Ātma-Tattva: The Nature of the Self

Ātma-Tattva · ātma-tattva, “the truth of the Self”

Ātma-tattva means “the truth about the self”. The Bhāgavata Purāṇa, in Skandha 11, Chapter 28, holds Bhagavān Kṛshṇa‘s clear, step-by-step teaching on this subject to his devotee Uddhava. He explains the difference between the ātman (the true self) and the anātman (what is not the self). He explains what bondage and freedom are, and how bondage comes from ahaṃkāra (the sense of “I” and “mine”) alone, even though the ātman is always free. He also describes how the jīvanmukta, one who is freed while still living, lives and acts in the world.

The teaching ends with a central idea: moksha (liberation) is not something new that one gets. It is the recognition of what has always been true. It is simply the removal of the veil of ignorance that hid the self’s natural light.

The source names the chapter “Ātma Tattva Nirūpaṇa”, the setting out of the truth of the ātmā. But this truth runs through the whole Bhāgavata Purāṇa. Śrī Śuka Maharshi opens his teaching to Parīkshit with it and closes with it, as the king waits for Takshaka. Bhagavān Kapila teaches it to his mother Devahūti. Sanatkumāra teaches it to Pṛthu, and Nārada Maharshi hides it in the account of Purañjana for King Prācīnabarhis. Jaḍabharata teaches it to King Rahūgaṇa, the very king who had insulted him. Bhagavān Saṅkarshaṇa teaches it to Citraketu, and the boy Prahlāda teaches it to his schoolfellows in the house of Hiraṇyakaśipu. Yaśodā comes to know it in Gokula. Śrī Kṛshṇa gives it to the gopīs at Samantapañcaka and to Vasudeva at Dvārakā, and Balarāma gives it to Rukmiṇī. Everywhere the teaching is the same: the ātmā is one, self-luminous, unborn and undying, the witness of body, senses and mind, untouched by puṇya and pāpa; it seems bound only through ajñāna (ignorance); and that ātmā is not different from Śrī Hari, the dearest of all.

How the teaching opens

Within Śrī Śuka Maharshi’s telling to Parīkshit, Bhagavān Kṛshṇa speaks to Uddhava. He begins with conduct. The substratum of this world, made of prakṛti and purusha, is the non-dual Parabrahman. Seeing this, the sādhaka should neither praise nor blame the nature or the actions of others. One who clings to the unreal world praises and blames them, and he quickly slips from the purushārtha, the true goal of human life.

The dream and deep sleep. When sleep dissolves the senses, the jīva dwelling in the body sees a false dream with the mind. When the mind too is dissolved, he reaches deep sleep, which is like death. In the same way the ajñānī who takes manyness to be true wanders in a dream-like, unreal world and lies in ignorance, which is a form of death. Duality is unreal: in it, what is auspicious and what is inauspicious? Whatever the mind imagines and speech speaks is untrue. Reflections, echoes and the snake seen in a rope are untrue, yet people deal with them: a man puts on his tilaka by looking at his reflection, and is afraid when he sees a rope as a snake. In the same way the body and the other seen things, though untrue, cause fear until death.

The Paramātmā becomes all. The Paramātmā is able to become everything; he is the innermost self of all and the indweller of all. He creates himself as this world, sustains himself and withdraws himself. So nothing can be called other than the ātmā, as if the created world were one thing and the creating Paramātmā another. The mahātmās have shown that the world which appears in the ātmā, with its divisions of ādhyātmika, ādhibhautika and ādhidaivika, and of waking, dream and deep sleep, is not the highest truth. This world of three kinds, dravya, śakti and vijñāna (substance, power and knowing), is the product of sattva, rajas and tamas; though it does not really exist, it shines as though it exists, because of ajñāna. One who knows this steadiness of jñāna (knowledge of the śāstra) and vijñāna (the experience of the ātmā) neither blames nor praises anything in the world. He moves about like the sun, unattached and the same to all.

Four ways to know that the world is mithyā. What did not exist before birth and does not exist after death does not exist in the present either; though it is seen, it is unreal. The sādhaka should know this truth in four ways:

  • By pratyaksha (perception): what exists is the clay, not the pot.
  • By anumāna (inference): this world is unreal, because it has a beginning and an end, like a pot.
  • By the Veda: neha nānāsti kiñcana, “here there is no manyness at all”.
  • By his own experience: everything shines by the movement of one’s own mind.

The jñānī who knows this moves in the world unattached.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

The Nature of Bondage

Uddhava asked a basic question. The ātman shines by its own light. It is never born, it is beyond the guṇas (the three qualities of nature) and it is untouched by ignorance. The body has no life of its own, like a log of wood. Neither of them can truly experience saṃsāra (the cycle of birth and death). So who is it that is bound?

In Uddhava’s own words: “O Īśvara! The ātmā is the one who sees; the body is what is seen. The ātmā is imperishable and beyond time, without guṇas, pure (without puṇya and pāpa), self-luminous like fire, without the covering of ajñāna; the body is inert like a log. Saṃsāra, joy and sorrow, cannot belong to the ātmā, nor to the inert body. Yet it is experienced. To which of the two does it belong?”

Bhagavān Kṛshṇa answered that bondage comes from the ātman seeming to take itself to be the non-self: the body, the senses, the prāṇas (life-breaths) and the mind. This mistaken identity (tādātmya) is produced by avidyā (ignorance), which has no beginning and which lays the non-self over the self. As long as this mistake lasts, saṃsāra seems real and important. Even though saṃsāra is itself mithyā (not truly real), it causes suffering just as strongly as a dream causes suffering to the dreamer.

A person who falls from deep sleep into a dream does not question whether the dream is real. In the same way, the jīva (the individual soul) caught in avidyā does not question whether the world is real. And just as the sufferings of a dream vanish the moment the dreamer wakes up, the sufferings of saṃsāra vanish the moment ātma-jñāna (knowledge of the self) arises.

For the jīva who broods on enjoyments, Bhagavān Kṛshṇa said, the wandering in saṃsāra does not stop, like a danger in a dream and the sorrow it brings; but for one who has woken, the dream causes no distress. Grief, joy, fear, anger, greed, delusion, desires, despair and the like, and birth and death, are experienced by the ahaṅkāra alone, not by the ātmā. The root tattva within the body, the senses, prāṇa, apāna and the mind is the Paramātmā itself. Because of the sense of “I” and “mine” in them, that Paramātmā is called the jīva; in the collective this jīva has many names, such as sūtrātmā and mahat-tattva, and, subject to Kāla (time), it wanders everywhere in saṃsāra. The ahaṅkāra, born of identification with mind, speech, prāṇa and apāna, the body and karmas, has no root: it is not the real tattva, yet it shines in many forms. The sādhaka given to reflection should cut it with the sword of discriminating knowledge and, free of desires, move about on the earth.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

What the Anātman Is

Bhagavān Kṛshṇa listed what the ātman is not:

  • The physical body and all that comes from it
  • The five jñāna-indriyas (sense organs) and the devatās linked with them
  • Prāṇa, apāna and the other life forces
  • The manas (the mind that desires and doubts)
  • The buddhi (the intellect that decides)
  • The citta (the power of memory and reflection)
  • The ahaṃkāra (the sense of “I”)
  • The five great elements: ākāśa (space), vāyu (air), agni (fire), jala (water) and pṛthvī (earth)
  • The three guṇas and their source, avyakta prakṛti (unmanifest nature)

None of these is the ātman. The ātman is the unchanging witness, pure awareness, in which all of these appear and disappear.

In the chapter’s words, the body is a modification of earth; the devatās are those who favour the senses; the mind is that which resolves and doubts and grows by food; and prakṛti is the state of balance of the three guṇas. “None of these is the ātmā; this is certain.” For the body and the rest, Bhagavān Kṛshṇa told Uddhava, sattva and the other guṇas are the material cause and dharma and adharma the instrumental cause. In ajñāna one takes the body so made to be one’s own nature; when ātma-jñāna arises, that adhyāsa (superimposition) ceases. The ātmā is not a seen thing to be known; and since the ātmā is oneself, it is not something that can be given up either.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

The True Ātman

The true ātman is:

  • Svayaṃprakāśa: shining by its own light; it needs nothing outside itself to make it known
  • Aja: unborn; it was never born and will never die
  • Avināśī: imperishable; it cannot be lessened, changed or destroyed
  • Nirguṇa: beyond the three guṇas; sattva, rajas and tamas belong to prakṛti (nature), not to the ātman
  • Sarvajña: all-knowing, in the sense that it is the ground of all knowing
  • Kevala: completely one, with no second
  • Advaita: not two; the seeming many separate selves are māyā (the power that makes the one appear as many)

Words and thoughts cannot reach the ātman. They turn back from it, unable to hold it. Yet it is what makes all speech and thought possible. It is the witness of the three states, waking, dreaming and deep sleep, and is itself the fourth, turīya, the ground beneath all three.

In the chapter’s own description, the ātmā is self-luminous, unborn, not reached by perception or any other means of knowing, of great glory, a mass of consciousness, the witness of all, all-knowing, one, without a second. Words turn back, unable to reach it, and impelled by it speech and the other senses act. To imagine difference in it is only an error of the buddhi, and even that error has no support other than the ātmā, which is one’s own nature.

Gold and its ornaments. The ātma-tattva that is at the beginning and the end of this world is in the middle too; it alone is the cause of the world and makes the world shine. Gold not yet shaped into ornaments is there before the ornaments and after them, and in the middle too, though it is called by many names, such as necklace. “In the same way,” Bhagavān Kṛshṇa said, “I am in the form of this world.”

Anvaya and vyatireka. The mind has three states, waking, dream and deep sleep; the world has three divisions, adhyātma, adhibhūta and adhidaiva; and their root is the three guṇas. All of this shines only in the consciousness of the ātmā: this is anvaya, the ātmā present through all. In samādhi none of it is there, yet the consciousness of the ātmā goes on shining: this is vyatireka, the ātmā standing apart from all. So the ātmā, the fourth, alone is true. An effect that did not exist before it arose and does not exist after it perishes is, in the middle too, only a dealing in name and form; whatever effect a cause makes shine is not different from that cause. “This is my firm conclusion,” said Bhagavān Kṛshṇa. Creation, born of sāttvika, rājasa and tāmasa ahaṅkāra, does not really exist, yet it shines; it is the self-existent Parabrahman that makes it shine, and so it is Parabrahman itself that shines as manyness, as the senses, the tanmātras, the five elements and the jīvas.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

Freedom Is Recognition, Not Gaining Something New

Bhagavān Kṛshṇa set out the key principle. Moksha is not something newly made, or given, or reached by travelling to a far-off place. The ātman is already free. Moksha is the removal of the ignorance that made the ātman seem bound.

When the sun rises, it does not create light. It removes the darkness that was hiding the light already there. In the same way, ātma-jñāna does not create freedom. It removes the veil of avidyā that was hiding the ātman’s natural freedom.

In the chapter’s words: when the realisation of Bhagavān Kṛshṇa as the ātmā arises, firm and true, the ajñāna that covered a person’s buddhi is destroyed. Moksha does not come anew. A person’s own nature is moksha.

The means of this removal are three:

  • Śravaṇa: hearing the teaching from a teacher who has realised the truth
  • Manana: reflecting on it with reason and making it one’s own
  • Nididhyāsana: steady contemplation, until the recognition becomes an unbroken, direct experience

Bhagavān Kṛshṇa named the means of jñāna, which is knowing the ātmā as distinct from the non-ātmā, in this way: the Veda (hearing, śravaṇa), tapas (deep contemplation, nididhyāsana), one’s own experience, the instruction of elders, and reasoning (manana). Having heard the śāstra from a skilled guru, the sādhaka should clearly discern Brahman, which is other than the body and the rest and not different from the ātmā. Knowing this, he should reject the idea of “self” in the body, be content with the bliss of his own nature, and turn away from every impression of desire.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

The Jīvanmukta: How the Freed One Lives

Bhagavān Kṛshṇa described the conduct of the jīvanmukta, one who has recognised the ātman while still living in a body:

  • The buddhi of the jñānī (the knower) stays settled in the ātman at all times, whether the body stands, sits, walks, sleeps, eats or does any natural act. The feeling “I am the doer” is gone.
  • Even when the senses take in sounds and sights, the jñānī does not take them to be finally real. He sees them as svapna-tulya (dream-like) creations of the guṇas, and is not fooled by them.
  • If the guṇas rise and stir the mind, the jñānī does not chase them. If they settle, he does not rejoice. He stays as untroubled as the sky is untroubled by the clouds that pass through it.
  • The jñānī neither praises nor blames what others do. Seeing the one Brahman as the ground of all, he moves through the world as the sun moves: untouched, shining, the same towards all.

“Just as the sky is not affected by the heating of fire, the cooling of water, or the drying of wind, because the sky is not involved in those actions, so the ātman is not affected by the guṇas’ actions in the body, though the ahaṃkāra-ridden person believes otherwise.”

The ajñānī who identifies with the body, driven by an ajñāna that cannot be defined, keeps doing karmas until death and keeps receiving joy and sorrow as their fruit. The ātma-jñānī, though he is in the body, is free from all desires through the experience of the bliss of the ātmā; he has no doership and no changes. When his senses turn outward he too sees sound and the other objects, but by the inference “manyness is unreal, because it is seen” he sets the seen aside, as one who has woken does not think the vanished dream-world true. For the jñānī who has clearly realised Bhagavān Kṛshṇa’s nature, what is gained if the senses become one-pointed, and what is lost if they are scattered? Nothing: what does the sun gain when the clouds come, or lose when they go? The drying of air, the burning of fire, the wetting of water, the dust of earth and the cold and heat of the seasons do not touch space. In the same way the good and bad of the guṇas give the sorrow of saṃsāra to the ajñānī who identifies with the body, but do not cling to the imperishable Paramātmā, who is beyond prakṛti.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

The Place of Bhakti in Ātma-Jñāna

Even in this highest teaching about the self, Bhagavān Kṛshṇa affirmed that nishkāma-bhakti (devotion with no selfish desire) is central. The deep-rooted rāga-dvesha (liking and disliking) forms the very core of saṃsāra, and the only sure way to remove it is firm, desireless devotion to Bhagavān Kṛshṇa. Knowledge of philosophy alone, without bhakti, may not go deep enough to pull out the root vāsanās (hidden tendencies). But when the mind is made pure through bhakti, ātma-jñāna arises on its own, naturally, like the sun coming out from behind clouds.

In the chapter’s words, the impurity of the mind is rajoguṇa, and it goes away by the means of firm, desireless bhakti in Bhagavān Kṛshṇa. Until then the sādhaka should not attach himself to sense-enjoyments, even though the products of the guṇas do not shake the jñānī. When a man falls ill and is wrongly treated, the disease sprouts again and again and gives greater pain. In the same way, if the sādhaka does not destroy the rāga and dvesha and the karma-vāsanās in the mind, that mind, attached to everything, torments him while he lacks discrimination between ātmā and non-ātmā.

The fallen yogī. For those who practise yoga, the devatās create obstacles in the form of kinsmen and friends. Those who fall from yoga because of them take up the practice again in the next birth, by the strength of the practice of the former birth. They do not fall into the sprawl of karmas.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

Those who hold duality to be real

Some argue that this duality, the world of the five elements known by the senses as name and form, cannot be set aside and is true. They imagine themselves to be learned. In their view, the Upanishad statement that teaches the oneness of Brahman and ātmā is only an arthavāda (a statement of praise) subordinate to the statements about karma. Bhagavān Kṛshṇa said there is no substance in this view, because no purpose is seen in the oneness of the ātmā being subordinate to karma.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

Illness and obstacles in yoga

When a sādhaka not yet ripe in yoga is practising, diseases may arise in the body and obstruct him. Bhagavān Kṛshṇa told Uddhava what to do:

  • Some troubles that come as disease the sādhaka should remove by meditating on devatās such as Sūrya.
  • Others go away by practising āsanas joined with the holding of the breath.
  • Tapas, mantra-japa and medicines also remove diseases completely, as the case may be.
  • Troubles that bring harm, such as desire and anger, he should slowly remove by meditating on Bhagavān Kṛshṇa without a break, by nāma-saṅkīrtana and mantra-japa, or by following the mahātmās established in yoga.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

Striving for siddhis

Some who have conquered their senses make the body very strong and fixed in youth, and then strive for the yoga-siddhis (powers). But the body is like the fruit of a tree: it falls. So the discerning do not value the striving for the powers of yoga; such striving, full of toil, is useless. If one practises yoga every day, the body becomes strong by itself; even then the discerning one whose supreme goal is Bhagavān Kṛshṇa alone should not care much about that firmness of the body, and should not give up his practice.

The phala. “If the sādhaka thus takes refuge in me alone and practises this yoga without desire, obstacles do not trouble him. Moreover, he experiences the bliss of the ātmā.”

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 28

The ātmā throughout the Bhāgavata Purāṇa

The teaching of the 28th chapter gathers up what the Bhāgavata Purāṇa says of the ātmā from its second skandha to its last. Each teacher gives it in his own setting.

Śuka’s first teaching to Parīkshit (Skandha 2)

Śrī Śuka Maharshi tells Parīkshit that those intensely attached to worldly life cannot know the nature of the ātmā; for them the things to hear and remember are countless. Parameśvara, being in all beings as their ātmā, sees and experiences the whole world through their minds. Śrī Hari, who is without decay, dwells by nature in all beings as their ātmā; he alone is the real thing in creation, and because he is the ātmā he is also the most dear. Kāla, which rules even the devatās, cannot bring the ātmā under its sway, and the devatās, rulers of the lokas, cannot rule it; it is beyond sattva, rajas and tamas. Sūta tells the ṛshis that Śuka’s words established the nature of the ātmā for Parīkshit; and in his maṅgala namaskāras to Śrī Hari, Śuka says that the knowers of the ātmā worship Śrī Hari as the ātmā, the vaidikas as the form of the Veda, the dhārmikas as dharma and the tapasvīs as the form of tapas.

In the ninth chapter Śuka begins with the ātmā itself. The consciousness of the ātmā, whose nature is pure experience, is wholly different from the body and the rest. It has in truth no connection with the body and the other seen things, as a dreamer has none with the things seen in his dream. Yet through the māyā of the Paramātmā that connection comes about, and as māyā shows itself as devatās, humans, childhood and youth, the ātmā’s consciousness seems to take many forms in those upādhis (limiting adjuncts). Then the definition that Bhagavān Śrī Hari himself gives to Brahmā: that which in all places and times continues as the cause, yet in the highest truth is different from the effect; which continues as the light in waking and every other experience, yet is a mass of consciousness (cid-ghana) beyond them all: that is the ātmā. The seeker who wishes to know the ātmā needs only this inquiry.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapters 1–2, 4, 9

Maitreya, Brahmā and Bhagavān Kapila (Skandha 3)

Maitreya tells Vidura that as the trembling of water seems to belong to the moon reflected in it, the qualities of the body and the non-self seem to belong to the ātmā, which sees them, though they are not its own. In Brahmā‘s stuti to Śrī Hari, saṃsāra does not leave a man until he sees that his own self, distinct from body and senses, is not separate from Bhagavān Śrī Hari. And Bhagavān Śrī Hari says to Brahmā: “Many things give joy to beings, but the Ātmā is dearer than all. It is because love for the Ātmā is reflected in the body and the rest that they become dear. I am that Ātmā. Therefore a man should give bhakti to me.”

Bhagavān Kapila teaches his mother Devahūti that the ātmā is advaya (without a second), beyond prakṛti, without inside or outside, self-luminous, beyond the means of knowing, without “you” and “I”, the witness of the pairs of opposites. The Purusha, beginningless, nirguṇa and beyond prakṛti, is the ātmā, the most subtle and self-luminous tattva in body and senses, and the world is pervaded by the ātmā’s consciousness and shines by it. The jñānī knows that waking and the other states belong to the buddhi and do not stain the ātmā. As the sun on a wall is a reflection of the sun in a pool, which reflects the sun in the sky, so the light of consciousness in body, senses and antaḥkaraṇa is the reflection of the light of ahaṅkāra, and that is the light of Sat itself. In sleep the subtle bhūtas, the senses, mind and buddhi merge in the avyākṛta, but the ātmā’s consciousness does not sleep: it ever sees, and it lights up that state. Body, senses, mind, buddhi and ahaṅkāra have the ātmā’s consciousness as their ground and shine in it.

In the ashṭāṅga yoga Kapila tells how dhyāna ends. When the mind loses its support of ahaṅkāra and of any object, it merges in the ātmā like a lamp flame whose oil is spent. The sādhaka is freed from identification with the upādhi of the body and sees the undivided ātma-tattva, without meditator and meditated, as the ground of all. As a man thinks his son and wealth are himself and yet is plainly different from them, so the kshetrajña purusha is distinct from the body. And as fragrance travels on the wind to the nose, the mind purified by bhakti-yoga reaches its source, the ātmā.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 3, Chapters 7, 9, 25–29

Pṛthu, Sanatkumāra and Nārada (Skandha 4)

In his stuti to Bhagavān Śiva, Brahmā says that beasts and the ignorant lose themselves in anger, but the mahātmās keep their minds on Śiva’s feet, see him pervading all beings as their ātmā, and see the whole world as not different from the ātmā.

Śrī Hari teaches Pṛthu: only because a person does not know that his own nature is complete do desires arise; karmas follow, and the body is their fruit. So the discerning one has no “I” and “mine” in the body, and keeps no sense of “mine” in house, children and wealth. He sets the marks of the ātmā against the body: it is without a second, while bodies are many; untouched by puṇya and pāpa; self-luminous, while the body is inert; without guṇas though their substratum; all-pervading, since all shines in its consciousness; without covering; the witness of all; without internal difference; and so distinct from the body. One who knows the ātmā, which shows itself as “I” in every being, as distinct from the body, is one with Śrī Hari, and the guṇas do not stain him. The ātmā, witness of body, jñānendriyas, karmendriyas and mind, is unchanged, and knowing it gives jīvanmukti. Reflected in the aggregate of bhūtas, indriyas with their devatās and antaḥkaraṇa, the ātmā makes them shine; but the jīva of the liṅga śarīra meets pleasure, pain and delusion birth after birth.

Pṛthu welcomes the Kumāras: as men cannot recognise the Ātmā or the tattvas, so ordinary people do not recognise them as they travel. Sanatkumāra teaches that the Ātmā is dearest of all, that the body is loved only through its relation to it, and that to destroy the knowledge of the Ātmā is the greatest ruin of one’s own good.

Nārada Maharshi tells King Prācīnabarhis how Malayadhvaja realised the ātmā: it pervades the whole aggregate of body, senses and mind yet is distinct from it; as in a dream, knower and known shine only in its consciousness. Knowing it as the witness of the inner faculty, he withdrew from all activity, and he saw the ātmā in Parabrahman and Parabrahman in the ātmā. Then Nārada explains the account of Purañjana. For want of viveka (discrimination) the guṇas of the buddhi are laid on the ātmā, so that the ātmā, though only the witness, seems to undergo the buddhi’s changes. The jīva’s true nature is the nirguṇa ātmā; it comes to be by laying the properties of prāṇa, senses and mind on the ātmā. A person is self-luminous, and there is no difference between Bhagavān Śrī Hari, the Guru of gurus, and one’s innermost ātmā. The ātmā alone is real and the world mithyā, and only nishkāma bhakti to Śrī Hari removes ajñāna and turns back saṃsāra. The ātmā, dearest to all, is Śrī Hari himself; so there is no fear from Śrī Hari, and he who knows Śrī Hari as the ātmā is the jñānī, one with Śrī Hari, and the true guru. Nārada calls the whole account a parokshakathana, the truth of the ātmā told hidden in a narrative, and Maitreya gives its phalaśruti: whoever hears it, or causes others to hear it, is released from the liṅga śarīra and attains moksha.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 4, Chapters 6, 20, 22, 28–29

Jaḍabharata and Rahūgaṇa (Skandha 5)

Śuka tells Parīkshit how Jaḍabharata, established in the ātmā, carried the palanquin of King Rahūgaṇa. The king puts his doubt: fire heats the vessel, the vessel heats the water, the water cooks the rice; so surely the joys and sorrows of body, senses, prāṇas and antaḥkaraṇa pass to the ātmā too. Jaḍabharata answers that the ātmā stands in every state only as the witness of the visible world. Identification with the guṇas is the ātmā’s apara (lower) state; beyond the guṇas is its natural para (higher) state. The countless modifications of the mind have existence and shining only from the ātma-caitanya that witnesses the field, not from any real union of ātmā and anātmā, nor of their own. Nārāyaṇa, Vāsudeva, beyond Time and the ruler of all, is directly present in the body as that ātmā. Until he inquires into the ātmā and knows his own nature, the sādhaka wanders in saṃsāra. So Jaḍabharata taught the truth of the ātmā to the very king who had insulted him, and Rahūgaṇa gave up the notion that the body is the ātmā.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 5, Chapters 10–11, 13

Citraketu and Bhagavān Saṅkarshaṇa (Skandha 6)

When Nārada Maharshi brings back the jīva of Citraketu‘s dead son, the jīva speaks: the true nature of the jīva is the unattached ātmā; for it there is no dear one and no enemy, no “own” and no “other”; doership of dharma and adharma belongs to the buddhi, and the ātmā is pure seeing. The ātmā has no contact with puṇya and pāpa, nor with sukha and duḥkha; it stays in its own nature and witnesses cause and effect. Then Bhagavān Saṅkarshaṇa teaches Citraketu: in the world of name and form the ātmā pervades, and the world rests in the ātmā; he, the undivided Sat, is the ground of both. The states of waking and the rest are imagined in the ātmā through ignorance; the witness by which one knows deep sleep is Parabrahman itself. A person’s true nature is not different from Saṅkarshaṇa; if he forgets this, saṃsāra comes, one body after another, one death after another. Only in a human birth is there the chance to know the ātmā, and that knowledge is the purushārtha. Later, accepting the śāpa of Devī Pārvatī, Citraketu says: neither one’s own ātmā nor another gives sukha and duḥkha; only the ignorant think one of them is the doer.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 6, Chapters 16–17

Prahlāda and the asuras (Skandha 7)

Śuka tells Parīkshit that sattva, rajas and tamas are guṇas of the māyā-śakti, not of the ātmā, and do not all grow or decline at once. As fire is brought out of wood by churning, the jñānīs, by ātma-vicāra (inquiry into the self), set aside the anātmā, know Bhagavān Śrī Hari as the consciousness in the buddhi, and become one with him.

Nārada tells Yudhishṭhira how Hiraṇyakaśipu consoled his family with a teaching on the ātmā: it is beyond time, imperishable, without pāpa and puṇya, all-pervading, all-knowing, beyond prakṛti; by its māyā it creates bodies and takes on a subtle body. As trees reflected in moving water seem to move, and the earth seems to spin to spinning eyes, the changeless ātmā seems to change with the mind. By adhyāsa through ajñāna it seems to meet and part with things, to act, to enjoy saṃsāra, to be born and die and to grieve. In the old account he cites, Yama tells the kinsmen of King Suyajña of Uśīnara: beings are born and perish with bodies suited to their karma, but the ātmā, though manifest in the body, is not bound by the guṇas. A man is other than the house of five elements he lives in; bodies arise, change and perish like bubbles of water. Fire is distinct from the wood it pervades, air from the body, and space touches nothing; so the full ātmā is beyond the guṇas and the body. The prāṇa is chief in the body, but it is not the prāṇa that heard and answered; the witness ātmā is distinct from body and prāṇa. And in the resolve of his tapas that the devas report to Brahmā, Hiraṇyakaśipu reasons that the ātmā does not perish when the body perishes, and time keeps moving, so over any number of births he would gain his goal.

Prahlāda tells his father’s purohitas that Bhagavān Śrī Hari is himself the ātmā, and that for those who hold the idea of “mine” and “other” it is very hard to worship him. To his schoolfellows he teaches the ātmā in full. As a fruit’s six changes, birth, existing, growing, maturing, decaying and perishing, do not belong to the tree, the body’s changes do not pass to the ātmā. The ātmā is beyond Kāla and does not decay; there is no second beside it, so there is no rāga or dvesha in it; it is the eternal witness of the field of body, senses and mind; it is the support of the world, changeless, self-luminous, the cause of the world, all-pervading yet touching nothing, full, without covering. As a gold-maker draws the gold out of the stones of the mine by many known methods, the seeker should practise dhyāna and the other means and realise Brahman as the ātmā in the body itself. Petty sense-enjoyments perish with the body and bring dangers; the ātmā is a great ocean of bliss and needs none of them. The jīva does karmas with the body and gets another body; not knowing its difference from the body, it spreads body and karma.

In the dharma of the sannyāsī, Nārada tells Yudhishṭhira the teaching of Dattātreya to Prahlāda: the nature of the jīva is the treasure-house of happiness, and it shines forth when all activity ceases; enjoyment comes only when the mind meets objects through the senses. The muni dissolves the māyā-śakti into the experience of the ātmā and, steady in the ātmā and free of doership, ceases from the path of pravṛtti. For the householder, the body ends in worms, filth or ashes, but the ātmā is the cause even of ākāśa.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 7, Chapters 1–3, 5, 7, 13–14

In the account of Śrī Kṛshṇa (Skandha 10)

Vasudeva counsels Kaṃsa: as one sun or moon reflected in many pools seems to move when the water moves, the one full Ātmā in many bodies takes on the error of being a jīva. In the garbha-stuti the devas say that the jñāna-yogīs realise Śrī Hari as the ātmā through the buddhi and senses, which are lit by the ātmā’s own consciousness. Vasudeva’s stuti at Śrī Kṛshṇa‘s birth says that the body and the rest have no existence apart from the ātmā; they are names and forms resting only on speech, set aside by the wise as superimpositions, while the ignorant think them real. And Kaṃsa himself, seeing Yogamāyā escape, says that as pots made of clay break while the clay remains, bodies are born and die but the ātmā does not change.

When Yaśodā saw the whole world, and Gokula with herself in it, in the open mouth of the child Kṛshṇa, she bowed to the Paramātmā whose form the buddhi cannot grasp, and so the gopī Yaśodā came to know the ātma-tattva.

In his stuti, Brahmā tells Śrī Kṛshṇa that the world appears through not knowing one’s own nature, like a snake in a rope, and that with jñāna it dissolves again into the ātmā. When Parīkshit asks why the gopīs loved Kṛshṇa more than their own children, Śuka answers: to all beings their own ātmā is dearest, and children and wealth are dear for its sake. Even those who think the body is the ātmā hold the body dearer than wealth; even the discerning who hold the body as “mine” hold the ātmā dearer still, for the wish to live stays strong when the body has decayed. “Know that this Śrī Kṛshṇa is the ātmā of all beings.”

In the rains, Śuka says, the “I”-mode lit by the ātmā covers the full ātmā, as clouds lit by the moon cover the moon. The yājñika brāhmaṇas took the dying body for the ātmā, so they took Śrī Kṛshṇa for a man and did not honour him; yet Śrī Kṛshṇa is the ātmā in all beings, the witness of every movement of the intellect. He tells their wives: “I am the ātmā of all and the beloved of all. Prāṇas, buddhi, mind, body, wife, children, wealth and fame are dear only by their relation to the ātmā. What is dearer than the ātmā?”

In his sandeśa to the gopīs, carried by Uddhava, Śrī Kṛshṇa says that the ātmā, dense with knowledge, has no touch of dharma and adharma and does not follow the guṇas; it is other than body and senses; māyā shows itself as waking, dream and deep sleep, and the ātmā is their witness. Akrūra praises him: the upādhis of the ātmā, body and mind, cannot be shown to exist or not to exist, so in the ātmā there is neither birth nor difference, and for Śrī Kṛshṇa there is no bondage and no moksha; we imagine them in him.

After Rukmī is bound and disfigured, Balarāma teaches Rukmiṇī: the ātmā of all beings is one, like the Sun and like ākāśa, beyond prakṛti; the ignorant think the ātmās are many. As the Sun reveals sight and forms and yet is distinct from them, the ātmā gives the body its existence and shining and yet is distinct from it; it has no real union or separation with it. In the war at Bāṇa‘s city, Śrī Rudra praises Śrī Kṛshṇa: to leave him, the dear Ātmā and antaryāmī, for sense-pleasures is to throw away amṛta and eat poison. At dawn in Dvārakā Śrī Kṛshṇa meditates on the pratyagātmā, which, though called Brahman, is not other than the meditator: second-less, imperishable, untouched by avidyā, and, indicated by the māyā-śakti of the three guṇas that create, sustain and dissolve, a mass of sat-cit-ānanda.

At Samantapañcaka, where the Yādavas and the people of Gokula meet at the time of a total eclipse of the sun, Śrī Kṛshṇa teaches the gopīs: as all things are born from the five elements and dissolve back into them, all beings are born from him and dissolve into him; both the body and the enjoying jīva shine in him, the imperishable. By remembering him without ceasing their sense of limitation ended, and they became jīvanmuktas. At Dvārakā he teaches Vasudeva that the ātmā, one, self-luminous, eternal and nirguṇa, appears many through the guṇas it creates; as the elements seem greater or smaller in pots, the ātmā seems many, manifest in humans, hidden in trees, and sized to each body.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 10, Chapters 1–4, 8, 14, 20, 23, 47–48, 54, 63, 70, 82, 85

Śrī Kṛshṇa’s teaching to Uddhava (Skandha 11)

Before the 28th chapter, Bhagavān Kṛshṇa gives Uddhava the truth of the ātmā many times. He tells him to see that the world exists in the substratum of the ātmā’s consciousness, and that the ātmā is not different from Parameśvara, Śrī Kṛshṇa himself. The ātmā must be known not only by the intellect but in experience; then the inner being is full of joy and no obstacle troubles. In the account of Dattātreya and King Yadu, Dattātreya learns from the sky that the ātmā, like ākāśa, is all-pervading, not limited by the body, present in all and one with Parabrahman; and from the sun, that as one sun appears in many pools, the one ātmā appears in many upādhis, though the gross-minded think it many. From Piṅgalā he learns vairāgya: she lived content with what came unsought, with śraddhā in the ātmā, resolved to delight in the ātmā alone.

In the next chapters: dream-objects are imagined in the one ātma-caitanya, the brooding on enjoyments while awake is just as mithyā, and so is the manifoldness known through the senses. As fire is distinct from the wood it burns, the self-luminous ātmā, witness of the gross and subtle bodies, is distinct from them, and it has no touch of puṇya or pāpa. The senses act; the ātmā is unattached; the jīva enjoys the fruits through identification. As a dream-world appears in consciousness, grief, delusion, pleasure, pain and birth appear in the ātmā through ajñāna, and saṃsāra is not real; as one awake has no tie to his dream-body, the knower, though embodied, does not identify with the body. Among the eleven places where Śrī Kṛshṇa is worshipped, the last but one is one’s own self: he is worshipped as the ātmā by giving the body the enjoyments fit for it.

In the Haṃsa-gīti, Bhagavān Śrī Hari as Haṃsa teaches the Sanakādis that sattva, rajas and tamas belong to the buddhi, not to the Ātmā. Bondage is the Ātmā’s identification with the wandering buddhi; the Ātmā is the fourth, beyond the three states and their witness, and by steadfastness in it freedom from objects and citta comes at once. As long as one thinks the world’s manifoldness real, one is ajñānī, dreaming even when awake. Apart from the Ātmā there is no deva and no human; doing karma and reaching svarga are imagined for it as for a dreamer. The Ātmā-tattva that runs through the three states as memory, “I who slept and dreamed am now awake”, is non-dual, and the world, restless as a whirling firebrand, is only the play of the mind. The sādhaka seeking the bliss of the Ātmā gives up the hope of enjoyment and the sense of “I” and “mine”; even if pride in the body seems to come at times, as when he goes for bhikshā, the body cannot delude him; and as a drunkard does not notice whether his cloth is on, he takes no notice whether the body sits, stands, goes or returns under prārabdha. In dhyāna, the mind is drawn from Śrī Kṛshṇa’s face and fixed on the ākāśa-like consciousness of the Ātmā; one with Śrī Kṛshṇa, the sādhaka thinks of nothing further. Jñāna, Śrī Kṛshṇa says, is seeing the one ātmā everywhere.

In the counting of the tattvas, the guṇas belong to prakṛti, not to the ātmā; in the count of sixteen the mind is included in the ātmā. Those turned away from Śrī Kṛshṇa keep disputing whether the ātmā exists, and that dispute, born of taking difference as the highest truth, is futile. The mind, full of karma-impressions and joined with the senses, goes from body to body, and the ātmā follows it only through identification. Youth and old age are changes of the mind; seeing a father die or a son born, one imagines one’s own death or birth, but birth and death belong only to the body, not to the witnessing ātmā. Like one watching dancers who imitates them in his mind, the non-doing ātmā seems through ignorance to take on the states of intellect and body.

In the Bhikshu-gīta the mendicant brāhmaṇa asks: if people cause my sorrow, what has the ātmā to do with it? It is neither doer nor deed; when a man bites his tongue with his own teeth, with whom will he be angry? If the devatās of the senses cause it, doership is theirs; when one limb strikes another, with whom be angry? If the ātmā itself is the cause, nothing comes from another, and there is nothing beside the ātmā; so why anger? Śrī Kṛshṇa then teaches that the effect is not other than the cause and the world is not other than the Paramātmā; only the Ātmā exists, and for one who reflects so, the delusion of “I” and “mine” cannot remain, as darkness cannot after sunrise. The Ātmā-tattva is beyond the three states and pervades them as witness-consciousness. Through Ātma-jñāna one is freed from the jīva’s upādhi and lives in the world unattached, as Purūravas did when he realised Śrī Kṛshṇa within himself as the Ātmā.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapters 7–8, 10–11, 13–14, 19, 22–26

Śuka’s last teaching and Sūta’s close (Skandha 12)

In the account of the pralayas, Śuka tells Parīkshit that without the ātmā’s consciousness the world cannot be shown to exist even in the smallest degree; if it were independent of the ātmā, it would have to be self-luminous like the ātmā, and it is not. When ahaṅkāra, which covers the ātmā, is cut by the weapon of discrimination, the jñānī abides as Parabrahman itself, and that is the ātyantika pralaya.

Then, as Parīkshit waits for Takshaka, Śuka gives him his last teaching. “Give up the thought ‘I shall die’. You were not born before, and you will not perish now. The body was born; it alone will perish.” As fire is different from firewood, the self is different from body and senses; to think one will live on as sons and grandsons is ajñāna. One may dream one’s own head cut off; all that is seen belongs to the body, and the ātmā has no birth and no death. As pot-space becomes the great space when the pot breaks, the jīva merges in Parabrahman when the body dies. As light is a limited lamp while it is joined to oil, vessel, wick and fire, birth and death come to the ātmā only through identification with the body and the workings of the guṇas. The ātmā is self-luminous, beyond cause and effect, the support of all like space, eternal, without destruction or equal, all-pervading.

Sūta then tells Śaunaka and the ṛshis that the seeker should set aside the waves of joy and sorrow, old age and death, hunger and thirst, and rejoice, established in the ātmā. Seekers negate the non-ātmā by neti neti, “not this, not this”, describe the ātmā as the nature of Vishṇu, and embrace it in dhyāna. Those without the pride of “I” in the body and “mine” in the house reach the ātma-tattva, the all-surpassing nature of Parameśvara. Even when hearing has ceased, consciousness hears the unmanifest nāda; the witness in deep sleep is the ātmā; and from that consciousness of the ātmā, the Oṃkāra that rises in the space of the heart brings forth the whole world of sound.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 12, Chapters 4–6

Sources

  • Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapters 1–2, 4, 9; Skandha 3, Chapters 7, 9, 25–29; Skandha 4, Chapters 6, 20, 22, 28–29; Skandha 5, Chapters 10–11, 13; Skandha 6, Chapters 16–17; Skandha 7, Chapters 1–3, 5, 7, 13–14; Skandha 10, Chapters 1–4, 8, 14, 20, 23, 47–48, 54, 63, 70, 82, 85; Skandha 11, Chapters 7–8, 10–11, 13–14, 19, 22–26, 28; Skandha 12, Chapters 4–6