Jāti-Varṇa Nirṇaya
Jāti-Varṇa Nirṇaya · jāti-varṇa nirṇaya, “determining birth and varṇa”
Jāti means a birth-community, and varṇa means one of the four broad social roles: brāhmaṇa, kshatriya, vaiśya and śūdra. Nirṇaya means “deciding” or “settling”. Jāti-Varṇa Nirṇaya, “settling the question of jāti and varṇa”, is the subject of Chapter 10 of the Brahma Khaṇḍa of the Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa. The chapter explains the sacred origins of various communities through stories from the Purāṇas.
It tells how communities of craftspeople came from divine beings, namely the apsarā Ghṛtācī and the divine architect Viśvakarmā, who were cursed and born again on earth. It also discusses the principles behind the differences between jātis. A later part of the same Purāṇa, the Śrī Kṛshṇa Janma Khaṇḍa, adds Śrī Kṛshṇa’s teaching on the duties of each varṇa.
The Agni Purāṇa gives its own teaching in Chapter 151, where Pushkara teaches Paraśurāma the dharmas common to all people, the dharmas of each of the four varṇas, the meaning of anuloma and pratiloma unions, and the jātis born of mixed unions with the work of each. Its later chapters apply this teaching to the water offerings for the dead, to the fruit of dāna, to servitude and to the fines of the king’s court.
Overview
Chapter 10 of the Brahma Khaṇḍa takes up the complex question of jāti and varṇa from the view of the Purāṇas. It does not treat them only as social groupings. Instead, it roots them in stories of divine origin and in the working of karma. It shows that even communities of lower varṇa standing have a sacred ancestry.
Ghṛtācī, Viśvakarmā and the Nine Craft Communities
The central story of Chapter 10 is that of Ghṛtācī, an apsarā (a divine dancer), and Viśvakarmā, the divine architect. At Pushkara-tīrtha (the holy place of Pushkara) they cursed each other, and both were born again in human form. They later came together on the Malaya mountain and had nine sons, who became the ancestors of nine communities of craftspeople.
The nine communities are:
- Mālākāras (garland-makers)
- Karmakāras (blacksmiths)
- Śaṅkhakāras (workers in conch shell)
- Kuvindakas (weavers)
- Kumbhakāras (potters)
- Sūtrakāras (carpenters)
- Svarṇakāras (goldsmiths)
- Citrakāras (painters)
- A ninth community, also named in the text
Three of these nine sons later became patita (fallen) because of a brahma-śāpa, a curse given by a brāhmaṇa.
Teachings on Jāti
The wider teaching of the Brahma Khaṇḍa on jāti includes these points.
The Kali Yuga and jāti: The Brahma Khaṇḍa (Chapter 11) stresses that in the Kali Yuga, the present age, bhakti (loving devotion) to Śrī Kṛshṇa rises above differences of jāti. Vaishṇava brāhmaṇas are the greatest of all communities, and serving them brings merit beyond measure. This puts bhakti, rather than jāti, at the centre of social order.
The sacred origin of every community: The story of Ghṛtācī and Viśvakarmā shows that even craft communities counted as śūdra have divine ancestry, through beings from the divine worlds who took human birth. This makes jāti something sacred, rather than a mere social ranking.
Brahma-śāpa as the cause of change: The text shows that some communities fell from their first standing through curses given by brāhmaṇas. This explains the differences within communities, and also leaves open the possibility of being restored through dharma and bhakti.
The Duties of the Varṇas in the Śrī Kṛshṇa Janma Khaṇḍa (Chapter 83)
Chapter 83 of the Śrī Kṛshṇa Janma Khaṇḍa contains Kṛshṇa’s teaching to Nanda on the duties of each varṇa. Nanda asked about varṇa-dharma (the duties of the varṇas), and Kṛshṇa answered in detail.
Brāhmaṇa Dharma
The brāhmaṇa’s main dharma is Vishṇu-bhakti (devotion to Vishṇu), pūjā of the Śālagrāma (the sacred stone form of Vishṇu), havishyānna bhojana (eating only pure havishya foods) and guru-sevā (service to the guru). A brāhmaṇa who follows these is the foremost in all creation. Veda-pāṭha (recitation of the Veda), tapas (austerity) and Kṛshṇa-nāma-smaraṇa (remembering the name of Kṛshṇa) complete the brāhmaṇa’s life.
Kshatriya Dharma
The kshatriya’s dharma is to protect the people, rule the kingdom justly, fight wars according to dharma, protect brāhmaṇas and cows, and hold to truth in all dealings. A kshatriya who protects the weak and punishes the wicked fulfils his svadharma (own duty).
Vaiśya Dharma
The vaiśya’s dharma is honest trade, fair weights and measures, care of cows, farming done with the proper rites, and generous dāna (gifts) to brāhmaṇas. A vaiśya who earns honestly and gives generously is dear to Bhagavān Kṛshṇa.
Śūdra Dharma
The śūdra’s dharma is service to the three higher varṇas with dedication and devotion, honesty and pure conduct. A śūdra who serves the higher varṇas with true humility and keeps himself pure is worthy of respect.
Sannyāsī Dharma
The sannyāsī’s (renunciant’s) dharma is to give up all possessions and relationships completely, to live with vairāgya (detachment), to practise nāma-smaraṇa (remembering the divine name), to wander without a fixed home, to accept bhikshā (alms) without storing anything up, and to teach brahma-jñāna (knowledge of Brahman) to all who sincerely seek it.
Pativratā Dharma
The pativratā (devoted wife’s) dharma is pati-pūjā, honouring her husband as her highest devatā. She serves him in health and in sickness, keeps the home pure, raises the children in dharma, and stays chaste in thought, word and deed. As part of this teaching Kṛshṇa gave a stotra (hymn) spoken from the heart of the pativratā. In it the wife sees her husband as a form of the Divine and honours him in that way.
Per Agni Purāṇa
The Agni Purāṇa gives its teaching on varṇa and jāti in Chapter 151. Agni Deva tells that Pushkara taught Paraśurāma the dharmas by whose practice Manu and the others gained both bhukti (enjoyment in the world) and mukti (moksha). Pushkara says: “I shall tell you the dharmas of the varṇas, of the āśramas, and those common to all, which give delight to Vāsudeva and the others and which Manu and the others have taught.”
The dharmas common to all
These dharmas belong to every varṇa and every āśrama, in the order the text gives them:
- Ahiṃsā, not harming any being
- Satya, truthfulness
- Bhūtadayā, compassion for all beings
- A mind disposed to help and favour others (anugraha-buddhi)
- Tīrthayātrā, going to the tīrthas (holy places)
- Dāna, giving
- Brahmacarya
- Freedom from envy (mātsarya)
- Honouring the devatās and the brāhmaṇas
- Guru-śuśrūshā, service of the guru
- Hearing all the dharmas
- Pitṛ-pūjana, honouring the pitṛs (ancestors)
- Rāja-bhakti, loyalty to the king
- Always learning things only with the help of the best śāstras
- Freedom from cruelty
- Kshamā, forbearance
- Āstikya-buddhi, faith in the Veda and the higher world
The dharmas of each varṇa
- The brāhmaṇa has six dharmas: yajana (performing yajña), yājana (performing yajña for others), dāna (giving), adhyāpana (teaching the Veda and the other texts), pratigraha (receiving gifts) and adhyayana (study).
- The kshatriya and the vaiśya share three of these: dāna, adhyayana and yajana.
- The kshatriya’s own dharma is pālana, protecting the people, and dushṭa-nigraha, restraining the wicked.
- The vaiśya’s own dharmas are kṛshi (agriculture), go-saṃrakshaṇa (protecting cows) and vāṇijya (trade).
- The śūdra’s dharma is service (śuśrūshā) of the brāhmaṇa, the kshatriya and the vaiśya, or the various śilpas (crafts).
For the brāhmaṇa and the other two upper varṇas, the upanayana (the sacred-thread rite) is the second birth. From it they are dvija, twice-born.
In Chapter 152 Pushkara adds that a brāhmaṇa should live by his own karma. If he cannot, he may live by the callings of the kshatriya, the vaiśya and the śūdra, but he must never take up the calling of the saṅkara jātis, those born of mixed unions.
Anuloma and pratiloma
- Anuloma (ānulomya, “with the grain”) is the union in which the father is of a higher varṇa and the mother of a lower one. The jāti of the child is the same as the mother’s jāti.
- Pratiloma (prātilomya, “against the grain”) is the union in which the woman is of a higher kula (family line) and the man of a lower one.
The jātis born of pratiloma unions
| Father | Mother | Jāti of the child |
|---|---|---|
| Śūdra | Brāhmaṇa | Caṇḍāla |
| Kshatriya | Brāhmaṇa | Sūta |
| Vaiśya | Brāhmaṇa | Devala |
| Śūdra | Kshatriya | Māgadha |
| Śūdra | Vaiśya | Āyogava |
Those born of pratiloma women by pratiloma men are of thousands of kinds. They must marry only those of a jāti equal to their own, neither lower nor higher.
The work of each jāti
- Caṇḍāla: killing those condemned to death.
- Vaidehaka: making the things women use, and guarding women.
- Sūta: sārathya, being a charioteer.
- Pukkasa: living by hunting.
- Māgadha: stuti, singing praise.
- Āyogava: going down into the raṅga (the stage or arena) and living by craft.
The Caṇḍāla must live outside the village, wear the clothes of the dead, and must not touch people of the other varṇas.
Yet the way upward is open to them. By giving up their lives for the sake of cows and brāhmaṇas, and for the protection of women, children and others, the Caṇḍālas and the others gain spiritual elevation.
The jāti of those of mixed birth (saṅkara jātis) is settled by their parents and by the karma that belongs to their jāti.
Source: Agni Purāṇa, Chapters 151–152
Jāti in the rites, in dāna and in the king’s court
The later chapters of the Agni Purāṇa apply this teaching:
- Water offerings: no jalāñjali (offering of water in the joined palms) is given for one born of varṇa-saṅkara, the mixing of varṇas, nor for one who abandoned his own dharma, nor for a parivrājaka (wandering sannyāsī). For them the water rite has ceased (Chapter 158).
- Dāna: the fruit of a gift grows with the one who receives it. A gift to a varṇasaṅkara gives twice the fruit, to a śūdra four times, and to a vaiśya or a kshatriya eight times (Chapter 209).
- Servitude: among the varṇas, dāsya (servitude) is only in the anuloma order, one of a lower varṇa to one of a higher, never in the pratiloma order (Chapter 256).
- Words of abuse: the fine is fixed after weighing the higher and lower standing of the varṇas and jātis involved. When one of a lower varṇa abuses one of a higher varṇa, the fine is two or three times as much; when one of a higher varṇa abuses one of a lower varṇa, it is halved (Chapter 258).
- Seizing another’s wife by the hair: if the man is of the same jāti, he pays the uttama (highest) fine; if the union would be anuloma, the madhyama (middle) fine; if it would be pratiloma, the man is put to death and the woman’s ears are cut off (Chapter 258).
Source: Agni Purāṇa, Chapters 158, 209, 256, 258
Sources
- Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa, Brahma Khaṇḍa, Chapters 10–11
- Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa, Śrī Kṛshṇa Janma Khaṇḍa, Chapter 83
- Agni Purāṇa, Chapters 151–152, 158, 209, 256, 258