Daiva and Purushakāra

Daiva Purushakāra · daiva purusha-kāra, “destiny and human effort”

Daiva means destiny or the divine will: the unseen force of karma (the results of past actions) that shapes what happens to us. Purushakāra means human effort: what a person chooses to do and works hard to achieve. How these two forces work together in human life is one of the great questions of the Mahābhārata.

The question comes up again and again in the Udyoga Parva, when Śrī Kṛshṇa and the advisers of the Pāṇḍavas are preparing for the war with the Kauravas. Is the outcome of events already fixed by daiva, so that human effort is useless? Or is purushakāra the deciding factor, so that daiva is only the background against which we act? Later, in the Anuśāsana Parva, Yudhishṭhira puts the same question directly to Bhīshma.

The Agni Purāṇa gives the teaching in the words of Pushkara to Paraśurāma: daiva is the karma a man did before in another body; it is beyond thought, while purushakāra accomplishes the work and is the best. Adverse daiva can be made favourable by effort, and effort joined with daiva gives fruit in its season, as farming bears fruit when the rain comes. So one must act, and never sit trusting in daiva alone.

The Bhāgavata Purāṇa shows daiva as the unseen (adṛshṭa) that bears the fruit of karma, itself a form of Bhagavān Śrī Hari, as Bhagavān Kapila teaches Devahūti. Daiva drives the jīva into each new birth and makes it taste the fruit of its pāpa; and when Brahmā saw that his creation did not grow, he joined the fitting effort with contemplation of the grace of daiva, and creation by pairs began.

The Two Forces

Daiva is the force of the unseen. It is the result of past actions (karma), the will of the divine order working itself out through time. It is what has already been set in motion by earlier choices and earlier lives, and what the order of the universe requires at this moment. In the Mahābhārata, daiva often means the fact that the Kurukshetra War cannot be avoided: the wrong done to the Pāṇḍavas has set forces moving that cannot simply be undone by a peace gesture.

Purushakāra is the force of a person’s own will and effort. It is the kshatriya’s (warrior’s) readiness to act, to fight, and to seek justice through skill and strength. It does not deny daiva. Rather, it is the active meeting with the world as it is. The argument for purushakāra is that without it, daiva becomes an excuse for doing nothing, and that what daiva points to comes about precisely through the effort of those who work towards it.

In the Discussions of the Udyoga Parva

The Yānasandhi Parva (Chapters 47–71) contains discussions held at Upaplavya, where the weight of daiva and purushakāra is examined. Yudhishṭhira by nature tends to ask whether war is worth its cost even if victory is certain, and the Mahābhārata challenges this tendency again and again. Śrī Kṛshṇa‘s advice is always the same: the path of dharma needs purushakāra in the service of what daiva has ordained. To sit idle is not to honour daiva but to abandon it. Kṛshṇa’s own peace mission to Hastināpura is itself an act of purushakāra: trying every possible way before accepting the war that daiva has been pointing towards ever since the unfair game of dice.

Bhīshma’s Teaching in the Anuśāsana Parva

Chapter 6 of the Anuśāsana Parva gives the teaching of daiva and purushakāra in full. Bhīshma gives it to Yudhishṭhira by telling a dialogue between the ṛshi Vasishṭha and Brahmā. It teaches that daiva (the fruit of past karma, or fate) and purushakāra (effort made now) are not rivals. They work together as causes: daiva is the seed and purushakāra is the field, and neither alone can bring a harvest. Effort is needed for daiva to bear fruit at all. Brahmā supports the teaching with a long list of kings, ṛshis and even devas whose fortunes rose and fell by this rule.

The question, and the seed and the field

Yudhishṭhira praised Bhīshma as one who knows all the śāstras (sacred texts), and asked him plainly which of the two is greater: daiva or purushakāra. Bhīshma answered with an itihāsa (an account from the past). Long ago the revered Vasishṭha had asked this same question of Brahmā, the Pitāmaha (Grandfather) of all the lokas (worlds). Padmasambhava Brahmā, the one born from the lotus, gave a reasoned answer in sweet words.

Brahmā began from a fact no one can escape. Nothing is born without a bīja (seed), and no fruit comes without a seed either. From one seed another seed forms, and from that seed alone the fruit comes. Here kṛta, a person’s own stored puṇya (merit), is itself the seed. A farmer goes to his field and gets exactly the fruit of whatever seed he sows. In the same way, puṇya or pāpa (sin) gives exactly the fruit of the karma done, no more and no less.

A field gives no fruit unless a seed is sown in it. In the same way, daiva cannot bear fruit without purushakāra. Purushakāra is the kshetra (field) and daiva is the bīja (seed). Only when field and seed come together does the crop grow well.

Karma is seen directly, daiva is not

Brahmā‘s argument rests on what can be seen. When people act, they themselves directly taste the fruit of the good and bad deeds they have done. This is pratyaksha-siddha: plain to see in the world. Good karma gives sukha (happiness), and karma of pāpa gives duḥkha (sorrow). Only the karma that is done bears fruit. No one tastes the fruit of what they have not done.

One who makes the effort of purushakāra gains prosperity along with good fortune. One who does no karma at all falls from every joy, and suffers as if salt were rubbed into a wound. Tapas (austerity) gives rūpa-saubhāgya (beauty and good fortune) and precious gems; every such gain comes through karma. To one who does no karma, daiva gives nothing at all.

Brahmā declares that purusha-prayatna (human effort) alone gives svarga (heaven), bhoga (enjoyment), dharma-nishṭhā (firmness in dharma) and prābhava (power) of buddhi (intellect) in this world. The stars, the devatās, the nāgas, the yakshas, the moon, the sun and Vāyu (the wind) all rose above the merely human state (mānusha-bhāva) and reached their divine places through purushakāra. One who makes no effort cannot enjoy wealth, friends, prosperity or noble birth. Each varṇa has its own form of purushakāra:

  • A brāhmaṇa prospers through ācāra (right conduct).
  • A kshatriya prospers through parākrama (valour).
  • A vaiśya prospers through vyāpāra (trade).
  • A śūdra prospers through sevā (service).

Wealth does not come to the miser who cannot give, nor to the impotent, the lazy, the coward, or one without tapas.

Even Nārāyaṇa and the devas depend on karma

Brahmā presses the point further. Śrī Mahānārāyaṇa himself, who made the three lokas and all beings, devas and dānavas alike, performs tapas in the ocean. If karma had no fruit, all karma would be useless; and if everyone relied only on daiva, everyone would stop caring about action.

Even in devaloka (the world of the devas) a small pāpa causes great fear, while in the world of men the fear that follows śubha (good) and aśubha (bad) karma is less. The places of the devatās, even Indra‘s own place among the star-forms, are plainly anitya (not lasting). Without karma of puṇya, even devatās cannot stay in their places. The devas cannot welcome the karma of puṇya done by humans, because they fear their own defeat. So they create vighnas (obstacles), and trouble men who follow dharma with terrible temptations. Ṛshis such as Cyavana have overpowered Indra and the devas by the strength of their tapas, so daiva does not work here apart from karma. Ṛshis and devatās are always in conflict: the devatās block the tapas of the ṛshis, and the ṛshis, by the strength of their own tapas, push devatās out of their places. Without daiva, mere words could never bring sukha or duḥkha to anyone. Karma alone is the root of daiva, and only the puṇyavantas (those rich in merit) truly walk in dharma.

Kings and ṛshis who rose and fell

Brahmā then gives a list of those who fell and those who rose. It shows that purushakāra secures what daiva alone cannot promise, and that daiva alone cannot protect what purushakāra fails to keep up.

  • Yayāti fell from svarga to earth when his stored puṇya ran out. He went back to svarga only through the puṇya earned by his own grandsons (dauhitras).
  • Purūravas, known of old by the name Aila (the son of Ilā), reached svarga through the āśīrvāda (blessings) of brāhmaṇas.
  • Saudāsa, king of Kosala, performed great yajñas such as the Aśvamedha. Yet through the śāpa (curse) of Vasishṭha Maharshi he became a man-eating rākshasa.
  • Aśvatthāmā and Paraśurāma, mighty warriors and sons of ṛshis, masters of the bow and mahāvīras (great heroes) of the highest order, did not reach svarga in spite of their puṇya and their strength.
  • Vasu Mahārāja performed a hundred yajñas, like a second Indra. Yet he fell to Rasātala for one dosha (fault): he declared the śruti on the paśu-yajña (the yajña with an animal offering) not valid.
  • Bali Cakravartī, the son of Virocana, was bound by the dharma-pāśa (noose of dharma) of the devatās and sent to Pātāla. This came about through the prayatna (effort) of Śrī Mahāvishṇu himself, not through daiva acting alone.
  • Janamejaya Mahārāja had killed brāhmaṇa women, yet he took refuge at Indra’s feet and set out for svarga all the same. Brahmā asks: did daiva stop him?
  • Vaiśampāyana Maharshi carried the pāpa of killing a brāhmaṇa boy without knowing it, yet he went on towards svarga unhindered. Brahmā asks again: did daiva stop him?
  • Nṛga Mahārāja was a great giver of cows (dāna-para). Once, by mistake, he gave to another brāhmaṇa a cow that had wandered back into his own herd. By that one pāpa he became an ūsaravelli (a chameleon or monitor lizard).
  • Dhundhumāra, a rājarshi (a king who is also a ṛshi), went on performing yajñas into old age. Yet he turned down the varas (boons) that the devatās gladly offered him, and stayed asleep in Girivraja itself. He never went up to svarga or to the higher states.
  • The Pāṇḍavas won back the kingdom the Kauravas had taken from them by the strength of their own arms (bhuja-bala), not through daiva.

Brahmā ends the list with a question: do munis give a śāpa through the strength of daiva, or through the strength of their own tapas, that is, through karma? A saying puts the same truth from the other side:

daivena dattaṃ karmaṇā nāśitam

It means: “What daiva gives, wrong action destroys.” Even rare and precious bhogas (enjoyments), if people of pāpa gain them, do not stay with them. Daiva itself cannot protect one who is bound by lobha (greed) and moha (delusion).

Fire and oil, food and effort

Brahmā gives two more comparisons. A small fire grows only with the help of vāyu (wind); in the same way, daiva grows only with the help of karma. A lamp grows dim when its oil runs out; in the same way, daiva grows less as karma runs out.

Think of a man with every kind of food in his house who does not eat, and a man with young women near him who does not engage in rati (love-making). Neither can enjoy the fruit that is right there before him, because he lacks pravṛtti (the will to act). One without udyama (effort) cannot enjoy wealth, bhogas or women, however much of them there is. But the nitya-udyogī (one who is always at work) can gain even what daiva has hidden most deeply. The devatās themselves, pleased by his sadācāra (good conduct) and śraddhā (faith), come to live in such a person’s house for the sake of their own share, and so give him the best fruits. A person poor in wealth but rich in dāna-dharma (the dharma of giving) draws the devatās to his home, and that home becomes like devaloka. A home rich in wealth but empty of dāna-dharma the devatās see as no better than a cremation ground.

Brahmā ends with the rule that governs it all. In this jīvaloka (world of living beings), one without prayatna (effort) gets no fruit at all, and daiva cannot lift such a person from a bad path to a good one. A disciple walks behind his guru, keeping the guru in front of him. In the same way, daiva walks behind purushārtha (human effort), keeping purushārtha in front of it. It is one’s own stored (saṃcita) purushārtha that carries one to wherever daiva has decided. Bhīshma tells Yudhishṭhira that he has told exactly what he has seen with his own eyes: that purushārtha alone is pratyaksha-phalaprada, giving fruit that can be seen directly.

Farming and rain (kṛshi-parjanya-nyāya)

The teaching also meets an objection. It may seem to turn the expected order upside down: rain (daiva) must come before the farmer’s work (karma), so karma would not seem to rule daiva. The answer names two kinds of karma: saṃcita, karma stored up and waiting, and ārambha, karma newly begun for the sake of enjoyment. Through karma done with udyoga (effort), one gains phala (fruit) in this very life. Through karma done by śāstra-vidhi (the rules of the śāstras), one reaches the path to svarga. So bhoga (enjoyment) depends on daiva, while saṃcaya (gathering) depends on karma. Even in farming, waiting in hope for rain is itself a purusha-lakshaṇa (a mark of human effort). And a farmer can also dig wells and water the land by his own effort, to bring in the harvest without relying on rain alone.

So a person reaches the path of svarga through karma begun with the upward push (utthāna) that daiva gives, joined to the vidhi (rule) laid down in the śāstras.

Time and effort in Chapters 163–164

Later in the Anuśāsana Parva, in Chapters 163–164, Bhīshma comes back to daiva and purushakāra in short sayings. Effort sometimes fails, and good fortune sometimes comes without being earned. Yet a man whose kāla (time) has run out dies, and one whose time has not run out lives on, whether he is struck by a hundred arrows or only touched by a blade of grass. Time, and not effort or the lack of it, is what can be seen to decide. Bhīshma’s answer is a call to keep going: if wealth still does not come through effort, one should turn to tapas, “for a plant does not sprout without a seed being sown.”

Bringing the Two Together

Kṛshṇa‘s advice, given in many parvas (books) of the Mahābhārata, is not that daiva overrules purushakāra, nor that purushakāra cancels daiva. The two work together. The wise person reads the signs of daiva correctly, understanding what the order of the universe requires, and then puts full purushakāra into meeting that requirement. This is what sets Kṛshṇa’s advice apart both from fatalism (the belief that effort is pointless) and from the pride of relying only on oneself, cut off from dharma.

Per Agni Purāṇa

Pushkara’s teaching to Paraśurāma

In the Agni Purāṇa, Agni Deva tells Vasishṭha Maharshi the rāja-nīti (the rule of kings) that Pushkara taught Paraśurāma. At the close of his teaching on the duties of the king, Pushkara says that all works depend on daiva (destiny) and on purushakāra (human effort). Of these, daiva is acintya, beyond thought; purushakāra can accomplish the work. And the one cause that gives a king the kingdom, the earth and Lakshmī (prosperity) is the affection of his people (Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 225).

Then, before he teaches the upāyas (the means of policy) beginning with sāma, Pushkara explains the two in full:

  • “Paraśurāma! The karma that a man did before with another body is called daiva.”
  • Therefore the wise man must know that purushakāra is the best.
  • If daiva is adverse, it can be made favourable by purushakāra.
  • As the fruit of sāttvika karmas done before, success comes today even without any purushakāra.
  • “Bhṛgunandana! Purushakāra itself, with the help of daiva, gives fruit at the proper time.”
  • Both daiva and purushakāra give fruit to man: when farming is done by effort and the rain comes, the fruit is obtained in its season.
  • Therefore one must perform karma and act with purushakāra, and not sit trusting in daiva alone.

All works begun with the upāyas starting with sāma then succeed (Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 226).

Śrī Rāma’s teaching to Lakshmaṇa

Agni Deva then gives the rāja-nīti that Śrī Rāma taught Lakshmaṇa, which gives victory. A king, says Śrī Rāma, should win the favour of the devatās (daivānukūlya) by good deeds, friends by sincere goodwill, kinsmen by respect, women by love, servants by gifts, and others by showing them agreeableness (Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 238). Winning the favour of daiva is named among the attractive qualities of a king, beside noble birth, truth, gratitude, utsāha (zeal) and dhārmikatva (devotion to dharma) (Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 239).

In his teaching on war and peace, Śrī Rāma names the kings with whom no sandhi (treaty) should be made, but only war. Among them are one struck down by daiva, and one who believes daiva alone to be the cause of fortune and misfortune and makes no human effort (purusha-prayatna). Daiva is also named among the causes of vigraha (war), beside pride, arrogance, harassing the janapada, destroying people, injuring wealth, powers or dharma, a friend’s cause, insult to the honourable, the destruction of kinsfolk, breaking the assurance of safety (abhaya) given to beings, spoiling the circle of states, and two desiring one and the same object (Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 240).

The word daiva

In its lexicon, the Agni Purāṇa gives daiva, dishṭa, bhāgadheya, bhāgya, niyati and vidhi as words for daiva, what is ordained (Agni Purāṇa, Chapter 360).

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa

In the Bhāgavata Purāṇa, daiva is the unseen power that bears the fruit of karma, and it is itself a form of Bhagavān Śrī Hari.

Daiva as a form of Bhagavān

Bhagavān Kapila teaches his mother Devahūti that prakṛti, the purusha who is beyond it, and daiva, which is the unseen (adṛshṭa) and the support of the fruit of the jīva’s karmas, are all forms of Parabrahman, the Paramātmā, Bhagavān Śrī Hari. In the same teaching he shows daiva at work in the life of the one attached to the world: daiva in the form of kāla (time) wipes away everything a man earns with toil hoping for happiness, so that only sorrow is left to him; and daiva makes the man who supports his family by adharma suffer the fruit of that pāpa in naraka. When the jīva is to take a human birth, it is impelled by daiva according to its past karma and enters a woman’s womb through a man’s seed. Like a bird in a cage it cannot move its limbs there, and by the grace of daiva the memory of its past births comes to it; remembering the karmas of many births, it stays long without breath.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 3, Chapters 29–31

Brahmā’s effort and the grace of daiva

Maitreya Maharshi tells Vidura that when Brahmā saw that the beings he created did not increase, he reflected: “Aho! This is a wonder! I make effort at all times, yet these beings do not increase. Daiva is surely the obstacle in this.” So Brahmā, making the fitting effort, contemplated the grace of daiva. Then his form divided in two, and a pair, woman and man, appeared, and creation by pairs began.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 3, Chapter 12

Daiva among the causes of happiness and sorrow

When King Parīkshit asked Dharma, standing in the form of a bull, who had struck him, Dharma answered that, bewildered by the arguments of the different schools, he could not tell from whom the seeds of their calamities spring. Yogīs who do not accept multiplicity say that beings are themselves the cause of their happiness and sorrow; the daivajñas (knowers of daiva) say that it comes from daiva; the mīmāṃsakas say that it comes from former karma; the lokāyatikas say that it comes from one’s own nature alone; and a few hold that it comes from Parameśvara, who cannot be grasped by the mind or pointed out by words. He asked the rājarshi to judge these with his own buddhi.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 1, Chapter 17

Daiva in the fruit of karma and in rebirth

  • Brahmā, praying to Bhagavān Śiva for Daksha, says that those who see only difference and wound others with words like spears are slain by daiva itself, in the form of the fruit of their own karma; and that whatever offences the deluded commit by the force of daiva, the mahātmās forgive in their compassion and show only grace (Skandha 4, Chapter 6).
  • Vasudeva, teaching Kaṃsa that death is certain for every body, tells him that the mind, made of vāsanās (impressions), is driven by daiva, the karma that gives birth, towards a body; the jīva goes with that mind, takes that body, is born and holds it as himself (Skandha 10, Chapter 1).
  • When Akrūra came to take Śrī Kṛshṇa to Mathurā, the gopīs cried that today even daiva acted against them, for daiva had brought them separation from Śrī Kṛshṇa, the giver of moksha (Skandha 10, Chapter 39).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 4, Chapter 6; Skandha 10, Chapters 1, 39

Sources

  • Mahābhārata, Udyoga Parva, Chapters 47–71 (Yānasandhi Parva)
  • Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapter 6
  • Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapters 163–164
  • Agni Purāṇa, Chapters 225–226, 238–240, 360
  • Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 1, Chapter 17; Skandha 3, Chapters 12, 29–31; Skandha 4, Chapter 6; Skandha 10, Chapters 1, 39