Ahiṃsā and the Question of Eating Meat

Ahiṃsā means not harming any living being. In the Anuśāsana Parva of the Mahābhārata, Bhīshma, lying on his bed of arrows, teaches Yudhishṭhira about ahiṃsā and the eating of meat. The śāstras (sacred texts) praise ahiṃsā, and they also allow, and in some cases require, meat in certain śrāddha (rites for the ancestors) and yajña (fire offering) settings.

Bhīshma teaches that ahiṃsā has four parts: mind, speech, conduct and eating. If any one part fails, ahiṃsā as a whole fails. Giving up meat bears the same fruit as a hundred years of monthly Aśvamedha yajñas. Killing for no sacred purpose (vṛthā) is always pāpa (wrongdoing), while meat consecrated with mantras and offered in rites for the ancestors or in yajña carries only a small dosha (fault). A long line of righteous kings gave up meat and so reached svarga (the heavenly world) and Brahmaloka (the world of Brahmā). The teaching ends with the great declaration that ahiṃsā paramo dharmaḥ, “ahiṃsā is the highest dharma”, equal to or greater than all yajñas, all bathing at tīrthas (holy places) and all dāna (giving) put together.

The Vāmana Purāṇa names ahiṃsā first among the thirteen limbs of the ancient dharma that the rākshasa king Sukeśī heard from the munis and commanded all his people to keep, and Bhagavān Śiva, praising Bhagavān Vishṇu, names ahiṃsā among the virtues that are Vishṇu himself.

The Agni Purāṇa places ahiṃsā first among the dharmas common to all varṇas and āśramas, and first among the five yamas of yoga. Agni Deva calls it the highest dharma, inside which all other dharmas fit as all footprints fit inside an elephant’s, and names the ten kinds of hiṃsā whose giving up is ahiṃsā.

Chapter 114: Ahiṃsā Has Four Parts

Yudhishṭhira said that ṛshis, brāhmaṇas and devas all praise the dharma marked by ahiṃsā, as the Veda confirms. Yet people keep causing hiṃsā (harm) through body, speech and mind. How, then, can they be freed from suffering?

Bhīshma answered that those who know the truth of the Veda have taught that ahiṃsā has four parts: mind, speech, conduct (karaṇa) and eating (bhakshaṇa). If even one of the four slips, ahiṃsā as a whole fails, just as a four-legged animal cannot stand on three legs. And just as an elephant’s footprint covers the footprints of all smaller creatures, so ahiṃsā holds all other dharmas within itself.

A being becomes caught up through mind, speech and conduct, one after the other. So a person who first gives up even the thought of meat, then talk about it, and then the act of eating it, becomes free from hiṃsā in all three ways. Bhīshma says that the brahma-vādins (teachers of the Veda) name three causes as the seats of this fault: mind, speech and rasa (taste, craving). The wise, whose minds are set on tapas (spiritual discipline), do not eat meat at all.

He then teaches that a person who eats meat, knowing that it is no different in kind from the flesh of his own son, yet stays overcome by delusion, is counted the lowest of people. Just as a son is born from the union of father and mother, so hiṃsā, in the same close way, gives birth to the heaviest pāpa-garbha (seed of wrongdoing) for the one who does it.

Every tongue delights in taste, and the taste of meat especially grips the senses and clouds the mind, even against the śāstras. So Bhīshma warns that many people who are otherwise good praise meat without thinking, drawn by its taste. The chapter ends by saying that many sādhus (holy people) have given up even their own lives, feeding others with their own flesh, and so reached svarga.

Chapter 115: Śrāddha and Ahiṃsā

Yudhishṭhira asked Bhīshma a question. Bhīshma had praised ahiṃsā as the highest thing, yet he had also taught that the pitṛs (ancestors) desire meat in śrāddha, and there can be no meat without killing an animal. What, then, is the fault in eating it, and the good in giving it up? Is there a difference between one who kills and eats, one who eats what another has killed and given, and one who buys meat killed by someone else?

Bhīshma’s answer draws on what many ṛshis taught on this very question:

  • Manu Svāyambhuva said that one who does not eat meat, does not kill and does not cause killing is a friend to all beings.
  • Nārada said that one who tries to feed his own flesh with the flesh of another must surely perish.
  • Bṛhaspati said that giving up madya (alcohol) and māṃsa (meat) makes a person equal to one who constantly gives dāna, performs yajña and does tapas. A hundred years of monthly Aśvamedhas and giving up meat bear equal fruit. Giving it up for even one month equals the fruit of an Aśvamedha, and giving it up even once a month or once a fortnight wins Brahmaloka.
  • The Vedas as a whole neither praise nor forbid meat outright. Bhīshma accepts that one who is used to the taste finds it very hard to give up. Yet this very vrata (vow) of abhaya-dāna, giving fearlessness to all beings, is called the highest of all vows, because one’s own prāṇa (life) is as dear to oneself as it is to every other creature. The wise, seeing that life is equally dear to every being, know that ahiṃsā is dharma, tapas, satya (truth) and sukha (happiness) itself. Meat does not come from grass, wood or stone. It only ever comes into being by killing a creature, so the fault cannot be escaped.

Vṛthā-Māṃsa and Consecrated Meat

Bhīshma then draws a key distinction.

Vṛthā-māṃsa is meat taken for no sacred purpose, not consecrated, and against vidhi (the proper rule). It must never be eaten. One who eats it goes to naraka (the lower world of suffering) without doubt.

Meat that is prokshita (sprinkled with water made holy by mantras, with the palm facing down) or abhyukshita (sprinkled with the palm facing up), and that a brāhmaṇa seeks for pitṛ-karma (rites for the ancestors) or yajña-karma, carries only a slight dosha. Meat eaten outside this setting wraps the eater in heavy pāpa.

The person who kills the animal for someone else to eat takes on heavier pāpa than the one who only eats. One who kills animals on the excuse of deva-pūjā, yajña or Vedic vidhi, but really out of craving for the taste, without truly understanding the inner meaning of the yajña, goes to naraka. But one who once ate meat without knowing better, and then turned away from it, gains great dharma precisely because he turned away.

Bhīshma tells the old itihāsa (true account) of King Vasu of Cedi. The ṛshis once asked him whether meat, though generally forbidden, could in fact be eaten in ritual settings. Vasu said that it could. The very act of saying so made him fall from the sky back to the earth. This shows how dangerous it is to approve of eating meat without limits.

Bhīshma also says that in the first kalpa (the earliest age), those who performed yajñas used a paśu (sacrificial animal) “made of grain” (vrīhi-maya) as a substitute, rather than a living animal. And Agastya, caring for the welfare of all beings, made the wild animals of the forest pure with water blessed by mantras. In this way the rites for the pitṛs and the devas would not fail for lack of proper offerings, while their killing was still not required.

The Kings Who Gave Up Meat

Bhīshma then names the great rājarshis (royal ṛshis) who gave up meat, especially during the bright fortnight of Śrāvaṇa and the four months of the rainy season, and so reached svarga and even Brahmaloka:

He also names Śyenacitra, Somaka, Pṛku, Raivata, Rantideva, Vasu, Sṛñjaya, Kṛpa, Bharata, Dushyanta, Karūsha, Rāma, Alarka, Nara, Virūpāśva, Nimi, Dhīmanta, Janaka, Aila, Pṛthu, Vīrasena, Ikshvāku, Śambhu, Śveta, Sagara, Aja, Dhundhu, Subāhu, Haryaśva, Kshupa, and Bharata again. These and many other mahārājas gave up meat especially in Śarat-kāla (autumn) and the month of Kārtika. So they reached svarga, where they live in Brahmaloka among thousands of apsarās (heavenly dancers), served by gandharvas (heavenly musicians).

Bhīshma ends by saying that anyone who practises, recites or hears this teaching on giving up meat, however wicked in other ways, never falls into durgati (a bad fate). Such a person:

  • Is freed from all pāpa
  • Gains every wish
  • Wins the highest honour among his relatives
  • If in distress, is freed from distress; if bound, is freed from bondage; if sick, is freed from sickness; if sorrowing, is freed from sorrow
  • Is never born as an animal or bird
  • Gains rūpa (beauty), dhana (wealth) and great yaśas (fame)

Chapter 116: The Fruit of Ahiṃsā

Yudhishṭhira admitted that he was still confused. People crave meat above all the finest sweets and delicacies, acting almost like rākshasas in their craving. He wished to hear even more fully the good of giving it up and the harm of eating it.

Bhīshma agreed that nothing beats meat for taste. It is especially valued by the wounded, by those given to pleasure, and by travellers worn out by the road, because it quickly brings back strength. Still, he taught the following in favour of giving it up:

  • One who wants to feed his own flesh with another’s flesh is the lowest of beings, because nothing in the world is dearer to any creature than its own life. So a person should show others the same dayā (compassion) he shows himself.
  • Meat comes only from śukra (seed). So eating it does great harm, while giving it up wins great puṇya (merit), as the wise say.
  • One who eats meat allowed by Vedic vidhi does not fall into pāpa, since the Veda itself says that paśus were created for yajña. Any other way of acting is called “rākshasa vidhi”, the rule of the rākshasas.
  • For kshatriyas (warriors) in particular, meat won by one’s own strength in the hunt (mṛgayā) is not a fault. Forest animals belong to no one and are set aside for all the devas, so they are held to be consecrated (prokshita) for everyone, following the example Agastya set. The hunted animal may itself kill the hunter, and this equal footing (samatā) removes the fault from the act. That is why rājarshis go hunting.
  • Even so, dayā toward all beings is the higher path. The compassionate person fears nothing anywhere. This world belongs to the compassionate, just as the next world belongs to the tapasvī (one who practises tapas), because ahiṃsā is the very lakshaṇa (mark) of dharma.
  • One who gives abhaya (fearlessness) to all beings receives abhaya from all beings in return.
  • The tapas of the non-violent never grows less. The non-violent person is always a performer of yajña, and is mother and father to all beings.
  • Every creature fears death equally and trembles at the moment of dying. Beings suffer through garbha-vāsa (life in the womb), birth and old age, tormented in the womb by sour, bitter and sharp fluids, urine and waste. And those who are addicted to meat are themselves cut apart and eaten in their turn.
  • The word māṃsa (meat) itself is explained: “he (the animal) will eat me (in a future life), so I eat him (now)”, māṃ saḥ khādatīti “māṃsa”. The killer is killed in turn and the eater is eaten in turn, because each acts by the same law in which fruit follows karma exactly.

The chapter reaches its peak in the famous declaration:

Ahiṃsā paramo dharmaḥ, ahiṃsā paramo damaḥ, ahiṃsā paramaṃ dānam, ahiṃsā paramaṃ tapaḥ. Ahiṃsā paramo yajñaḥ, ahiṃsā paramaṃ phalam, ahiṃsā paramaṃ mitram, ahiṃsā paramaṃ sukham. “Non-harming is the highest dharma, the highest self-control, the highest dāna, the highest tapas. Non-harming is the highest yajña, the highest fruit, the highest friend, the highest happiness.”

Bhīshma declares that the dāna given in all yajñas together, the merit of bathing at all tīrthas, and the fruit of all kinds of dāna combined, do not equal ahiṃsā. The tapas of the non-violent never fades, and the non-violent person is always a yajvā (performer of yajña), and mother and father to all beings. He tells Yudhishṭhira that even a hundred years would not be enough to tell all the virtues of ahiṃsā.

Per Vāmana Purāṇa

The first limb of Sukeśī’s dharma

The rākshasa king Sukeśī asked the munis to teach him dharma, and they taught him at length. Returning to his city, Sukeśī gathered all the rākshasas devoted to dharma and said: “Rākshasas! I have heard from the munis the form of dharma, ancient and auspicious. I command all of you to practise it without any hesitation.” Its thirteen limbs, in his order, are:

  1. ahiṃsā (non-violence)
  2. satya (truth)
  3. asteya (not stealing)
  4. brahmacarya
  5. amānitva (freedom from pride)
  6. śauca (purity)
  7. restraint of the senses
  8. dāna (giving)
  9. dayā (compassion)
  10. kshānti (patience)
  11. auspicious, sweet speech
  12. constant eagerness in doing good deeds
  13. sadācāra (good conduct)

“These give the higher worlds,” said Sukeśī. By his command all the rākshasas kept this thirteen-limbed dharma with steadfastness and joy, and by its power they grew in sons and grandsons, in strength and in wealth.

Source: Vāmana Purāṇa, Chapter 16

Ahiṃsā is Vishṇu

In the stotra with which Bhagavān Śiva praised Bhagavān Vishṇu at Kurujāṅgala, when he sought release from Brahmahatyā, he declared: “Dharma, yajña, tapas, satya, ahiṃsā, śauca, ārjava (straightness), kshamā (forbearance), dāna, dayā, Lakshmī and brahmacarya: all are you.”

Source: Vāmana Purāṇa, Chapter 3

Per Agni Purāṇa

The first of the common dharmas

In the Agni Purāṇa, Agni Deva tells how Pushkara taught Paraśurāma the dharmas by which Manu and the others gained bhukti (enjoyment in the world) and mukti (moksha). Pushkara first gives the dharmas common to all varṇas and all āśramas (sādhāraṇa dharma), which give delight to Vāsudeva and the others. Ahiṃsā stands first among them, followed by satya (truthfulness), bhūtadayā (compassion for all beings), a mind disposed to help others, going to tīrthas, dāna, brahmacarya, freedom from envy, honouring the devatās and brāhmaṇas, service of the guru, hearing all the dharmas, honouring the pitṛs, loyalty to the king, learning only with the help of the best śāstras, freedom from cruelty, kshamā (forbearance) and faith in the Veda and the higher world.

Source: Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 151

The first of the yamas

Agni Deva teaches the yoga of eight limbs (ashṭāṅga yoga) for the removal of the burning pain of saṃsāra. Its first limb is the five yamas: ahiṃsā, satya, asteya (not stealing), brahmacarya and aparigraha (not gathering possessions).

Ahiṃsā is not causing pain to living beings. It is the highest dharma. As the footprints of all who walk on a road fit inside the footprint of an elephant, so all dharmas fit inside ahiṃsā.

Hiṃsā (harm) is of ten kinds:

  1. causing agitation to others;
  2. causing them affliction;
  3. causing them disease;
  4. making blood come out of their body;
  5. carrying tales;
  6. obstructing their welfare;
  7. revealing their secrets;
  8. taking away their happiness;
  9. binding them without cause;
  10. killing.

Not doing these is ahiṃsā.

Source: Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 372

Per Brahma Purāṇa

The munis asked Vyāsa whether there is any means of going in comfort along the terrible road to Yama-loka. Vyāsa answered that those who in this world are devoted to dharma and given to ahiṃsā, who served the guru and worshipped the devas and brāhmaṇas, do not go by the road of Yama at all, together with their wives, sons and family; they go to the world of Dharmarāja in divine vimānas with golden banners, served by apsarās. Among those who go in comfort he names those who caused no pain to others, those with compassion for all beings and those who gave abhaya (freedom from fear), and also those who had truth and purity and did not eat meat.

Then Vyāsa spoke of not eating meat. Among all foods to chew and eat there is nothing tastier than meat, yet one who desires the good of others should not eat it. Brahmā, the best of all knowers of the Veda, has said that one who does not touch meat and one who gives a thousand cows are equal. The puṇya that comes from resorting to all tīrthas and performing all yajñas comes from not eating meat alone.

Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Chapter 216

Sources

  • Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapter 114
  • Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapter 115
  • Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapter 116
  • Vāmana Purāṇa, Chapters 3, 16
  • Agni Purāṇa, Chapters 151, 372
  • Brahma Purāṇa, Chapter 216