path of moksha (Skandha 5, Chapter 6). Kapila promised his mother that by the path he taught she would soon attain moksha (Skandha 3, Chapter 33). Nārada gave Citraketu a mantra that is a means to moksha and told him he would soon attain the glory of Saṅkarshaṇa, than which there is no higher goal (Skandha 6, Chapter 15). Yuvanāśva performed tapas and attained moksha; Saubhari merged his sense of a separate jīva in the Paramātmā, and his wives, seeing it, followed him as flames merge into a fire that has gone out (Skandha 9, Chapter 6); Sagara, free of desire, followed Aurva‘s teaching and attained moksha (Skandha 9, Chapter 8). Śrī Kṛshṇa told Devakī and Vasudeva that as Pṛśni and Sutapas, deluded by his māyā, they had not asked for moksha, and that loving him as son and as Parabrahma they would attain his supreme nature (Skandha 10, Chapter 3). Moksha is impossible for the wicked, yet by touching Śrī Kṛshṇa the pāpas of Agha were washed away and he attained moksha (Skandha 10, Chapter 12). Śrī Kṛshṇa, Bhīma and Arjuna, coming to Jarāsandha as brāhmaṇas, named Hariścandra, Rantideva, Mudgala, Śibi, Bali, the hunter and the pigeon as those who gave up impermanent life and attained permanent moksha (Skandha 10, Chapter 72). Śrutadeva and Bahulāśva, worshipping Śrī Kṛshṇa and the maharshis as one ātmā, attained the goal of the good (Skandha 10, Chapter 86). Śrī Kṛshṇa’s wives, by their undivided love for him, attained the supreme fruit of moksha, and seeking it great kings gave up their kingdoms for the forest (Skandha 10, Chapter 90).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 1, Chapters 12, 15, 19; Skandha 3, Chapter 33; Skandha 5, Chapters 4, 6; Skandha 6, Chapter 15; Skandha 9, Chapters 6, 8; Skandha 10, Chapters 3, 12, 72, 86, 90

The bhakta who does not seek moksha

The highest bhaktas do not ask even for moksha. The ṛshis tell Sūta that neither svarga nor moksha without rebirth equals a moment’s company of Vishṇu‘s devotees (Skandha 1, Chapter 18), and the Pracetas say the same (Skandha 4, Chapter 30). The Sanaka ṛshis, in Vaikuṇṭha, praise Śrī Hari’s bhaktas who care not even for moksha, much less for the posts of Indra and the rest (Skandha 3, Chapter 15). Śuka says that Śrī Kṛshṇa gives his devotees even moksha but does not easily give bhakti-yoga, and that his devotees show no regard for moksha even when it comes of itself (Skandha 5, Chapter 6); to those whose minds love the service of Śrī Hari, even moksha without rebirth is small (Skandha 5, Chapter 14). Vṛtra, facing Indra’s vajra, said it would cut his noose of attachment and he would reach moksha, and prayed that apart from Śrī Hari he wanted neither svarga, nor Dhruva‘s place, nor Brahmā‘s, nor the yoga-siddhis, nor moksha (Skandha 6, Chapter 11). Prahlāda said: “We shall serve Śrī Hari’s feet and sing his glory; what need have we of dharma, artha and kāma, or even of moksha beyond the guṇas?” (Skandha 7, Chapter 6). Before Bhagavān Narasiṃha he asked only to be taught his service as the means to moksha, and said that while maharshis often seek their own moksha in solitude, he would not gain moksha alone and leave the afflicted behind (Skandha 7, Chapter 9). Śrī Kṛshṇa tells Uddhava that one whose mind is offered to him desires nothing but him, not Brahmā’s position, not Devendra’s seat, not rule of the world, not the siddhis, not even moksha (Skandha 11, Chapter 14); that no fruit but he, neither svarga nor moksha, is dear to the jñānī (Skandha 11, Chapter 19); and that his single-pointed bhaktas do not desire moksha without rebirth even when he gives it (Skandha 11, Chapter 20).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 1, Chapter 18; Skandha 3, Chapter 15; Skandha 4, Chapter 30; Skandha 5, Chapters 6, 14; Skandha 6, Chapter 11; Skandha 7, Chapters 6, 9; Skandha 11, Chapters 14, 19–20

Moksha in the phalaśrutis

Whoever hears with śraddhā the great departure of the Pāṇḍavas gains bhakti in Śrī Hari and attains moksha (Skandha 1, Chapter 15). Whoever, with mind fixed on Kapila, hears or tells his teaching with faith even once reaches his parama-pada (Skandha 3, Chapter 32). Whoever hears or causes others to hear Nārada‘s account of the ātma-tattva in the parable of Purañjana is released from the liṅga-śarīra (Skandha 4, Chapter 29). Whoever rises early and in silence, remembering Śrī Hari, reads the account of Vṛtra and Citraketu with śraddhā attains moksha, the highest purushārtha (Skandha 6, Chapter 17). One who hears and sings the accounts of Śrī Kṛshṇa attains his svarūpa and is freed from the speed of Kāla (Skandha 10, Chapter 90). And the Saptarshis honour the Gaṅgā as seekers of moksha would honour moksha come walking (Skandha 5, Chapter 17).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 1, Chapter 15; Skandha 3, Chapter 32; Skandha 4, Chapter 29; Skandha 5, Chapter 17; Skandha 6, Chapter 17; Skandha 10, Chapter 90

Per Brahma Purāṇa

Moksha, the final fruit, won from Bhārata

The land of Bhārata is the karma-bhūmi, the land of action, and svarga and moksha are both there for those who seek them. From Bhārata alone beings attain svarga and moksha, and from there too they fall into births as animals and birds, and into naraka. Svarga is the intermediate fruit of karma, and moksha the final (ātyantika) fruit; both are attained from here alone.

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Chapter 19

The ātyantika laya and the medicine for the three tāpas

Vyāsa tells the munis that the discerning jīva, seeing the suffering and the fault that come from the three kinds of tāpa (affliction), ādhyātmika, ādhibhautika and ādhidaivika, gains jñāna through vairāgya and so reaches the ātyantika laya, the final dissolution, which is moksha. In saṃsāra whatever is a cause of happiness is itself a cause of sorrow. So, not growing attached to wife, sons and wealth, seeing the faults of the three tāpas and striving for mukti is the only medicine that removes this pain, and the discerning should strive for that alone. Karma and jñāna are both means to mukti, and jñāna is of two kinds: the upāsana of Śabda-brahman taught in the Āgama, and the knowledge of the Brahma-tattva born of discernment.

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Chapters 232, 234

Yoga, sāṅkhya and jñāna

When the maharshis ask for yoga, the medicine for the sorrow of saṃsāra, Vyāsa says: “One who practises yoga becomes a yogī and attains moksha, which is supremely hard to attain.” When the citta clings to no karma and reaches ānanda, the practitioner attains moksha-siddhi; but there is no moksha unless one knows that all but the Para-tattva is impermanent.

No one gains siddhi without jñāna, tapas, mastery of the senses and the giving up of all attachment. The path of the jñānīs cannot be seen, like the path of birds in the sky or of fish in the water. One who knows that as much ātmā as is in the forms of the visible world, just so much tattva is in the Paramātmā, attains deathlessness and moksha and becomes Brahman. Practising without a break for not less than six months, with an equal eye on praise and blame, gain and loss, clod and gold, “however low the birth, whether woman or man, they attain mukti”, and the wise who follow this path see Vāsudeva, unborn, ancient, eternal and beyond the senses, and become one with that Brahma-tattva.

Karma is the cause of bondage and vidyā the cause of mukti; so the munis who know the tattva do not perform karmas. By karma the purusha of sixteen tattvas dies and is born again; by vidyā he becomes of the form of the akshara and is freed. Merging the five senses into the mind, holding the mind in dhyāna on the Para-tattva and letting the senses rule him no longer, the one of peaceful mind is freed. As darkness goes and things are seen, so as ajñāna goes the ātmā is realised; and like a water-bird untouched by the water, the jīvanmukta yogī moves among sense objects untouched by their faults. This teaching of the tattva, which Varuṇa taught his son Bhṛgu, was brought out by the knowers of tattva as butter is churned from curds, to uplift the seekers of moksha. It must never be taught, even for the whole earth, to one without a calm mind, mastery of the senses, tapas and the other good marks, nor to one whose buddhi is spoiled by tarka, a tale-bearer or one who praises himself.

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Chapters 235–237

The one dharma of moksha

The munis asked Vyāsa for the highest tattva and the dharma better than all dharmas. Vyāsa said: “I shall tell you the dharma that is most ancient, praised by the ṛshis, and best of all dharmas.” The senses trouble the jīva; holding them in check with buddhi, as a father holds his young sons, one should know that dharma by the highest tapas, the one-pointedness of the senses and the mind. When the senses turn back from every object, the eternal Paramātmā is realised. Like a tree that does not know where each of its fruits and leaves is, the jīva in the many things of saṃsāra does not know “Who am I? Where did I come from? Where must I go?”; but lighting the lamp of jñāna, he sees himself in himself. So take up vairāgya first, and cast off pāpas as a snake casts its slough.

The world’s course is a terrible river without beginning, born of the avyakta and of kāma, of great speed, flowing into the ocean of saṃsāra and down into the pātāla of the chain of births. The senses are its crocodiles, the mind’s saṅkalpas its banks, greed and delusion the grass that covers it, kāma and krodha the snakes in it, satya the ghāṭ for bathing, falsehood its waves, krodha its mud and the restlessness of the tongue its whirlpools. Only the wise can cross it. “This is the best dharma of all.” It is to be taught only to a devoted, close, pure-minded disciple, and to one’s son.

When the munis asked for the means to moksha laid down by Svayambhū, Vyāsa said that discerning knowledge (viveka-jñāna) is the right means. One who needs a pot must get that one right pot and need not learn about every pot in the world; so the seeker of moksha needs to know only the moksha-dharma. The road that leads to the eastern ocean does not lead to the western: the dharma that brings moksha is one only.

At the root of yoga one should conquer:

  1. krodha by forbearance;
  2. desires by giving up saṅkalpas;
  3. sleep by increase of sattva;
  4. fear by watchfulness;
  5. wanting, hatred and the drive of kāma by firmness of mind;
  6. dullness of buddhi by practising jñāna and viveka;
  7. troubles of body and mind by wholesome, light, measured food;
  8. greed and delusion by contentment;
  9. sense enjoyments by knowledge of tattva;
  10. adharma by compassion;
  11. the karmas of yajña and dāna by not seeking their fruit;
  12. craving by ayati;
  13. the burden of work by giving up attachment;
  14. love for the visible world by seeing it as impermanent;
  15. hunger by yoga;
  16. laziness by constant effort;
  17. doubts by certainty;
  18. babbling by silence;
  19. fear by courage.

Holding speech and mind by buddhi, and buddhi by the eye of jñāna, one gains the peace of the ātmā. Giving up the five faults of yoga, kāma, krodha, greed, fear and sleep, and keeping dhyāna, study, dāna, satya, modesty, straight conduct, forbearance, purity and mastery of the senses, one’s tejas grows, pāpa is destroyed, saṅkalpas are fulfilled, vijñāna unfolds, and at the end one enters the abode of Brahman. Freedom from delusion and attachment, giving up kāma and krodha, neither dejection nor arrogance, firmness without fear: this is the clear, stainless and pure path of moksha. Control of mind, speech and body is the rule that must never be broken.

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Chapter 238

The way of yoga and the way of sāṅkhya

Vyāsa teaches that by the sāṅkhya siddhānta one who knows all the courses of this world and their faults, and is free of attachment to sense objects, surely gains mukti after leaving the body; and that sāṅkhya and yoga are inseparable, both accepted by the good, and both give moksha when practised by the śāstra. Those who win the strength of yoga break the bonds of greed and reach the pure path of mukti; even Bhagavān Vishṇu, the giver of mukti, comes under the bond of a yogī whose yoga-śakti is firmly won. As a heedful archer strikes his target, the yogī who practises reaches moksha, “this is certain”; as one carries a full bowl of oil with an unmoving mind, the mumukshu climbs the ladder of yoga; as brāhmaṇas cross the ocean in a boat with a careful boatman, the yogī makes his mind collected by yoga and reaches moksha after leaving the body. Practising dhāraṇā, he burns mountain-heaps of good and bad karma, wins the highest siddhi and is freed at will; steady in dhāraṇā, he passes beyond birth, death and worldly pleasure and gains the bliss of moksha, and quickly reaches Nārāyaṇa.

In the way of sāṅkhya, knowing the tattvas and their merits and faults, the wise gain jñāna and vijñāna and reach the most auspicious moksha called niḥśreyasa. Sattva rests on the ātmā, the ātmā rests on Nārāyaṇa, Nārāyaṇa rests in moksha, and moksha has no support at all. By the śāstra one must know the karmas of the seeker of pleasure, the senses, and that moksha is hard to gain; that among thousands only one becomes a mumukshu, and that moksha won by the Vedas as pramāṇa is hard; and knowing all this, one must strive for moksha and gain it. The pure yatis rise to the pure-souled supreme Prabhu Nārāyaṇa, who takes them into his own form; they become deathless and do not come again into the round of births.

The munis then asked: “Do those who reach that state rejoice in moksha until Nārāyaṇa begins saṃsāra again? If they stay, who carries on the dharma of action in the world? If they come back, do they not come back into sorrow?” Vyāsa answered that, as the senses rest in the jīva in sleep and work again when it wakes, so the freed yatis who have gained sāyujya in Nārāyaṇa enter the dharma of creation again at the time of his creation. Fulfilled with sāyujya-moksha, they are born in the houses of the pure, and after leaving that body they gain moksha as before. For them there are only higher and higher courses; births as animals and dwelling in naraka do not come to them. “So fix your mind on Nārāyaṇa, the immeasurable; this beginningless world came forth from him alone.”

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Chapters 239–240

Moksha in the teaching of Vasishṭha to Janaka

In the dialogue of Vasishṭha and Janaka that Vyāsa tells, the mixing of puṇya and pāpa gives the human state, and puṇya alone gives the state of a deva; moksha is beyond all these and is won by jñāna alone. Janaka asks Vasishṭha: “Moksha comes from tattva-jñāna. We seek moksha; we wish to reach the supreme tattva that is free of ill, unconquerable, ageless, eternal, beyond the senses and with no ruler over it. Tell us the true tattva.”

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Chapters 241, 243

Bhakti, the Name and the pūjā of Vāsudeva

King Indradyumna bows to Bhagavān Vishṇu as the cause of moksha and asks for the supreme state on which those who know the path of moksha meditate. Maheśvara tells the munis that those who worship Vāsudeva, who bears the śaṅkha, cakra and gadā, in mind, speech and deed gain moksha. Dharma gives bhukti and mukti, and from dharma come artha, kāma and moksha too; and it is enough to utter the name of Hari once, even in enmity, to gain mukti, as Śiśupāla did. In the rite of the pañcatīrtha at Purushottama-kshetra, the bath at the Mārkaṇḍeya-hrada and the pūjā there end at last in moksha, and the prayer to the kalpa-vṛksha calls it the maker of the mahāpralaya, that is, the giver of mukti.

In the Gautamī Māhātmya, Bhagavān Vishṇu tells Maudgalya that holy rites purify a man, then he becomes detached, his knowledge becomes unobstructed and he is freed while living; through bhakti to Bhagavān Vishṇu moksha is easy for all, though bhakti alone does not bring worldly enjoyments. Maudgalya asked for moksha, saying it is rarer than enjoyments and more honoured; by dāna with the remembrance of Bhagavān Vishṇu and by the Gaṅgā he had both, and with his family he attained moksha together with his pitṛs. Bṛhaspati praises devotion to Bhagavān Śiva as the stairway to svarga and moksha.

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Chapters 51, 57, 216, 226; Gautamī Māhātmya, Chapters 52, 66

Karma, the debate of the ṛshis, and the guṇas

Mārkaṇḍeya, Bharadvāja, Vasishṭha, Atri, Gautama, Yājñavalkya, Jābāla and other ṛshis once discussed moksha among themselves, some praising jñāna, some karma, some both, and asked Brahmā and Bhagavān Vishṇu; Bhagavān Śiva decided that everything is gained through karma, and the place is the Mārkaṇḍeya-tīrtha. At Bhīmeśvara it is taught that karma sustained by bhāva is the cause of bondage and of moksha. Brahmā tells Nārada that by the guṇas the tīrthas, the varṇas, the Vedas, svarga and moksha arise or lose their power.

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Gautamī Māhātmya, Chapters 75, 103, 105

Moksha by the Gaṅgā

Indra tells Śacī that moksha may be hard in a householder’s life, but the three aims of dharma, artha and kāma are possible, and that a wife who seeks welfare in both worlds is the greatest friend; there is nothing like the Gaṅgā for moksha and release from pāpas, and nothing like knowing the non-difference of Bhagavān Śiva and Bhagavān Vishṇu for gaining dharma, artha, kāma and moksha. At Abjaka on the Gautamī, merely by bathing, all attain moksha with their pitṛs of five generations, and on the northern bank are seven thousand tīrthas that give moksha. At the end of the Gautamī Māhātmya Brahmā says: “This Gautamī grants moksha to all men who bathe in her, anywhere, at any time. That is by Śiva’s command.” Even the devas and dānavas, making peace before the churning, said that the joy of being free of enmity is not found in rule of the three worlds, nor in moksha; and Diti asked what use svarga, moksha or Brahmā’s place would be beside a virtuous, glorious and long-lived son.

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Gautamī Māhātmya, Chapters 36, 54, 59, 105

Sources

  • Mahābhārata, Śānti Parva, Mokshadharma Parva, Chapters 168–353
  • Mahābhārata, Śānti Parva, Chapters 168–173
  • Mahābhārata, Śānti Parva, Chapters 174–230
  • Vishṇu Purāṇa, Shashṭhāṃśa (Book 6), Chapter 5
  • Garuḍa Purāṇa, Dharma Khaṇḍa, Chapters 48–49
  • Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 14
  • Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 1, Chapters 12, 15, 18–19; Skandha 2, Chapters 1–3, 6, 9; Skandha 3, Chapters 9, 15, 21, 25–27, 31–33; Skandha 4, Chapters 6–9, 21–22, 25, 29–30; Skandha 5, Chapters 3–6, 11, 14–15, 17, 19, 24–25; Skandha 6, Chapters 2, 9, 11, 14–15, 17; Skandha 7, Chapters 6–7, 9, 13–15; Skandha 8, Chapter 19; Skandha 9, Chapters 6–8; Skandha 10, Chapters 3, 6, 10, 12, 14, 28, 39, 46, 48–49, 51, 60, 72, 86–87, 89–90; Skandha 11, Chapters 3, 9, 13–15, 19–23, 25, 28–29; Skandha 12, Chapters 3, 11, 13
  • Brahma Purāṇa, Chapters 19, 51, 57, 216, 226, 232, 234–241, 243; Gautamī Māhātmya, Chapters 36, 52, 54, 59, 66, 75, 103, 105