Karma-Phala: The Fruits of Action
Karma-Phala · karma-phala, “the fruit of action”
Karma means action, and phala means fruit. Karma-phala is the teaching that every action brings its own result, which a person meets in this life, after death, or in a later birth. The Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇa has one of the most detailed accounts of this in the Purāṇas. It shows how particular actions, both pāpa (wrong deeds) and puṇya (good deeds), lead to particular results in later births.
This teaching is given by Sumati, the son of Mahāmati. Sumati is a jāti-smara, someone who remembers his past births. Drawing on the memory of ten thousand past lives, he lists the results in rebirth of hundreds of kinds of action. The Brahma Vaivarta, Garuḍa and Vishṇu Dharmottara Purāṇas and the Mahābhārata add their own detailed teachings, which are set out below.
The Basic Principle
The main teaching of karma-phala in the Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇa is that every action brings a result that matches it exactly. The match is not loose or general but precise. An ātmā that has done a certain wrong will be reborn as a certain creature, or suffer a certain illness, or live in a certain condition that mirrors the nature of the original wrong. This is not random punishment. It is simply karma working itself out by its own inner logic.
Particular Wrongs and Their Results
The Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇa gives these examples:
- Stealing a golden vessel: rebirth as a kṛmi (worm)
- Stealing silk thread: rebirth as a cakravāka (ruddy shelduck)
- Stealing a silk garment: rebirth as a silkworm
- Stealing dākula (a fine cloth): rebirth as a parrot
- Stealing cotton cloth: rebirth as a parrot
- Stealing fine brocade: rebirth as a bear
- Stealing land: after naraka (the realm of suffering), rebirth first as grass, then as a bush, then as a vine, and finally as a human with little puṇya
- Castrating a bull: rebirth as a napuṃsaka (one who is neither male nor female) twenty-one times
- Neglecting ṛtu-dharma (the duties of the marital season): naraka
- Disrespecting one’s teacher: illness in the next birth
- Brahmahatyā (killing a brāhmaṇa): the Raurava naraka
- Killing a brother or a child: the Tama naraka
- Blocking someone’s brahmacarya (celibate study) or tapas (spiritual discipline): the Asipatravana naraka
- Insulting the dharmaśāstras (books of dharma): the Taptakumbha naraka
In each case the nature of the wrong is mirrored in the nature of the rebirth. The one who steals fine cloth becomes the worm that makes silk. The one who robs land becomes the grass that grows on it. The one who destroys a sacred ability is reborn with that ability in a lesser or broken form.
The Upward Path
Sumati also describes the fruits of good actions. The devout rise through a series of births, each life of greater puṇya leading to a higher birth, until they reach human birth again. Then they can take up once more the conscious path of dharma and moksha (liberation). The exact steps depend on the quality and strength of the good karma they have gathered.
The Good King in Naraka
The Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇa tells a striking story. A good king came into a naraka only by being near it, not because of any wrong of his own. He found that his presence alone eased the pains of everyone suffering around him. They begged him not to leave, because his puṇya was their relief. When he freely gave his puṇya to them, they were set completely free from the naraka.
This story teaches two things. First, being near a puṇyātmā (a person of great merit) brings relief even in naraka. Second, puṇya can be passed to others as a free gift. This principle lies behind śrāddha (the rite for the departed) and other rites that pass puṇya on to departed ancestors.
The Root Teaching
Sumati ends by saying that the wheel of saṃsāra (the cycle of birth and death) keeps the jīva (individual soul) bound through rāga (attachment) and lobha (greed), through adharma and avidyā (ignorance). Every act done out of desire brings a result, which in turn sets off more actions. This binds the jīva in an endless turning, like a ghaṭī-yantra (a water-wheel). The only way out is moksha, reached through yoga and vairāgya (detachment).
Karma-Phala in the Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa
Karma Rules Over All
The conversation between Sāvitrī and Yama in the Prakṛti Khaṇḍa of the Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa (Chapters 24–27) opens with a firm statement that karma is supreme. Yama tells Sāvitrī that karma is the svāmī (master) of all. It rules Brahmā, Vishṇu, Śiva and Yama himself. None of them can cancel the fruit of karma for another being. The one exception is Śrī Kṛshṇa, who is the master of karma itself. Only nishkāma (selfless) bhakti to Kṛshṇa can cut the tree of karma (karma-vṛksha) at the root and free the jīva from the cycle entirely.
Yama says he learned this from his father Sūrya, the sun. Sūrya is the sākshī (witness) of every action done by day, and Candra, the moon, is the witness of every action done by night. Together they see every act of every jīva, and nothing escapes them. Citragupta writes down all deeds in his everlasting records. Even four-faced Brahmā gives out fruits according to the thread of karma (karma-sūtra), like a potter who uses a staff (daṇḍa), an āvamu, water, a wheel (cakra), clay and thread to shape his pots.
Three Kinds of Karma and Where They Lead
Yama divides karma into three kinds: sat-karma (good action, puṇya), dushkṛta (wrong action, pāpa) and miśra (mixed). Those who do only good go to svarga (the realm of joy) and in time reach moksha. Those who do only wrong go to naraka. Those whose karma is mixed get mixed fruits, such as svarga followed by life on earth (bhūloka), or naraka followed by rebirth, and so keep going round the wheel of saṃsāra.
After death the Yamadūtas (Yama’s messengers) take the jīva to Yamapurī, Yama’s city. There Yamarāja sits on a jewelled throne (ratna-siṃhāsana), served by three koṭi (thirty million) attendants. He chants the name of Kṛshṇa on a crystal mālā (rosary) and meditates on Śrī Kṛshṇa’s feet with deep feeling, his hair standing on end and his voice choked. He treats all beings equally. Together with Citragupta, he weighs the jīva’s karma and sends it to the proper loka (world). The jīva lives through these fruits in a sūkshma-deha (subtle body), which never dies however harsh the pains of naraka.
Place, Time and Recipient
In Chapter 37, in Bṛhaspati‘s teaching to Indra, the Purāṇa explains how deśa (place), kāla (time) and pātra (the person who receives) multiply the fruit of karma. A gift (dāna) given on an ordinary day to an ordinary brāhmaṇa brings an ordinary fruit. The same gift brings:
- On amāvāsyā (new-moon day) or sūrya-saṃkramaṇa (the day the sun enters a new sign): one hundred times the fruit
- During a lunar eclipse (candra-grahaṇa): one koṭi (ten million) times the fruit
- During a solar eclipse (sūrya-grahaṇa): ten koṭi times the fruit
- On Akshaya Tṛtīyā: akshaya (never-ending) fruit
Place works the same way:
- At an ordinary place (sāmānya-sthāna): ordinary fruit
- At a temple (deva-mandira): one hundred times
- On the bank of the Gaṅgā or at a Nārāyaṇa-kshetra (holy place of Nārāyaṇa): avyaya (undying) fruit
- At Kurukshetra, Badarī or Kāśī: one koṭi times
- At Kedāra or Haridvāra: one lakh (one hundred thousand) times
- At Pushkara or Bhāskara-kshetra: ten lakh times
So does the person who receives:
- An ordinary brāhmaṇa: ordinary fruit
- A learned paṇḍita who performs sandhyā-vandana at the three times of day: one lakh times
- A paṇḍita who practises upāsanā with a Vishṇu mantra: one koṭi times
Even karma done a koṭi of births ago follows the jīva like a shadow and does not let go until its fruit has been fully lived through. The same principle holds for japa (repeating a mantra) and snāna (holy bathing).
The Fruits of Good Actions
Chapter 27 describes the fruits of śubha-karmas (good actions) after death and in later births. Among its main teachings:
- Anna-dāna (giving food): the gift of greatest puṇya. Whoever gives food truly gives life. Those who give food reach brahma-svarūpa (the nature of Brahman) after death, and their family line continues.
- Kanyā-dāna (giving a daughter in marriage): the highest of all gifts. A father who gives his daughter to a worthy groom with the proper rites goes to the highest loka.
- Go-dāna (giving a cow): brings great puṇya. The giver crosses the Vaitaraṇī river safely.
- Bhūmi-dāna (giving land): among the gifts of greatest puṇya. The giver never falls into want, and his family line is protected.
- Kṛshṇa-nāma and Kṛshṇa-mantra-japa (chanting the name and mantra of Kṛshṇa): destroy the pāpa gathered over countless births and open the path to Goloka.
- Tīrtha-yātrā (pilgrimage): brings the combined fruits of countless yāgas (Vedic sacrifices).
Bṛhaspati’s Teaching to Indra
When Indra returned to Amarāvatī after Durvāsa‘s śāpa and fell weeping at the feet of his guru Bṛhaspati, Bṛhaspati taught him that a wise man does not give way to grief when calamities come. Neither wealth nor calamity is ever permanent; they vanish like a dream. They depend on the karma done in former births and in this birth, and they come and go like the spokes of a wheel. In this Bhārata-kshetra every being must surely experience the fruit of the good and bad karma it has done, and karma does not wear away unexperienced however many years pass. When jīvas have experienced the fruits of their karma and some karma-bhoga (fruit still to be lived through) remains, they take a birth that fits it, in Bhārata-bhūmi or elsewhere. By his own karma a man gains a brāhmaṇa’s śāpa or poverty, blessings or endless wealth.
Source: Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa, Prakṛti Khaṇḍa, Chapter 37
Even Brahmā Lives Through Karma
In the account of Tārā, which Śrī Kṛshṇa tells Nanda, Śukrācārya urges Candra to give Tārā back to Bṛhaspati: “In the presence of Nārāyaṇa a blade of grass and a mountain are equal. What are you in the presence of Hari? Even Brahmā has karma-bhoga.” When Candra had been purified, Bhagavān Śiva told him in the assembly of the devas: “Even in a hundred crore kalpas the fruit of karma does not perish without being experienced. Karma that is done, auspicious or inauspicious, must surely be experienced. By giving up the body one does not escape it. But by prāyaścitta (rite of expiation) it surely perishes.”
Source: Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa, Śrī Kṛshṇa Janma Khaṇḍa, Chapters 80–81
The Touch of Gaṅgā
When Gaṅgā came down to the earth, Śrī Kṛshṇa told her that the Vedas say that, by her touch and her breeze, the people living in Bhārata-bhūmi lose the karma-bhoga of their earlier births and leave behind all their pāpas.
Source: Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa, Prakṛti Khaṇḍa, Chapter 10
The Exception: Selfless Bhakti to Kṛshṇa Goes Beyond Karma
All these teachings confirm that the fruit of karma must be lived through without exception. Yet the Prakṛti Khaṇḍa keeps pointing to one exception that rises above all this. Yama himself says that nishkāma Kṛshṇa-sevā (selfless service of Kṛshṇa) cuts the tree of karma at its root. Bṛhaspati teaches the same: the Kṛshṇa mantra shatters the iron chains of karma.
Durvāsa Maharshi‘s teaching to Indra agrees. All yogīs, siddhas, yatis (renunciants) and mahāṛshis must live through the fruits of their karma without exception, but the bhaktas of Śrī Hari are free of this. Their touch burns away the pāpa of others as a great fire burns dry grass. The karma a bhakta of Kṛshṇa has gathered over koṭis of births is destroyed in one moment of true bhakti-dīkshā (initiation into devotion).
Karma-Phala in the Vishṇu Dharmottara Purāṇa
Chapters 111, 117 and 118 of the Vishṇu Dharmottara Purāṇa (second part), taught by Pushkara to Paraśurāma, give this Purāṇa’s own ordered list of the fruits of karma. They belong to a connected series on life after death (Chapters 111–121). The series covers how long the results of pāpa last, the path to svarga, the path to naraka, the twenty-one narakas, rebirth as animals, and the bodily marks borne in human birth by those who have come out of naraka.
How Long Suffering Lasts (Chapter 111)
Chapter 111, the Pāpa-nirṇaya (“deciding about wrong deeds”), gives exact lengths of suffering in naraka for the gravest wrongs:
- Brahmahatyā (killing a brāhmaṇa): suffering for a whole manvantara (one of the fourteen great ages of a Manu)
- Kshatriya-vadha (killing a kshatriya): suffering for 4 yugas
- Vaiśya-vadha (killing a vaiśya): suffering for 3 yugas
- Śūdra-vadha (killing a śūdra): suffering for 1 yuga
- The pañca-mahāpātakas (the five great wrongs): suffering for a whole kalpa (one full cycle of creation)
These lengths set out a clear order of seriousness. Killing a brāhmaṇa disturbs the order of the world the most, and brings suffering for a whole manvantara. Lesser wrongs bring shorter suffering, though still over immense spans of time.
The Setting of the Teaching
This teaching is told by Mārkaṇḍeya to King Vajra at Aśmanagara, the outer setting of the second part of the Purāṇa. King Vajra’s questions about dharma and the fruits of karma lead Mārkaṇḍeya to pass on the detailed teachings that Pushkara gave to Paraśurāma.
Ways of Life That Lead to Svarga (Chapter 117)
Chapter 117, on the svargagāmī (“those who go to svarga”), lists more than thirty ways of living that lead to svarga after death, including:
- Regularly performing the pañca-mahāyajñas (the five great daily offerings)
- Always honouring guests (atithi-pūjā)
- Protecting and providing for those who depend on one
- Being truthful in every dealing
- Regularly offering śrāddha to the pitṛs (ancestors)
- Protecting cows and brāhmaṇas
- Dying bravely in battle while facing the enemy, which links the path to svarga with the ethics of war
- Steady bhakti to Vishṇu and keeping the Ekādaśī fast
- Giving land (bhūmi-dāna), cows (go-dāna), food (anna-dāna) and knowledge (vidyā-dāna)
Ways of Life That Lead to Naraka (Chapter 118)
Chapter 118, on the nirayagāmī (“those who go to naraka”), lists more than thirty ways of living that lead to naraka, including:
- Giving false witness and lying under oath
- Betraying trust and friendship
- Ingratitude (kṛtaghnatva)
- Abandoning parents and elders without providing for them
- Violating the teacher’s wife (guru-talpa)
- Cowardice in battle, the exact opposite of the brave death that leads to svarga
- Eating during an eclipse
- Hypocrisy in religious life (outward show without inner dharma)
- Making innocent people suffer
- Destroying other people’s livelihoods through deceit
The Vishṇu Dharmottara Purāṇa is consistent in its view. These two lists are not random. They mirror the division between dharma and adharma that runs through all 183 chapters of its second part. The fruit of karma is how the world upholds the same principles of dharma that Pushkara teaches throughout.
Wrongs and Rebirths in the Garuḍa Purāṇa (Chapter 3)
Chapter 3 of the Dharma Khaṇḍa of the Garuḍa Purāṇa has the longest list in the Purāṇas linking wrong deeds to the births they lead to, with more than eighty entries. Some of them are:
- Killing a brāhmaṇa: birth as a dog, pig, donkey or crow, then through ever lower births
- Killing a cow: birth as a camel, then a horse, then a dog, then a lowly human birth troubled by disease
- Stealing gold: birth as a locust or a rat; a thief of precious metals becomes an insect
- Adultery: birth as a wasp or a crawling insect
- A brāhmaṇa drinking liquor: birth as a caṇḍāla or mleccha (an outcaste or foreigner)
- Eating stale or impure food: birth as a crow or a vulture
- Eating alone without sharing: birth as a needle-mouthed creature (sūcīmukha)
- Blocking a pilgrim’s journey: birth as a stone or a boulder
- Betraying a friend: birth as a jackal or a hyena
- Cutting down trees without need: birth as an insect that bores into timber
- Giving false witness in court: born blind or deaf in the next birth
- Neglecting pitṛ-tarpaṇa (water offerings to the ancestors): birth in the Ugragandha naraka, then a hundred years as a preta (a wandering departed soul)
- Selling the Vedas: birth as a worm in filth
- Insulting the devatās: birth into lasting illness and poverty
- Destroying another’s livelihood: birth into poverty for seven generations
- Speaking harsh words: born with a speech defect
The main principle is the same as in the Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇa: the nature of the wrong is mirrored in the nature of the rebirth. The one who betrays trust becomes an animal that must always watch its back. The miser becomes a creature that cannot even open its mouth wide enough to take in food.
“Dharma Wins”: The Closing Teaching (Chapter 46)
Chapter 46 of the Dharma Khaṇḍa gives the verse that sums up the whole section:
Dharmo jayati nādharmaḥ satyaṃ jayati nānṛtam / kshamā jayati na krodhaḥ vishṇur jayati nāsuraḥ
“Dharma wins, not adharma. Truth wins, not falsehood. Patience wins, not anger. Vishṇu wins, not the asuras.”
This verse comes as the final summary just before the closing teaching of Chapters 48–49. It boils the whole teaching on karma-phala down to its heart: the world is not morally neutral. The working of karma-phala is not a machine of random punishment. It shows that dharma, satya (truth) and kshamā (patience) are in the end stronger than their opposites. And Bhagavān Vishṇu, who is the very ground of dharma, is the final guarantee of this order.
The Karma-Phalikopākhyāna in the Anuśāsana Parva (Chapter 7)
In the Anuśāsana Parva of the Mahābhārata, Yudhishṭhira sits before Bhīshma, who lies on his bed of arrows (śaraśayyā). He asks what fruit (phala) comes from every good action. Bhīshma answers that this is a paramarahasya, a great secret of the ṛshis.
He first sums up six model dharmas, each shown in stories he has just told Yudhishṭhira:
- Not hating or resenting the water of rivers
- Seeing one’s own sorrows as the fruit of one’s own past faults, not as something done by others
- Honouring guests with the devotion of Sudarśana
- Striving for brāhmaṇa-hood (brāhmaṇyatva) against all odds, as Viśvāmitra did
- Showing kindness to all beings (sarvabhūta-dayā), as the parrot Śuka did
- Trusting that the body is protected by daiva (destiny) even while following dharma through one’s own effort
Bhīshma then passes on Bhagavān Vyāsa‘s own list, vow by vow, of which action brings which fruit in janmāntara, the next birth:
- A vānaprastha (forest-dweller) sleeping on the bare ground: fine houses and beds in the next birth
- Wearing bark and rough (nāra) garments: fine clothes and ornaments
- A mind disciplined by yoga (yogātma-citta): excellent vāhanas (vehicles)
- A king devoted to agni-upāsanā (tending the sacred fire): paurusha (valour) in the next birth
- Holding back the tongue from the pleasure of taste: saubhāgya (good fortune); giving up meat: sons and cattle
- Brahmacarya (celibacy), whether practised hanging upside down, living in water, or through any strict vow of sleeping alone (ekaśayī): the lokas one has longed for
- Honouring a guest with pādya (water for the feet), āsana (a seat), dīpa (a lamp), anna (food) and nivāsa (lodging): equal to a yajña with five gifts to the officiating brāhmaṇas (pañca-dakshiṇa)
- Dying on the battlefield (vīraśayyā): svarga, the never-ending lokas (akshaya-lokas), and everything one wishes for
- Dāna (giving): dhana (wealth) in the next birth; mauna (silence): ājñā-śakti (the power to command); tapas: bhogas (enjoyments); brahmacarya: āyushya (long life)
- Ahiṃsā (non-harming): saundarya (beauty), aiśvarya (sovereignty) and ārogya (health)
- Living on fruits and roots: rājya (a kingdom); living on leaves alone: svarga
- Prāyopaveśa (fasting until death): unbroken sukha (happiness) all through the next birth
- Śākāhāra-dīkshā (a vow to eat only vegetables): go-dhana (wealth in cattle); living on tṛṇa (grass) alone: svarga
- Giving up relations with women, bathing at the three times of day (tri-kāla snāna), and living on air alone (vāyu-bhakshaṇa): the full fruit of a yajña
- Living on water alone while keeping up the daily agnihotra (nitya-agnihotra) and mantra practice (mantra-sādhana): a kingdom; fasting completely (nirāhāra): svarga
- A twelve-year vow (vrata-dīkshā) of giving up food and bathing at holy tīrthas (puṇya-tīrthas): lokas higher even than those of the hero who gives his life in battle
- Studying the Vedas fully: immediate freedom from sorrow; dharma practised in the mind alone (mānasa-dharma): svargaloka
Bhīshma adds that no action done through any of the five senses ever goes unseen and lost. The five indriyas (senses), with the mind as the sixth, stand as sākshins (witnesses) to every act. He points out that āśā (craving) alone, of all the body’s powers, never grows old or fades with age, even as the hair turns grey, the teeth fall out, and the eyes and ears weaken. It is craving, not the body, that must be given up for true happiness. Karma follows the one who did it as surely as a calf finds its own mother among a thousand cows. And it ripens only at its own set time, just as flowers and fruits appear only in their season without anyone needing to prompt them.
Bhīshma ends with the teaching that ties all dharma together. Pleasing one’s father pleases Prajāpati. Pleasing one’s mother pleases Pṛthivī (the Earth). Pleasing one’s guru pleases Brahmā. Honouring these three fulfils every dharma at once. Neglecting even one of them makes every other action in life fruitless. Vaiśampāyana records that the Kuru elders who were gathered there were filled with wonder and joy at this teaching.
Bhīshma closes the chapter by comparing falsehood with faulty ritual. Reciting Vedic mantras with impure pronunciation, performing a soma-yāga without giving dakshiṇā (the gift due to the officiating brāhmaṇas), or making a homa offering into the fire without its mantra, brings pāpa equal to that of telling a lie.
Per Bhavishya Purāṇa
The fruit of karma is one of the subjects the Bhavishya Purāṇa names at its own beginning. The opening chapter of the Brahma Parva sets out what the Purāṇa contains, group by group, and in the fourth group it says that Bhagavān Vyāsa has told here of conception and birth (garbha-prasava), the fruit of karma, the dharmas of jāti, kula and Veda, and the vaitāna vrata dharmas.
Source: Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 1
Sources
- Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇa
- Brahma Vaivarta Purāṇa, Prakṛti Khaṇḍa, Chapters 10, 24–27, 36–37; Śrī Kṛshṇa Janma Khaṇḍa, Chapters 80–81
- Garuḍa Purāṇa, Dharma Khaṇḍa, Chapters 3 and 46
- Vishṇu Dharmottara Purāṇa, Uttarārdha (Dvitīya Khaṇḍa), Chapters 111 and 117–118
- Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapter 7
- Bhavishya Purāṇa, Brahma Parva, Chapter 1