Harihara-Abheda
Harihara-Abheda · hari-hara-abheda, “the oneness of Hari and Hara”
Harihara-abheda is the teaching that there is no difference (abheda, “non-difference”) at all between Hari (Vishṇu, and Kṛshṇa) and Hara (Śiva). Many people think of them as two separate beings. This teaching says they are one reality appearing in two forms.
It is also called Śiva-Vishṇu abheda: Bhagavān Śiva and Bhagavān Vishṇu are not two separate beings but one Parabrahman, the one Supreme Reality.
The Vāmana Purāṇa shows this oneness as a darśana. When the devas could not see Bhagavān Śiva, Bhagavān Vishṇu showed them the Īśvara-liṅga resting on his own heart-lotus; and when they wondered how Hari and Hara could be one, he took the viśvarūpa (all-embracing form) in which Śiva is joined in Hari, holding the marks and weapons of both. The devas, headed by Brahmā, bowed to that form and knew the two to be one.
Per Mahābhārata
Harihara-abheda is taught in the Purusha-māhātmya chapter of the Anuśāsana Parva‘s Umā-Maheśvara Saṃvāda (the conversation between Umā and Maheśvara). Here Śiva himself, under the name Īśvara, gives the teaching. He has just finished teaching Umā the whole of dharma on Himavat (the Himālaya). The gathered ṛshis then ask to hear the māhātmya (greatness) of Vāsudeva (Kṛshṇa), and Śiva answers.
Kṛshṇa as the Source of Brahmā and Śiva
Śiva declares that Kṛshṇa (Hari) is greater than Brahmā himself. He is eternal, the purusha, shining golden like the sun in a cloudless sky, ten-armed, bearing the Śrīvatsa mark, Hṛshīkeśa, and honoured by all the devas. From his garbha (womb) Brahmā was born. From his head Śiva himself was born; Śiva says, “From his head I was born.” From his hair came the grahas (planets). From the hair of his body came the devas and rākshasas. The ṛshis and the eternal lokas (worlds) came from his body. He is himself the home of Brahmā, Pitāmaha’s own house, and the dwelling of all the devas. He is the maker of this whole earth, the Īśvara (ruler) of the three worlds, and the one who at the end dissolves all beings, both sthāvara (unmoving) and jaṅgama (moving).
Śiva says plainly: “I, who am Īśvara, live safely within his very body.” All the devas take shelter within his body and rest there in comfort. Even Brahmā rested peacefully within his garbha. Pitāmaha (Brahmā) himself, being held within Hari’s body, is protected by him.
His Form and Family Line
Śiva then describes Kṛshṇa‘s great form: the Śārṅga bow, the cakra, the Nandaka sword, and Garuḍa, enemy of all serpents, on his dhvaja (banner). He traces Kṛshṇa’s descent through the family of Manu down to Vasudeva (also called Ānakadundubhi) and Kṛshṇa:
Manu → Aṅga → Antargāma → Havirdhāma → Prācīnabarhi → the ten Pracetās → Daksha → Daksha’s daughter → Āditya → Manu → Ilā/Sudyumna → Budha → Purūravā → Āyu → Nahusha → Yayāti → Yadu → Kroshṭā → Vṛjinīvanta → Ushaṅgu → Śūra → Citraratha → a second Śūra (a nephew) → a third, great Śūra → Vasudeva (Ānakadundubhi) → Kṛshṇa
Of Vasudeva’s son it is said that he defeated Jarāsandha, king of Magadha, at Girivraja and freed the kings whom Jarāsandha had imprisoned. He became the foremost of all kings, ruling from Dvārakā in the Śūrasena country.
The Declaration of Oneness
Śiva tells the ṛshis to honour this Vāsudeva exactly as they would honour the eternal Brahmā. He declares, “yo hi māṃ drashṭum icchet”: whoever wishes to see Śiva or Pitāmaha (Brahmā) need only see and honour Vāsudeva, and nothing more needs to be considered. Honouring him is the same as honouring both Śiva and Brahmā together. Whoever pleases Puṇḍarīkāksha (the lotus-eyed Kṛshṇa) also pleases Brahmā and the whole company of devas. Pūjā of Kṛshṇa is itself the parama-dharma (highest dharma), because he has taken avatāra with great tejas (radiance) for the good of the people. He himself created crores of ṛshis for the sake of dharma, including Sanatkumāra and the other ṛshis doing tapas on Gandhamādana.
Balarāma as Śesha (Ananta)
Śiva also says that Balarāma, also called Saṃkarshaṇa, Hali or Bala, fair as a snowy mountain, is the great serpent Ādiśesha, also called Ananta. His flag is a golden tāla (palmyra) tree with three crests. His thousand-hooded head is covered with great serpents. Every divine weapon comes to him the moment he thinks of it. Vishṇu and Rāma (Balarāma, the serpent form of Hṛshīkeśa) are declared to be one and the same avyaya (unchanging) being in two aspects: the eternal Ananta who holds up the earth. Garuḍa, son of Kaśyapa Prajāpati, once asked the devas to let him see the full size of Vishṇu-as-Śesha by his own power, and even he could not find its limit. Śesha holds Bhūdevī (the earth) within his coils in perfect bliss, living within Kṛshṇa‘s own being.
Śiva ends by telling the tapasvīs (ascetics) to honour this “yadu-śreshṭha”, the best of the Yadus, with all their effort.
Per Harivaṃśa
The teaching is given in the Harivaṃśa, in the chapter of the Hariharātmaka Stotra. There Mārkaṇḍeya Muni explains to Brahmā that Kṛshṇa and Śiva share one and the same ātmā (inner self). Their two divine bodies are only two expressions of a single paramātmā (Supreme Self), and Brahmā, Vishṇu and Maheśvara (Śiva) all arose together from a single mūrti (form).
The setting: the battle at Śoṇitapura
Mārkaṇḍeya Muni gives this teaching during the story of Bāṇāsura. Bhagavān Śrī Kṛshṇa and Mahādeva Śiva had fought a mighty battle at Śoṇitapura, each using powerful astras (divine weapons). Brahmā stepped in and reminded Śiva: “You are his second ātmā. It is never right for you to fight with him.” Śiva agreed and entered Kṛshṇa’s body. The two then came out together and embraced, their divine forms joined for a moment. Brahmā saw this wonderful union, was amazed, and asked Mārkaṇḍeya Muni to explain the mystery.
Mārkaṇḍeya’s Explanation
Mārkaṇḍeya explained the teaching in several layers.
One Source, Three Forms
Vishṇu is Brahmā; Vishṇu is Śiva. From one single, undivided mūrti came Brahmā, Vishṇu and Maheśvara. All three, the Trimūrti, are equally loka-kartā (makers of the worlds), loka-nātha (protectors of the worlds), vara-pradātā (givers of boons) and svayambhū (self-born). The three worlds are held up equally by all three.
Each Enters the Other
When Vishṇu enters Rudra’s body, he takes on Rudra’s rūpa (form). When Śiva enters Vishṇu’s body, he takes on Vishṇu’s form. This entering into each other (anyonya-praveśa) is the deepest truth behind their outward look as two separate beings. Rudra, Agni, Vishṇu and Soma together make up this whole universe, and the universe itself is nothing but the joined svarūpa (true form) of Agni and Soma.
The Shared Tapas
Once, the three, Brahmā, Vishṇu and Maheśvara, performed a single tapas (spiritual discipline) together, each half in the form of Ardhanārīśvara (half-female) and half in the form of Ardha-Purusha (half-male). This first tapas is the root of their oneness.
One in All Creation
As clouds, all three rain on the world. As the sun, all three pour out light. As Vāyu (the wind), all three blow through creation. The whole moving universe is their shared expression. They know what has passed, what is present and what is yet to come.
The Statement of Oneness
Mārkaṇḍeya says it most directly:
The ātmā of Śiva and Keśava is one. Only the body is twofold. Without Vishṇu there is no Śiva; without Śiva there is no Vishṇu. That is exactly why they merged into each other in former times. To those Śiva-Keśavas who have merged in this way, I bow.
This clearly separates the ātmā, which is one and undivided, from the śarīra or rūpa (body or form), which shows itself as two for the sake of devotion, for their roles in the world and for loka-vyavahāra (the everyday working of the world). The oneness is at the level of tattva (true nature). The seeming twoness is at the level of form and action.
The Hariharātmaka Stotra
The Hariharātmaka Stotra, the hymn that comes right after this teaching, turns it into a song of praise. Each verse speaks to Rudra and Kṛshṇa at the same time, showing that every quality of one is also a quality of the other. The one who lives on the mountain (Śiva) is also the one who lives in the ocean (Vishṇu). The holder of the trident (Śiva) is also the holder of the cakra (Kṛshṇa). The husband of Umā is also the husband of Lakshmī. The stotra does not join the two by placing one below the other. It holds them as fully equal, two faces of one reality.
Brahmā’s Dream as a Sign
Brahmā had seen a dream, and this dream led him to ask Mārkaṇḍeya his question. In it, Vishṇu wore Śiva‘s marks, the triśūla (trident), the tiger-skin and the paṭṭiśa (a kind of spear), while Śiva rode Garuḍa, Vishṇu’s carrier. Mārkaṇḍeya explains that this was a direct vision of their oneness. In the dream state, the deepest truth rose up in the form of symbols. The marks and carriers that in waking life seem to tell one apart from the other can be swapped, exactly because the two are not different in their deepest nature.
Why This Teaching Matters
This teaching on Harihara-abheda is especially striking because it does not come as a philosophical talk. It comes as a revelation set inside a story of conflict and making peace. Kṛshṇa and Śiva had really fought each other in battle, and the teaching comes out of the ending of that battle. It does not deny that they truly appear separate, for the battle was real. Instead it shows the deeper ground in which that separateness is held and gone beyond.
The Hariharātmaka Stotra was recited by the great ṛshis Vyāsa, Nārada, Bharadvāja, Gārgya, Viśvāmitra, Agastya, Pulastya and Dhaumya. This shows that it is sacred wisdom handed down, not the opinion of one group.
Per Kūrma Purāṇa
The Kūrma Purāṇa states this teaching clearly. After Daksha‘s yajña (fire ritual) is destroyed in Chapter 15, Brahmā himself teaches Daksha and the gathered devas that anyone who sees Vishṇu and Rudra (Śiva) as separate falls into delusion and goes to naraka. The text says plainly: “Yo Haraḥ sa Hariḥ”, “He who is Hara (Śiva) is that same Hari (Vishṇu).”
Chapter 51 adds the teaching of the Caturvyūha, the four forms of Nārāyaṇa. Here the four great tasks of the universe (pure awareness, dissolution, keeping the world going, and creation) belong to Vāsudeva, Śiva, Pradyumna and Aniruddha (Brahmā). All four are aspects of the one Nārāyaṇa.
Background: The Story of Daksha’s Yajña
This teaching was given after Daksha‘s yajña was destroyed. Daksha had left Śiva out of his yajña. He said Śiva was only Hara, a being of tamas (the quality of darkness), and not worthy of the rank of Paramātman (Supreme Self) that he gave to Nārāyaṇa. Dadhīca Ṛshi protested strongly. In the end, Vīrabhadra destroyed the yajña. Śiva himself then appeared there, and the devas and Daksha made peace with Maheśvara. Brahmā, who had seen everything, then took Daksha and the devas aside and gave them the teaching of abheda.
What Dadhīca Said First
Before Brahmā‘s formal teaching, Dadhīca Ṛshi had already spoken of abheda when he faced Daksha:
- “He whose body is the whole world, who is Parameśvara: is Śaṅkara not worshipped with Vedic rites in every yajña?”
- “This Rudra is Mahādeva, the kind Hara, the one who carries the skull (kāpālin). He is Āditya, Bhagavān Sūrya, the blue-throated one, Vilohita.”
- “This shining one with a thousand rays, Viśvakarmā, the one whose form is the three Vedas, who dwells in the form of Rudra: see him!”
- “He is the Supreme Self who lives in the hearts of the wise, the dhārmika (those who live by dharma) and those who teach about Brahman. He is the witness of all, the one of intense radiance. This difference of body connected with Śiva (Śiva-sambandhi śarīra-bheda) is only the form of Kāla (Time).”
Brahmā’s Teaching: The Heart of Abheda
After Śiva had left, Brahmā, the lotus-born (Kamala-sambhava), spoke to Daksha and all the devas. The key words are:
Yo Haraḥ sa Hariḥ.
“The one who is Hara is that Hari.”
Yo Vishṇur evaṃ sa svayam Rudro Mahādevaḥ.
“He who is Vishṇu is himself Rudra, Mahādeva.” There is no doubt about this.
The teaching has three parts:
- Vishṇu creates this world (“etaṃ lokaṃ Vishṇuḥ sṛjati”).
- Īśvara (Śiva) keeps it standing (sthita).
- “In this way this whole world has come from Śiva and Nārāyaṇa.” So the two together are the cause of the world.
Brahmā then gives the teaching on how one reaches moksha: “Those who follow the Vedic path see Vishṇu, the destroyer of pāpa (wrongdoing), and Śiva with an eye of abheda. Such people reach moksha.” And the other side: “Those who, because of moha (delusion) and lack of faith in the Veda, see Vishṇu, the cause of the world, as different from Īśvara, fall into naraka.”
Śiva and Nārāyaṇa as One
Brahmā‘s teaching openly treats the two names as one:
- Sarvātman Parameśvara: Śiva and Vishṇu are the one Supreme Self of all beings.
- “Ādyantarahita pūjyasya Parameśvarasya”: the one worthy of pūjā is the Parameśvara, who has no beginning and no end.
- Brahmā tells Daksha: “Give up the wish to rule over the worlds. Instead, become a devotee of that one (Śiva). By his grace, at the end of this kalpa (world-age), you will become Gaṇādhipati (ruler of the gaṇas).”
- “Give up putting Vishṇu against Śiva! Be faithful to Śiva too.” This shows that the text is speaking to people who, like Daksha, praise Vishṇu while belittling Śiva.
The Four Vyūhas: Chapter 51
Chapter 51 comes in the section that describes the manvantaras (the long periods each ruled by a Manu). It carries the abheda teaching further with the Caturvyūha, the “four-fold form”.
Bhagavān Nārāyaṇa is said to fill all existence with just one aṃśa (portion) of himself. He exists in four vyūhas (forms):
| Vyūha | Guṇa / Nature | Name | Task |
|---|---|---|---|
| First | Nirguṇa (beyond the guṇas), whose form is jñāna (knowledge) | Vāsudeva | Pure awareness; beyond the guṇas; the supreme Brahman |
| Second | Tamo-guṇa (darkness), called Kāla (Time) | Śiva | Dissolution at the end; the tāmasika body of the Parameśvara |
| Third | Sattva-guṇa (goodness) | Pradyumna | Sustaining and protecting; the prakṛti-form of Vishṇu by which the world is enchanted |
| Fourth | Rajo-guṇa (activity) | Aniruddha (Brahmā) | Creating the world; the rājasika form |
The guṇas are the three basic qualities of nature: sattva (goodness and light), rajas (activity and passion) and tamas (darkness and inertia).
The text also says: “Kṛshṇa Dvaipāyana Vyāsa is himself the very form of Nārāyaṇa-Vishṇu.” This makes the purāṇa-kāra, the composer of the Purāṇas, one with the Parameśvara himself.
The Seven Manvantara Avatāras of Vishṇu
Just before the Caturvyūha passage, Chapter 51 lists seven avatāras of Vishṇu, one for each of the first seven manvantaras. In each, Vishṇu takes a form that suits the group of devas of that age:
- Svāyambhuva: born of Prakṛti through Brahmā‘s saṅkalpa (will) as a Mānasa-putra (mind-born son)
- Svārocisha: born with the Tushitas as Tushita
- Uttama: born with the Satyadevas as Satya-rūpa
- Tāmasa: born with the Haris as Hari
- Raivata: born with the Mahnasas as Manasa
- Cākshusha: born with the Vaikuṇṭhas as Vaikuṇṭha
- Vaivasvata (the present manvantara): born of Kaśyapa and Aditi as Vāmana
This shows that in every world-cycle the same supreme Nārāyaṇa takes an avatāra. The text ends: “With one aṃśa, Nārāyaṇa fills the whole world. All the devas and the kings of this earth are portions of Vishṇu.”
Where the Kūrma Purāṇa Stands
The Kūrma Purāṇa is counted among the Śaiva Purāṇas, yet all through it teaches abheda. It is framed as a teaching given by Bhagavān Nārāyaṇa himself in his Kūrma (tortoise) form. Its main features are:
- The speaker is Vishṇu, yet the text again and again raises Śiva up as Parameśvara.
- Śiva is declared supreme, yet Vishṇu (as Nārāyaṇa) is said to be his very self.
- The Vīrabhadra episode shows Śiva’s supremacy, yet Brahmā‘s teaching straight away returns to abheda.
- Śaiva emphasis in pūjā: devotees of Śiva reach Śiva-sāyujya (union with Śiva), sārūpya (a form like his) and sālokya (life in his realm). The Kūrma Purāṇa gives special praise to Śiva-bhakti.
- Yet a Vaishṇava framework of teaching: the Caturvyūha, Vāsudeva as the nirguṇa principle, and Vyāsa as the form of Nārāyaṇa.
For those who practise, the meaning is clear. Bheda-dṛshṭi, seeing Śiva and Vishṇu as separate, is itself a spiritual mistake. Abheda-dṛshṭi, the vision of oneness, kept up while worshipping either of them, leads to moksha.
What This Means for Devotees
Brahmā‘s teaching in Chapter 15 stresses:
- Pūjā of either Śiva or Vishṇu with abheda-bhāva (a feeling of oneness) leads to the highest goal (parama-gati).
- Nishṭhā (steady faith) in the Parameśvara, who is ādyantarahita (without beginning or end), is the path.
- The Daksha story is a clear warning. Narrow sectarian thinking that looks down on one aspect of the Supreme, whether Śiva or Vishṇu, is both a wrong understanding and brings karmic results.
Per Vāmana Purāṇa
The Vāmana Purāṇa tells this in Chapter 36, in Pulastya Maharshi‘s account to Nārada Maharshi.
The devas cannot see Bhagavān Śiva
Once the whole world was shaken. The devas went to the abode of Murāri Vishṇu, bowed to him and asked the cause. Śrīhari said: “Let us all go to the dwelling of Śrī Śaṅkara. He, being of great jñāna, can tell the cause.” With Janārdana going along, the devas and Indra went to Mount Mandara. There they did not see Śiva and Pārvatī, nor Nandīśvara, nor the bull, and they stood staring at what seemed an empty abode. Bhagavān Vishṇu asked them: “What is this? Do you not see Mahādeva, seated right in front of you?” The devas said they could not see Girijānātha.
Then Śrīhari told them that because they had committed Śiva-droha, offering the garbha-havana of Bhavānī Mṛḍānī for their own ends, Śūlapāṇi had taken away their jñāna and viveka (discernment), and so they could not see him even with open eyes. He told them to purify their bodies by the taptakṛcchra vrata and then to perform abhisheka to Bhagavān Śiva; then their pāpas would go and their lost sight would be given back. The devas with Indra kept the taptakṛcchra vrata and became free of pāpa.
Śaṅkara in Bhagavān Vishṇu’s body
Then they said to Keśava: “O Keśava, if you tell us where Śambhu is, we will do abhisheka with milk and the rest.” Bhagavān Vishṇu said: “Here, Śaṅkara is with me, in my body. Do you not see him?” The devas said: “We do not see him. O Madhusūdana, tell us truly where Maheśvara is.” Then the imperishable Śrīhari showed the devas the Īśvara-liṅga, as if lying on his own heart-lotus. Rejoicing, the suras did abhisheka to that liṅga-mūrti with milk and the rest as prescribed, anointed it with gorocana, adorned it with candana, did pūjā with bilva leaves and flowers, offered agaru dhūpa with bhakti and great herbs as naivedya, did japa of the hundred and eight names, and went round it in pradakshiṇa with namaskāras.
The Hari-Hara viśvarūpa
Then the devas began to wonder among themselves: “How can Hari and Hara, whose natures are of the mutually opposed sattva and tamas guṇas, be joined as one?” Even as they were troubled, that imperishable Prabhu Śrīhari, holding all weapons and endowed with all auspicious marks, took the viśvarūpa.
In that form Śiva stood joined in Hari. The Purāṇa names, in its own order:
- three eyes;
- earrings of serpents and of lotuses;
- the jaṭājūṭa (matted locks);
- the banners of Garuḍa and of Vṛshabha, the bull;
- necklaces of serpents;
- the pītāmbara (yellow silk);
- the tiger skin;
- the vanamālā (forest garland);
- the weapons that belong to Śiva and Keśava: the cakra, the khaḍga (sword), the śaṅkha, the hala (plough), the Śārṅga bow, the Pināka bow, the śūla, the Ajagava bow, the khaṭvāṅga, the kapāla (skull-bowl), the ghaṇṭā (bell) and others.
Seeing that wondrous Hari-Harātmaka form, all the devas headed by Brahmā said: “Prabhu Sarvagata, all-pervading one! Avyaya, imperishable one! Namaskāra to you!” They bowed, and they knew that the two are one.
Then Śrīhari led the devas, now all of one mind, to Kurukshetra, his own āśrama, where Śaṅkara stood in the waters as Sthāṇu.
Source: Vāmana Purāṇa, Chapter 36
Per Agni Purāṇa
The Agni Purāṇa gives the form in which Hari and Hara are made one mūrti, the Harihara-mūrti, in its teaching on the making of the mūrtis of Bhagavān Vishṇu‘s forms. On the right half of the body are the signs of Rudra, and on the left half the signs of Keśava. In the right hands he holds the śūla (trident) and the ṛshṭi (a spear); in the left hands the gadā (mace) and the cakra (discus). Devī Pārvatī stands at his right side and Devī Lakshmī at his left.
The Harihara-mūrti is installed in the same way as the mūrtis of Saṅkarshaṇa and the Viśvarūpa, the Rudra-mūrti, the liṅga and Ardhanārīśvara.
Source: Agni Purāṇa, Chapters 49, 63
Per Brahma Purāṇa
Pūrṇatīrtha, where both dwell
In the Gautamī Māhātmya, Brahmā tells Nārada of Pūrṇatīrtha on the northern bank of the Gautamī, and asks: which being can fully tell the greatness of Pūrṇatīrtha, where both Bhagavān Vishṇu, who bears the cakra, and Bhagavān Śiva, who bears the Pināka, dwell?
Indra and Bṛhaspati go to the Gautamī
Indra had been cast down from his kingdom three times, and he asked Bṛhaspati why. The two went to Brahmā, who named the fault as khaṇḍa-dharma, dharma left broken or incomplete, and told them the earlier account of King Dhanvantari, son of Āyus. When they asked how the fault could be removed, Brahmā said: “Go to the Gautamī, the divine river, and praise Bhagavān Vishṇu and Bhagavān Śaṅkara. In the three worlds there is no other means of purification than those two and that river.” They bathed in the Gautamī, had darśana of the two, and praised them: Indra praised Hari through his forms, from Matsya, Kūrma, Varāha, Narasiṃha and Vāmana to Rāma and Kalki, and Bṛhaspati praised Śiva as Someśvara, asking only for unbroken bhakti.
The vara of Hari and Hara
Then Hari and Hara, the rulers of the devas, together said: “Choose whatever you desire, any vara, even one most hard to obtain.” Indra asked that the pāpa by which his kingdom was lost and regained again and again be subdued, so that he and all that was his might be stable. Saying “So be it,” they granted his words, and seeing Indra and Bṛhaspati, a smile spread over their faces. Their forms were free of all deficiency, standing without any support, free of change, the refuge of the worlds; both were givers of bhukti and mukti.
Hari and Hara said: “This great tīrtha has three presiding deities, and the river Gautamī gives whatever is desired.” They told Bṛhaspati to bathe Indra in the river for his welfare, remembering the two of them, with this mantra: “Whatever good and meritorious deeds have been done in this birth and in the previous birth, let them reach perfection and completeness. O Godāvarī, namaskāra to you.” Whoever repeats this mantra and bathes in the Gautamī has his rite made perfect by the grace of Hari and Hara both, is freed from the faults of previous births, and becomes puṇyavān. Bṛhaspati performed the great abhisheka of Indra, and the river that arose from it was named Maṅgalā; its confluence with the Gaṅgā is Pūrṇatīrtha.
Indra received the kingdom of the three worlds from Hari, and it was made stable by Maheśvara. Where Bṛhaspati praised Maheśvara for the stability of Indra’s kingdom is the Govinda tīrtha, whose presiding deity is Siddheśvara; beyond it lie Indratīrtha and Bārhaspatya, where the presiding deities are Siddheśvara, Vishṇu and Govinda. A bath, dāna or any act of puṇya done in these tīrthas bears everlasting fruit, and they are very dear to the pitṛs.
Source: Brahma Purāṇa, Gautamī Māhātmya, Chapter 52
Sources
- Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapter 147
- Harivaṃśa Purāṇa, Vishṇu Parva, Chapter 128
- Kūrma Purāṇa, Pūrvārdha (first half), Chapter 15
- Kūrma Purāṇa, Pūrvārdha (first half), Chapter 51
- Vāmana Purāṇa, Chapter 36
- Agni Purāṇa, Chapters 49, 63
- Brahma Purāṇa, Gautamī Māhātmya, Chapter 52