Brāhmaṇatva

Brāhmaṇatva · brāhmaṇa-tva, “the state of being a brāhmaṇa”

Brāhmaṇatva, also called brāhmaṇya and brahmatva, is the state of being a brāhmaṇa. The Bhavishya Purāṇa speaks of it in three places. In the Brahma Parva, Sumantu Muni teaches King Śatānīka that the forty-eight saṃskāras (sacred rites of refinement) give brahmatva, and that the Pratipat vrata brought rare brāhmaṇatva to Viśvāmitra. Later, in Chapters 40–45, comes the great inquiry into what brāhmaṇatva rests on. In the Madhyama Parva, Śrī Sūta sings the glory of the brāhmaṇa and names the twenty-six doshas (faults) that a man must give up.

The inquiry begins with a doubt in the heart of Śatānīka: is jāti (birth) higher, or karma (deed)? Sumantu answers with what Brahmā once told the ṛshis, who had come to him in wonder at the brāhmaṇatva of Viśvāmitra. Brahmā takes up each thing that might be its basis, and sets aside in turn birth, Veda study, the body, the saṃskāras and the outward marks. He affirms sadācāra (good conduct), tapas and brahma-jñāna. He names eight great ṛshis of unlikely birth, and says of five of them that one becomes a brāhmaṇa by tapas, with saṃskāra as a cause beside it. He says that the division of jāti is a false construction. He then defines the four varṇas by nature and by conduct, as Īśvara ordered them. His closing word gathers it all: men attain siddhi only when jāti and karma join, as fruit comes only when daiva and human effort join.

Brahmatva by the saṃskāras

In the second chapter of the Brahma Parva, Sumantu tells Śatānīka that the vipra is born for dharma and artha, for the rise of all beings, and that because he does good karma for the welfare of the world he reaches svarga, then Maharloka, then Janoloka, then Brahmaloka. So the brāhmaṇa attains brahmatva.

Śatānīka asks: “O Suvrata! Brahmatva cannot be attained. What kind of vipra can reach such brahmatva and Brahmaloka? Is a vipra a brāhmaṇa only in name? Which qualities of Brahmā reach him?”

Sumantu replies that he has asked well. If the forty-eight saṃskāras beginning with garbhādhāna, ordained for a brāhmaṇa by the Veda and the śāstras, are duly performed for him, he gains brahmatva, the honoured place of Brahma. The saṃskāras are the cause of attaining brahmatva.

The text calls these saṃskāras forty, and gives them in this order:

  • The saṃskāras of the life: Garbhādhāna, Puṃsavana, Sīmantonnayana, Jātakarma, Annaprāśana, Caula, Upanayana.
  • The four Brahma-vratas: Prājāpatya, Saumya, Āgneya, Vaiśvadeva.
  • Then: Snātaka, Gārhasthya.
  • The Pañca-yajñas, which a gṛhastha should do for his own good: Brahma-yajña, Deva-yajña, Pitṛ-yajña, Manushya-yajña, Bhūta-yajña.
  • The seven Pāka-yajñas: Aupāsana, Vaiśvadeva, Pārvaṇa, Ashṭa, Māsa-śrāddha, Sarvabali, Īśānabali.
  • The seven Havir-yajñas: Agnyādhāna, Agnihotra, Darśa and Paurṇamāsya, Cāturmāsya, Nirūḍha-paśubandhana, Sautrāmaṇi.
  • The seven Soma-yajñas: Agnishṭoma, Atyagnishṭoma, Ukthya, Shoḍaśī, Vājapeya, Atirātra, Āptoryāma.

With them go the eight ātma-guṇas (qualities of the ātmā), which complete the forty-eight:

  1. Anasūyā: not speaking ill of the virtues of the virtuous, not praising one’s own virtues, not delighting in the faults of others.
  2. Dayā: goodwill toward one’s own people and others, friend and enemy, as toward oneself.
  3. Kshamā: not being angered and not grieving when trouble arises in speech, mind or body.
  4. Śauca: giving up things not fit to be eaten, the company of good people, and keeping to sadācāra.
  5. Anāyāsa: going on with a good karma without a break, though the body is burdened by it.
  6. Maṅgala: doing the praised karma and giving up the unpraised, as the munis who speak of Brahma say.
  7. Akārpaṇya: giving dāna constantly, without a wretched heart, even from small wealth.
  8. Aspṛhā: being content, without harming others, with even the small thing one has.

Thus the body of the brāhmaṇa, refined by the forty-eight saṃskāras, attains brahmatva and reaches Brahmaloka. By the puṇya karmas of the Veda and by prokshaṇa and such, the body of a vipra is refined both in this loka and after death. Then, having gained garbha-śuddhi and the dharmas marked by the āśramas, brāhmaṇas who have desire for this Purāṇa attain mukti.

Sumantu adds a rule. Whoever leaves aside the brāhmaṇas near him, who speak svasti to those who take refuge, and honours others instead, incurs a pāpa that cannot be told in words. So the nearby brāhmaṇa must be honoured as a guest is honoured, with gifts of food and drink and so on, according to śāstra.

Phala: whoever hears, comes to know and reads these vipra-saṃskāras told in the Purāṇa gains prosperity, rise, fame, the highest wealth, riches and grain, sons and friends, a good form and Sūryaloka, and after that reaches Brahmaloka.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 2

Viśvāmitra and the Pratipat vrata

At the close of the Pratipat Kalpa, Sumantu tells Śatānīka how the upavāsa of the first tithi gives brāhmaṇatva. One who keeps the vrata for a full year is born a brāhmaṇa ten times when he returns from svarga.

Viśvāmitra, wishing to gain brāhmaṇatva, performed tapas for a long time. That tapas only became a cause of distress to the devas. He did not gain brāhmaṇatva, and met many kinds of obstacles. Then, firm in niyama and vrata, knowing this to be the best of tithis and dear to Brahmā, he began the upavāsa vrata on Pratipat. And Brahmā gave the wise Viśvāmitra rare brāhmaṇatva in that very body, here in this life.

A kshatriya, a vaiśya or a śūdra who keeps the vrata on this tithi attains brāhmaṇatva. Sumantu says that the tithi grants desires, is dear to Brahmā and is secret. Among the Haihayas, Tālajaṅghas, Turushkas, Yavanas and Śakas, those who kept this upavāsa vrata gained the brāhmaṇatva they desired.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 16

The question of Śatānīka

In the Shashṭhī Kalpa, Śatānīka hears of the hard vrata and of the greatness of Kārtikeya. A doubt rises in his heart. Kārtikeya is born in many ways: how is his birth to be reconciled with his greatness? Is jāti the higher, or karma? Does greatness come from birth, or from the karma one performs?

Sumantu says that this same question was once put to Brahmā, and that he will give the answer Brahmā gave. Certain intelligent śishyas, the ṛshis, were amazed at the brāhmaṇatva of Viśvāmitra and eager to understand it. They went to Brahmā as he sat at ease, and, humble with bhakti and śraddhā, they bowed to him and asked: “O Brahmadeva! Among these, birth, Veda study, the body, the saṃskāra of the ātmā, ācāra and karma, by which did brāhmaṇatva arise in the Ādi Kalpa?”

They added: if the outer and inner marks that belong to the karma of mind, speech and body, and to jāti, dravya and guṇa, are artificial, then one cannot settle what is natural and what is not.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 40

Yogīśvara’s reasoned word

Brahmā replies that the matter is not to be doubted in that way, and he gives the reasoned statement that Yogīśvara made for the good of his śishyas.

The pramāṇas (means of right knowledge) for settling the difference between things are well known, says Yogīśvara, so one can examine directly and decide what is what. The siddhānta of one like an atīndriya-jñānī, a knower of what is beyond the senses, is accepted. But to say that he alone is the final word, and that only what he says is pramāṇa, is not right, for many pramāṇas settle a thing. Because of this variety, it is hard to settle the true nature of a thing.

To call the Veda paurusheya (made by a person) would support its having been born. What the Veda states is to be practised. The śruti is followed after it is uttered, for before utterance the act, the vidhi and nishedha and their order stand unmanifest. To say that the meaning has a fixed rule with its fruit, like fire with smoke, is only one side.

Likewise it is not right to say that brāhmaṇa and the other jātis follow from the person. Merely naming a person does not make his jāti visible. A horse in a herd of cattle can be examined and declared a horse by the wise. A brāhmaṇa cannot be separated in that way from the śūdras, for humanness is common to both. All people are of one kind, and there is nothing particular within the human jāti. Only saṃskāra and excellence of rite set the brāhmaṇa jāti apart, and by these it is known apart from the śūdra jāti.

Some who do not know the tattva (the truth of the matter) say that every living being is a brāhmaṇa. The ocean of saṃsāra answers them. It is churned by the crocodiles of old age and filth, it heaves with the waves of sorrow from births as humans, cattle, birds and others and in the lowest jātis, its whirlpools are the crowds caught in hardship, disease, grief and torment, and it is full of the tortoises of dogs, pigs, caṇḍālas, worms and insects. How can the jīva who rises and sinks in that ocean, carrying a great load of pāpa, be a brāhmaṇa?

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 40

The seven vyādhas

Then Brahmā says: “O brāhmaṇas! The account of the seven vyādhas (hunters) was told long ago by Manu. Hearing it, one should give up the standing that comes from birth.”

On a mountain in the Daśārṇa country seven vyādhas, like beasts, passed their time. In Sarid-dvīpa cakravāka birds passed their time to the end. In the Mānasa lake, haṃsas. And likewise brāhmaṇas born in Kurukshetra, masters of the Veda, passed their time. At the end of their long journey one cannot know where all of these are. “What do you conclude about this?” asks Brahmā. So no brāhmaṇya can be seen in the living being as such.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 40

Jāti rests on work

Since the human jāti has no separate division of brāhmaṇya, it cannot be pointed out as “this is brāhmaṇya”. The common human form has only very subtle differences, and no clear marks of jāti. In colours such as white and black there may be likenesses. In blood, bone, marrow and flesh there is no difference of varṇa at all.

This brāhmaṇatva, says Brahmā, is made, not permanent, and only by convention is it treated as natural. It is a sign of the fruit of some small measure of good deeds in a former birth. As one says “those who trade” and “those who practise medicine”, all differences of jāti rest on people’s own occupations.

How can those who have given up puṇya-karma be brāhmaṇas? What kshatriyas are those who do not protect the world? How are vaiśyas who have left their own dharma vaiśyas? How are śūdras who do not do the karma fixed for their jāti śūdras? Among people there is no difference such as that between a cow and a horse. The arrangement of occupation can be refused by the pramāṇas, and the fool and the miser cannot know what is settled and what is forbidden.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 40

The brāhmaṇas by kula who perish

Brahmā then names the ways of living by which a brāhmaṇa, though a brāhmaṇa by kula, goes to destruction without fail:

  • owning cows, buffaloes, goats, horses, sheep, elephants and the like, and grass-lands;
  • living on interest from lending;
  • trade;
  • the work of the goldsmith, weaver, barber and washerman, and work in leather;
  • eating flesh; dancing and wandering through many countries;
  • eating onion and garlic; drinking the milk of deer and camels;
  • buying and selling flesh, yaksha-dhūpa, milk and such things;
  • keeping company with a śūdra woman, a courtesan, a caṇḍāla woman and others;
  • living on the food of śūdras;
  • wearing the garments of the dead; eating food set aside for the dead;
  • using the food and drink of people under mṛtāśauca and jātāśauca;
  • not performing brahma-yajña, deva-yajña, pitṛ-yajña, bhūta-bali and atithi-pūjana;
  • mada, mātsarya, hatred, greed, lust and tamo-guṇa;
  • being without ācāra, and slander.

Those who fall by not following the dharmas stated in the śāstra, however distinguished their gotra, saṃskāra, titles and ornaments, and even if they teach the Veda or have studied it, fall from brāhmaṇatva because they follow the way of bad conduct. So jāti does not stay in one place. People should study the ślokas here so that they do not fall.

A brāhmaṇa falls at once by selling flesh, lac and salt. A brāhmaṇa who sells milk becomes a śūdra in three days. Those who guard cattle, those who buy and sell, the goldsmith, weaver, washerman, barber, leather-workers, wandering dancers, those sent by masters on errands and moneylenders: Manu has named these as śūdras.

The śūdra attains brāhmaṇatva. The brāhmaṇa attains śūdratva. Likewise the kshatriya and the vaiśya too can attain brāhmaṇatva. This should be known.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 40

Veda study does not make a brāhmaṇa

Brahmā turns to the claim that Veda study gives brāhmaṇya. Yet, he says, these too study the Vedas: vaiśyas, kshatriyas, rākshasas such as Rāvaṇa, śvādas, mālas, those who do servile work, vyādhas, cowherds, fishermen and other śūdra jātis. Some śūdras go to other lands, take shelter with brāhmaṇas and kshatriyas, are made like brāhmaṇas in dealings, form and language, learn one Veda or two in due order, and marry a pure brāhmaṇa maiden. Or they study the Vedas, gain equality with the kshatriya and vaiśya jātis, and become a jāti of a land east of the Gauḍa country or of a southern land. As their śūdratva is unknown, they obtain whichever brāhmaṇa jāti they wish. So no difference based on the Veda-branch or the rite can be known. The śāstrakāras who follow the way of nyāya have said the same.

Even when studied with the aṅgas, the Vedas cannot purify those without ācāra. Veda study is the task of brāhmaṇas, but good conduct as one’s way of life is the mark of a brāhmaṇa. By a brāhmaṇa who has studied the four Vedas but lacks sadvṛtta no act can be done. Even if he performs a karma it is fruitless.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 41

Outward marks and powers

Śikhā, oṃkāra, saṃskāra, sandhyopāsana, the mekhalā, the daṇḍa, the deer skin, the pavitra and the like can be found among śūdras too, according to their nishṭhā. Even the Trimūrti cannot prevent this, far less can men. So among people the yajñopavīta, the saṃskāras, mekhalās and śikhās are not looked on as anything special.

Nor do powers mark a brāhmaṇa. If only the brāhmaṇa had power in black rites and rare acts, who could kill those belonging to him? By the greatness of tapas, satya and the like comes the power to contemplate knowledge relating to the devatās. As for mantra-śakti, it is within reach of all. Deceit and harsh speech are common to all people. In giving śāpa and anugraha there is no difference of power. In being robbed by thieves, bandits, kings and evil men there is no difference among people. An eminent brāhmaṇa who does no forbidden act in this land, in this Kali Yuga, may at another time, in another land, be caught in doing them. Powers such as śāpa and anugraha are known to the Paramātmā, and some speak of them as a sign of the attainment of brahmatva. Those whose minds are attached to saṃsāra, covered in the darkness of moha, fall like moths into fire, into the pits on the upward paths.

Through contact with the Veda, jāti-dharma is somewhat special in the brāhmaṇa jāti. Saṃskāra comes by birth, or by completeness of means. Among brāhmaṇas the learned posit a difference of five kinds. But no special thing arises from jāti or from the Veda. One bound to do the Veda-ordained karmas who does not do them becomes a cause of lack of karma. One who dwells in his own mind and grows with Veda-yoga becomes a person of knowledge without a second, and no others can know him.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 41

Brāhmaṇya is unseen

Is the brāhmaṇya desired by all of a visible nature? It is of the form of adṛshṭa, the unseen. The eye knows the visible form; for what is not so, there is no such way. By completeness there is a supreme speciality in the brāhmaṇa’s body, by which the devatās in his ātmā remember what is puṇya, what is pāpa, what is improper and what the śāstra says. By the virtues of complete observance śūdras too become complete and stand equal with brāhmaṇas. So neither inwardly nor by outward cause is there any distinction of brāhmaṇa and śūdra. A leading man of great saṃskāra may arise in the brāhmaṇa class, but no equality with Vyāsa and the others can apply to him.

Birth is natural and study has no speciality, so neither can be the cause of difference among jātis. Where is jāti in the jīva, who is carried along from the five-element nature of the body and the unseen saṃskāras of the mind? Among nāstikas, mlecchas, yavanas and other peoples, and among doers of cruel acts, is one not seen who excels by dharma? He was not born from the completeness of the brāhmaṇa jāti. Without a cause there is no difference, either in the antarātmā or outwardly.

In these, in order, any difference between śūdra and brāhmaṇa is still to be searched for: sukha and the like; aiśvarya; command; abhaya; vīrya; form; the eyes; activity; āyus; the limbs; stoutness; weakness; steadiness; fickleness; prajñā; vairāgya; dharma; parākrama; the trivarga; skill; medicines; the woman’s womb; gait; the discharge of the body; the nine openings; love; measure; hair. In all dharmas there is equality, and even the devatās cannot see a difference.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 41

The four varṇas are not four colours

Brāhmaṇas are not white like moon-rays. Kshatriyas do not have the hue of the palāśa flower. Vaiśyas do not have a colour like haridala. Śūdras are not black like charcoal. In walking, in bodily colour, in hair, in sukha and duḥkha, in blood, skin, flesh, bone and fluids, all people are equal. In colour, measure, form, stay in the womb, birth from it, speech, intellect, the karmendriyas, lives, strengths, dharma, artha and kāma, diseases and medicines, there is no special difference from jāti.

Paramātmā alone is the master of all beings. How then did differences of jāti arise? Examined by pramāṇas, examples and nyāya, the difference falls to pieces. Brahmā gives three examples.

  • The father. One father has four sons, and the jāti of those four sons is one. So too the one father of all people is Paramātmā.
  • The fruit. On trees such as the udumbara and the aśvattha, some fruits grow on the upper part and some on the lower, yet in colour, form and taste all are the same. So the human jāti too should be held to be one.
  • The gotras. Those of the Kauśika, Kāśyapa, Gautama, Kāṇḍinya, Māṇḍavya, Vasishṭha, Ātreya, Kautsa, Āṅgīrasa, Garga, Maudgalya, Kātyāyana and Bhārgava gotras all come of a descent of brothers and sisters, or of sons and daughters-in-law. Among them the marriage rule and the differences of varṇa are made.

Out of compassion for those who speak of a merely bodily brāhmaṇatva, says Brahmā, to remove their darkness of blindness an añjana (healing collyrium) is applied, made with the divine medicines of the śāstric view, which gives them good sight.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 41

Brāhmaṇatva is not of the body

The physical form perishes, so brāhmaṇya cannot be ascribed to the beings who wear the body. No single limb attains it, nor the collection of limbs. If bodyhood, which all beings have from earth, water, air and fire, gave it, brāhmaṇatva would apply to all beings. To ascribe it to the body is the work of those who do not know the tattva. Even the bodies of those who give the saṃskāras have no brahmatva. Searched for with effort in the body, it is not found. If it could be seen in the body, it would arise also among those called of low kula, among caṇḍālas and forest-dwellers. Because the powers of the body waste away, and the body itself turns to ash, brāhmaṇya is not of the nature of the body and is not born in the body.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 41

Pride of jāti

Brahmā offers what the people of sadācāra have said as subhāshita. The living being, showing forth births as trees and plants, as conches, as ants, bees and elephants, moves here and there like an actor in the courses of karma, wandering without right sight. “Wrapped in the armours of form, wealth, knowledge, kula and splendour, you let go whenever the path of dharma is mentioned. You go from this loka to that, and from there come back here. Until your ahaṃkāra is burned to ash, you cannot gain knowledge.”

Blinded by the ahaṃkāras of jāti, kula, form, age and varṇa, people cannot see what would bring them śreyas in this world or the next. Knowing these divisions, what wise man can keep pride of jāti? Jāti follows karma. Who has one lasting jāti?

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 42

Saṃskāra alone does not make a brāhmaṇa

If in an assembly of the learned someone says “he became a brāhmaṇa by saṃskāra”, his word is to be refused by those who speak by nyāya. Brahmā names the saṃskāras in this order: garbhādhāna, puṃsavana, sīmantonnayana, jātakarma, nāmakaraṇa, annaprāśana, cūḍākarma, upanayana, snātaka, samāvartana, pāṇigrahaṇa. People are refined by these and other rites. They are the brāhmaṇas, and in them desires rage constantly!

Even among brāhmaṇas born of brāhmaṇas who have had the saṃskāras, long life, strength and tejas may be plainly absent. The one with saṃskāra and the one without it, both born of brāhmaṇa bodies, do not differ in what they like and dislike, or in what they gain and fail to gain. Without jñāna, Veda study, karma, inquiry into Vedānta, niyama and control of the senses, by the mere joining of saṃskāra a man gains no difference from a śūdra. Merely by having a body refined by saṃskāra one is not freed of pāpas.

The man of evil conduct, though he has had the saṃskāras, goes to naraka. The man of sadācāra, though he lacks the saṃskāras, becomes an excellent brāhmaṇa. One who falls from worthiness parts from brāhmaṇatva without fail. Vyāsa and other excellent munis, without any of the saṃskāras beginning with garbhādhāna, were simply keeping ācāra.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 42

The excellent brāhmaṇas of unlikely birth

There are many excellent brāhmaṇas, says Brahmā, who gained śreyas and are honoured by all the lokas. He names some of them, and who each was born of:

Many others like them were at first non-brāhmaṇas and afterwards obtained brāhmaṇatva. Those exalted ones who walk by the word of such great ones gained a tejas grown through ācāra.

Then comes the refrain. Ṛshyaśṛṅga, born from the womb of a doe, became a mahāmuni. One becomes a brāhmaṇa by tapas, and together with it saṃskāra too is a cause. Parāśara, father of Vyāsa, though born in the womb of a māla woman, became a maharshi. So one becomes a brāhmaṇa by tapas alone, and together with it saṃskāra is a cause. Kaṇāda, though born of an owl, became a mahāmuni. So tapas is the cause of brahmatva, and with it saṃskāra too. Vasishṭha, though born of the womb of a courtesan, became a mahāmuni. Tapas is the cause of brāhmaṇatva, and saṃskāra a cause following after it. Mandapāla, though the son of a boat-woman, became a mahāmuni. One becomes a brāhmaṇa by tapas, and together with it saṃskāra is a cause.

Even those skilled in the saṃskāra rites taught in the Vedas and Āgamas gain the highest fruit only by the strength of the wealth of jñāna and tapas. For great pāpīs, even with bodies refined by saṃskāra, brahma-jñāna alone brings cessation. So the wise know that this alone is the sign of brahmatva.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 42

The lowest brāhmaṇas and the equality of all

Brahmā goes on, speaking to the knowers of the Veda mantras. Will they accept special excellence through saṃskāra for a body born from śukla and śoṇita, joined with natural impurity? Some hold that man gains superiority only through the saṃskāras, from nisheka to the śmaśāna. He rejects their position. Brāhmaṇas endowed with all the saṃskāras do surpass śūdras in their various occupations. Yet there are lowest brāhmaṇas, and he lists them: the one of fierce acts; the one who performs no karma; the slayer of a brāhmaṇa; the one who goes to the guru’s bed; the thief; the slayer of a cow; the drinker of madya; the one who keeps company with another’s wife; the liar; the one mad with pride; the nāstika; the reviler of the Veda; the village purohita; the killer; the one of many faults; the one who obtains what should not be obtained; the doer of forbidden acts; the robber; the wanderer who roams for alms; the proud one; the gambler; the actor; the contemptible one; the doer of pāpas; the one who eats what must not be eaten; the one who sells everything.

Such men, struck down by pāpas of speech, mind and body, cannot gain purity even by a hundred yajñas. Therefore mantra, agnihotra and the slaying of the paśu at the yajña vedi are not the causes of brāhmaṇatva, for such acts can be done by śūdras too. Those bound by the noose of karma perish. Burned in the fire of saṃsāra, they wander wretched in the forest of birth and death.

Among the lowest of men of the four varṇas, born of food and semen, in both following and not following one’s own dharma, only mixture is to be seen. Śūdras, brāhmaṇas and others do not differ in the matter of birth. They are equal in intellect, strength and nature; in dharmas, birth, wealth and duties; in puṇya and pāpa; in bonds, torments and afflictions; in sorrows; in the sāttvika, rāja and tāmasa states; in kapha, vāta and pitta; in livelihood and its loss; in truth and untruth; in illness, poverty and endurance.

In all varṇas are found the slayers of beings, the pāpātmās, the speakers of untruth, the revilers of sādhus, thieves, the merciless, those who keep company with another’s wife, doers of mean acts, those of evil conduct, those who oppress others and rich men of evil mind. Like the boyas who live in the forest hunting deer, many tale-bearers and wicked men fill their bellies by harming others. Some, even after studying Veda dharma, increase their wealth by harming beings, by reviling others and by false conduct, and these are the lowest, who live by selling the Vedas. Of whatever varṇa, these are lowest among men: the deceitful, the envious, the misers, fools, the proud, cheats, those who eat others’ food, the cruel, lovers of quarrel, idle talkers, flatterers, sellers of what must not be sold, eaters of what must not be eaten, and those without tapas.

Brāhmaṇas who take clothes not fit to be received and do not give up what is contemptible: how can such men be gurus on this earth? Those who carry staves, those who beat the ḍiṇḍara drums, the jesters, the wrathful, doers of low acts and makers of evil talk harm beasts and animals as a lion harms them. Those who see a muni who has nothing but tapas, honour him and then insult him as they go, are enemies of themselves.

Brahmā gives one more reason. Bulls, horses, camels and elephants do not unite with animals of another kind and make them conceive, while a brāhmaṇa and a śūdra woman do. So the union of man and woman gives no clear division that could settle the difference between brāhmaṇa and śūdra.

The body is formed by the coming together of many material things. It is bound to place and time, its nature is to be burned away, and it has the jīva within, tormented by rāga and dveśha. Its mind spins without rest like the potter’s wheel in the ocean of sense enjoyment. It is burned by the fire of birth, death, old age and sorrow, and it is weak. In such a body no distinction can be conceived. This difference among men is made up by the strength of an agreement.

Brāhmaṇya comes about by resting on a brāhmaṇa. A woman who leaves her husband goes astray from desire, and some fall from brāhmaṇya and commit mahāpāpas. Therefore, the chapter closes, the division of jāti is only a false construction.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 43

Who are thought of as brāhmaṇas

Those are thought of as brāhmaṇas who practise the traditions made known by Brahmā, and who have these marks. They know well what is to be given up and what is to be taken, and have left the śāstra that teaches the unjust path. They have conquered mind, speech and senses, are devoted to sadācāra, and live bound to niyamas and ācāras. They strive always for the good of themselves and others, and are engaged in works that preserve household life. They are skilled in seeing the truth and rest in the state where the mind is dissolved. They are free of krodha, have svādhyāya and a heart full of bhakti, have given up attachment, have no envy, and have neither sorrow nor pride. They are peaceful and desire the good of all beings. They look on happiness and sorrow with an even eye, and stay in solitude. They have a mind of dharma and fear pāpa. They have no ahaṃkāra and mamakāra. They are heroes in dāna, compassionate, knowers of Brahman the real, without restlessness, and established in all the śāstras.

The auspicious tradition was set up for the good of the world by Brahmā, Svayambhū, Vāgīśvara, born from the navel, and by ṛshis of great tapas who give abhaya to all beings.

From greatness comes the name of Bhagavān Brahmā, the central place of creation. Those who with bhakti have taken refuge in Bhagavān Brahmā are called brāhmaṇas. Those who protect the distressed are kshatriyas. Those of the conduct of earning a livelihood are vaiśyas. Those who have gone far from the Veda are called śūdras.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 44

The virtues of brāhmaṇya

Brahmavādins devoted to ācāra speak of brāhmaṇya, and they always praise the fruit the mind desires, which is moksha. The virtues of brāhmaṇya, in order, are: patience; indriya nigraha; dayā; dāna; satya; śucitva; courage; pity; turning from sense objects; gentleness; straight conduct; contentment; freedom from ahaṃkāra; tapas; absence of kāma, krodha and the rest; dharma; jñāna; freedom from tale-bearing; brahmacarya; discernment; dhyāna; āstikatva; absence of hatred; turning from worldly things; a peaceful nature; fear of pāpa; freedom from theft; freedom from envy; freedom from craving; detachment; service to the guru; restraint in mind, speech and karma.

For those who follow such ācāras, brahmatva is abundant and increases every day. By steadfastness in the ācāra of the varṇa they gained according to their inclination, they become of great tejas. By remaining in a way that opposes no śāstra they become pure of mind. Dear to the good and the wise, they become learned by studying the Purāṇas and Āgama śāstras, practise the Gītā śāstra that was sung, and study with minds fixed on Dharma śāstra.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 44

Īśvara’s ordering of the varṇas

In all the manvantaras, karma done according to varṇa and āśrama comes to the highest fulfilment. So that the varṇas and āśramas should be in harmony, Īśvara himself set up a rule. Among those who accepted it, those of strength of mind are the greater number. Some he ordained as kshatriyas who protect the weak. Those who please the kshatriyas, who have them perform yajña, who rest on them and who speak of the eternal and true Brahman are brāhmaṇas. Some joined in vaiśya karma, and with foresight they destroyed the mean paths on the earth. Those who rest on ploughing, farming, go-raksha, trade and thrift he called vaiśyas. The distressed, the unsteady, those able to labour in service, those without tejas and those of little strength he called śūdras. Their karmas were divided according to the guṇas born of their own nature.

  • Natural to the brāhmaṇa jāti: peace, tapas, indriya nigraha, śucitva, kshamā, straightness, jñāna, vijñāna, āstikatā.
  • Natural to kshatriyas: valour, tejas, courage, capacity, steadiness in battle, generosity, authority.
  • Natural to vaiśyas: farming, go-raksha, trade.
  • Natural to śūdras: the karma of service.

The marks of the brāhmaṇa are also given in a second list: yoga, tapas, dayā, dāna, satya, dharma, Veda, vairāgya, knowledge by experience, knowledge of śāstra and faith in the divine. Svāyambhuva Manu said that one who has the śikhā made of jñāna and the pavitra made of tapas has abundant brahmatva.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 44

Conduct decides

In any varṇa, men are of three kinds: uttama, madhyama and adhama. Among them, the one who has turned back from acts of pāpa is established as a brāhmaṇa. Even a śūdra, if rich in śīla, is greater than a brāhmaṇa. A brāhmaṇa without ācāra is lower than a śūdra. One who neither touches madya nor sells it is called a sat-śūdra.

It is clear that jāti is one, and that it is divided into one and another by work. Speech is one, yet taking on other marks it has formed into languages. Oṃkāra alone is one: the word for Paramātmā, who pervades as creation, sustenance and dissolution in Bhūḥ, Bhuvaḥ and Suvaḥ. Such being so, for the division of men, why should one not go by the path that is seen through fitness? With this question the chapter ends.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 44

Brahmā’s closing word

Brahmā says: as doubt arises in you about the karmas of jāti, hear this reasoned word of mine, told again not at length, but as a whole. Men attain siddhi only by the joining of both, jāti and karma. Just as fruit comes only when daiva and human effort come together, so a man gains siddhi only when jāti and karma come together. Long ago the Yogīśvara of great tejas said exactly this when teaching his śishyas, briefly yet in full.

Then Sumantu turns to the king: “O King, in this way Brahmā answered the question the ṛshis asked. This word of the brahmarshi on the union of jāti and karma is reasoned. Therefore you need not wonder about Kārtikeya. The path of the devatās is always hard to know.”

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 45

The glory of the brāhmaṇa

In the Madhyama Parva, Śrī Sūta speaks of the glory of the brāhmaṇa. Among the three varṇas the brāhmaṇa is prabhu by birth. For the protection of all havya and kavya he was first brought forth through tapas. The devagaṇa accept havya and the pitṛgaṇa accept kavya through his mouth alone, and the Vedas rest in the mouths of brāhmaṇas. He is best by birth and to be honoured by all. He alone is a true brāhmaṇa whose forty-eight saṃskāras, beginning with garbhādhāna, are performed by the vidhi of the śāstra.

By honouring a dvija the devagaṇa gain the fruit of svarga, and other men reach devatva. On whom a brāhmaṇa is pleased, Bhagavān Vishṇu is pleased. Because he knows all subjects, the brāhmaṇa alone is commended for deva-pūjā, pitṛ-kārya, yajña, vivāha, vahni-kārya, śānti-karma and svastyayana. Without a brāhmaṇa, dāna, homa and bali are fruitless in deva-kārya, pitṛ-kārya and yajña karmas.

On seeing a brāhmaṇa one should give abhivādana with śraddhā. By his word “dīrghāyur bhava” (be long-lived) a man becomes long-lived. By pūjā of a brāhmaṇa āyu, kīrti, vidyā and wealth increase. A home where the feet of vipras are not washed with water, where Veda and śāstra are not recited, and where the sound of svāhā, svadhā and svasti is not heard, is like a śmaśāna.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Madhyama Parva, Bhāga 1, Chapter 5

The twenty-six doshas

The learned have told twenty-six doshas of men bound for naraka, which one should give up to live in purity. They have many divisions and sub-divisions. Śrī Sūta gives their detail in brief:

  1. Adhama: one who goes before the guru and a devatā wearing shoes and holding an umbrella; one who sits on a high seat before the guru; one who goes on tīrthayātrā riding a vehicle; one who practises grāmya dharma in a tīrtha.
  2. Vishama: one who speaks dear and sweet words openly but holds hālāhala poison in the heart; one who says one thing and does another.
  3. Paśu: one who gives up thought of moksha and toils in worldly cares; one without the sevā of Hari; one who lives in Prayāga yet bathes elsewhere; one who leaves the visible deva and serves the unseen; one who does not know the essence of the śāstras.
  4. Piśuna: one who cheats by force, by fraud or by a show of false love.
  5. Kṛpaṇa: the dull-minded man who, though sweet food is at hand, feeds stale and bitter food in deva and pitṛ karmas, and gets neither svarga nor moksha; one who gives a poor thing with an unwilling mind and does pūjā of a devatā in anger; one who gives up the auspicious and sells his auspicious body.
  6. Pāpishṭha: one who abandons mother, father and guru; one without pure conduct; one who eats without restraint in front of his father; one who abandons a living father and mother and never serves them; one who breaks off homa, yajña and the like.
  7. Nashṭa: those who give up true conduct and make a show of false service; one who goes to prostitutes; one who lives by deva-dhana; one who lives by money gained through a wife’s adultery; one who lives by selling a daughter or by a wife’s wealth. These have no claim on svarga or moksha.
  8. Rushṭa: five kinds: one whose mind is always angry; one who grows angry on seeing his own lowness; one with crooked brows; one who is angry; one of a rushṭa nature.
  9. Dushṭa: seven kinds: one who spends life in what should not be done or in blamed conduct; one unsteady in dharma-kārya; the sleepy; one attached to bad habits; one who drinks madya; one given to women; one who always talks with dushṭas.
  10. Pushṭa: one who eats sweets alone; the cheat; one who blames good people; one with the habits of a boar.
  11. Hashṭa: the pāpātmā who neither studies nor hears Nigama and Āgama.
  12. Kāṇa: one without Śruti or without Smṛti, for these two are the eyes of brāhmaṇas. He is one-eyed.
  13. Andha: one without both Śruti and Smṛti. He is blind.
  14. Khaṇḍa: one who quarrels with his own brother; one who speaks unkind words to his mother and father.
  15. Caṇḍa: one who blames the śāstra; the back-biter; one who attends on a king; the servant of a śūdra; one who behaves wrongly with a śūdra’s wife; one who eats even once food cooked in a śūdra’s house; one who stays five days in a śūdra’s house.
  16. Kushṭha: the tri-kushṭhī, joined with the eight kinds of kushṭha; the low man who talks with people blamed in the śāstra.
  17. Dattāpahāraka: one who wanders like an insect; one who trades with a base fault.
  18. Vaktā: one who, being a false paṇḍita and ignorant, gives teaching on dharma.
  19. Kadarya: one who tries to take away the livelihood of the elders; a dweller of Kāśī who leaves Kāśī and lives elsewhere for many days.
  20. Daṇḍa: one who makes a show of false anger; one who, not being a king, imposes punishment.
  21. Nīca: one who steals the wealth of a brāhmaṇa, a king or a devatā, and with it pleases another devatā or brāhmaṇas, or feeds others with it: he is low like a donkey. One who only reads and does not understand, without Vyākaraṇa-śāstra, is a paśu. One who says one thing before guru and devatā and does another, and is of ill conduct, is called nīca.
  22. Khala: one who hunts for faults in the virtuous and good.
  23. Vācāla: one who speaks in mocking words to an unfortunate man; one who talks shamelessly with cāṇḍālas.
  24. Capala: one intent on keeping birds; one who, like a monkey, eats himself the food brought by a cat, on the pretext of sharing it out; one who cuts grass or breaks clods of earth for no purpose; one who eats meat; one attached to another’s wife.
  25. Malīmasa: one who does not apply oil, ubṭan and the like; one without scent and candana; one who does not do the nitya-karma.
  26. Steyī: one who wrongly takes the wealth of another’s house; one who earns wealth wrongly; one who takes wealth forbidden by the śāstra; one who steals a devatā-pustaka, ratna, maṇi and pearls, horses, cows, land or gold. Also those who do not reflect on the devatā and on mutual good; those who do not nourish guru, mother and father and do not do the duty owed to them; and those who do not behave rightly towards one who has helped them.

On Kāṇa and Andha, Śrī Sūta quotes this verse:

श्रुतिः स्मृतिश्च विप्राणां नयने द्वे विनिर्मिते।
एकेन विकलः काणो द्वाभ्यामन्धः प्रकीर्तितः।।

śrutiḥ smṛtiśca viprāṇāṃ nayane dve vinirmite |
ekena vikalaḥ kāṇo dvābhyāmandhaḥ prakīrtitaḥ ||

Śruti and Smṛti are made the two eyes of vipras. One lacking one of them is called kāṇa, and one lacking both is called andha.

Those with all these doshas dwell in a naraka full of blood. When right knowledge of these is gained, a man reaches devatva.

Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Madhyama Parva, Bhāga 1, Chapter 5

Sources

  • Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapters 2, 16, 40–45; Madhyama Parva, Bhāga 1, Chapter 5