The Ṛshis’ Dispute: Fire or Water (Tapastīrtha)
Tapastīrtha · tapas-tīrtha, “the tīrtha of tapas”
The ṛshis’ dispute over fire and water is the account of how Tapastīrtha on the Gautamī got its name, told by Brahmā to Nārada in the Gautamī Māhātmya of the Brahma Purāṇa. The ṛshis, expounders of the Vedas, disputed whether Agni or the waters are the greater. Brahmā declared them equal; Vāyu chose fire; Bhūmi chose the waters. Still unsatisfied, they went to the ocean of milk and praised Bhagavān Vishṇu, and an unembodied divine voice told them to propitiate both by tapas, and that the one that first gave them siddhi should be called the greater. On the bank of the Gautamī some worshipped Agni and some the waters, and then Sarasvatī, mother of the Vedas, spoke: the waters are the greater, for they are mothers, and above all the mothers of fire. The place is called Tapastīrtha, and there the river Sarasvatī rises and joins the Gaṅgā.
The tīrtha
Brahmā says that the tīrtha known as Tapastīrtha greatly increases tapas, grants every cherished desire, is sacred, and increases the happiness of the pitṛs. “Listen to what happened there,” he says; “it destroys pāpa.”
The dispute
A dispute arose among the ṛshis about the greatness of the waters against that of fire. Those who held Agni the highest said: without fire, where can life exist? Fire is the very essence of life; it is the ātmā; it is the havis; everything is born of fire. The world is sustained by fire and lit by fire, and there is no deity greater than Agni. He alone is the inner light and the great flame; nothing exists without fire, whose abode is all three worlds. The power in the seed a man places in the womb is of fire and nothing else. Agni is the mouth of the devas.
Those who held the waters the highest said: food is produced from water, and fire too is produced from water. Everything is sustained by water, and the waters are remembered as mothers. Those who know the ancient lore say that water is the very life of the three worlds; amṛta comes from water, and the healing herbs exist only through water.
Brahmā, Vāyu and Bhūmi
Holding these opposed views, the ṛshis came to Brahmā: “Tell us whether fire or water is superior; you are the ruler of the three worlds.” Brahmā answered: “Both are worthy of pūjā in the world. The world has come forth from both. Havya, the offerings to the devas, kavya, the offerings to the pitṛs, and amṛta are produced from both. Life in the world and the body are sustained by both. There is no special difference between them; their greatness is equal. This is my firm word: neither is superior to the other.”
But the ṛshis held that one must be greater, and went to Vāyu: “Which of the two is superior, O Vāyu? You are the prāṇa; truth is rooted in you.” Vāyu said: “Fire is superior; everything rests on fire.” Saying “No” among themselves, they went to Bhūmi: “Speak the truth, O Earth, you who support the moving and unmoving.” Bhūmi humbly said: “The waters, the eternal devīs, are the support even of me. Everything is born of the waters. So greatness is firmly established in the waters.”
At the ocean of milk
Saying “No” among themselves again, the ṛshis went to Bhagavān Vishṇu, lying in the ocean of milk, holding the śaṅkha, the cakra and the gadā, and praised him:
- “We take refuge in that true Reality which knows the whole universe, the future, the present and what is hidden in the cave of the heart, and into which all three worlds of many forms enter at dissolution.”
- “We take refuge in that true Reality, imperishable, permanent and immeasurable, which the ṛshis call knowable through the Vedas, by resorting to which people gain what they desire.”
- “The yogins do not attain the form of Vishṇu, the chief Reality in the universe made of the great elements.”
- “We ṛshis have come to ask this. O Jagannivāsa, abode of the universe, tell us the truth. You are the antarātmā of all embodied beings; you alone are everything, O Bhagavān Vishṇu, and everything is in you. Yet by the power of Prakṛti no one anywhere knows you, though you are within, without and everywhere, and take the form of the universe.”
Then the divine voice, the unembodied one, the support of the universe, spoke: “Let both, water and fire, be propitiated by tapas, devotion and niyama. The one from which siddhi is gained first may be called the greater.”
The two satras on the Gautamī
Saying “So be it,” the ṛshis, honoured by the worlds, went away, weary, downcast within and deeply detached. All of them went to the Gautamī, the one mother of all the worlds, the purifier of the three worlds, to perform tapas, and kept sacred observances with self-control. Some worshipped Agni and some worshipped the waters.
Sarasvatī’s answer
Then the divine voice of Sarasvatī, the mother of the Vedas, spoke:
- “The waters are the source of fire.”
- “Purity and cleanliness are gained through water.”
- “Without water, how can the pūjā of fire be done? Only when water is made ready does one become fit for sacred rites.”
- “A man remains impure and unfit for rites, even if he is a scholar of the Vedas, until he faithfully plunges into cool water.”
- “So the waters are the greater, for they are remembered as mothers, and above all the mothers of fire.”
Hearing this, the ṛshis, expounders of the Vedas, concluded that greatness belongs to the waters.
The names of the tīrtha
“The tīrtha where this happened, O Nārada, is called Tapastīrtha,” Brahmā says. “The tīrtha where the two satras of the ṛshis took place is called Satratīrtha.” It is also called Agnitīrtha and Sārasvatatīrtha. The place where the ṛshis’ doubt was dispelled by the divine voice is the source of the river Sarasvatī, which flows into the Gaṅgā. “Who indeed could fully describe the glory of that confluence?”
Phalaśruti
A holy bath and dāna there are splendid and grant every cherished object. There are one thousand four hundred tīrthas there, which give puṇya, and a holy bath and dāna there grant the joys of svarga and moksha.
Sources
- Brahma Purāṇa, Gautamī Māhātmya, Chapter 56