Haṃsa Gītā (Bhāgavata Purāṇa)

Haṃsa Gītā, “the song of the swan”

Haṃsa has other meanings too: see all meanings of Haṃsa.

The Haṃsa Gītā is a teaching from Skandha 11, Chapter 13 of the Bhāgavata Purāṇa. The great ṛshis (seers) ask Brahmā a hard question about the mind, bondage and moksha. Brahmā cannot answer it, so he meditates on Bhagavān Vishṇu. Bhagavān Vishṇu then appears before the assembly as a haṃsa, a shining white swan, and answers.

The teaching says that the mind is the cause of both bondage and moksha. It also says that only steady discrimination between the ātmā (the self) and what is not the self, joined with firm devotion to Bhagavān Vishṇu, dissolves the mind’s hold.

Śrī Kṛshṇa himself tells this account to Uddhava, as part of the teaching the Bhāgavata gives in Skandha 11. He has just taught how sattva conquers rajas and tamas, and how the sādhaka draws the mind back from every side and fixes it on him: “This alone is the restraint of the mind taught by my disciples Sanaka, Sanandana and the others.” Uddhava asks when, and in what form, he taught them. Śrī Kṛshṇa answers: the Sanakādis, the mind-born sons of Brahmā, asked their father how the mind and the objects of the senses may let go of each other; Brahmā could not reach the root of the question and thought of Śrī Kṛshṇa, who came to them in the form of a haṃsa. When they asked “Who are you?”, Haṃsa taught them that the Ātmā is one and is himself, that waking, dream and deep sleep are states of the buddhi of which the Ātmā is the witness, that the many-ness of the world is a dream-like delusion of the mind, and that the sword of discrimination cuts every doubt; then he made himself known as Śrī Hari, the form of yajña. Their doubts scattered, the maharshis worshipped and praised him, and he returned to his dhāma while Brahmā looked on. The chapter’s own name for the teaching is the Haṃsa-gīti, “the song of Haṃsa”.

Śrī Kṛshṇa’s teaching to Uddhava before the account

Śrī Kṛshṇa tells Uddhava that sattva, rajas and tamas belong to the buddhi, a product of prakṛti, and not to the Ātmā. By sattva one must conquer the other two, and sattva itself must then be conquered by sattva, by a peaceful disposition. In the one in whom sattva has grown, the dharma that is bhakti to Śrī Kṛshṇa arises. By using sāttvika things sattva grows; from sattva the highest dharma grows, rajas and tamas are destroyed, and with them the adharma born of them.

He names the ten causes of the guṇas, in order: śāstra, waters, progeny, place, time, karma, birth, dhyāna, mantra and saṃskāra. When these are sāttvika, sattva grows; waters such as the Gaṅgā make sattva grow. To tell which is which: what mahātmās such as Vyāsa praise is sāttvika, what they condemn is tāmasa, and what they regard with indifference is rājasa. Until ajñāna is removed and ātma-sākshātkāra, the direct realisation of the Ātmā, arises, one should use only the sāttvika ones: nivṛtti-śāstra, the waters of tīrthas, a secluded place, brāhma-muhūrta, nitya-karma, a sāttvika mantra and the like. From that comes dharma, and from dharma, jñāna.

As the fire born from the rubbing of bamboos burns the very forest that caused it and then dies down, so the fire of jñāna, born of inquiry, burns to ash the guṇas from whose imbalance this body was born, and itself merges in the Ātmā’s own nature.

Uddhava asked: “O Śrī Kṛshṇa, people say that sense-pleasures are the home of dangers. Yet like a dog that comes back even when driven away, like a donkey that follows even after being beaten, like a goat that trusts the butcher, they go on enjoying them. How is this?”

Śrī Kṛshṇa answered. In the heart of the undiscerning person arises the false idea “the body is I”, and through it rajas, the cause of sorrow, pervades the mind, though the mind is itself a product of sattva. Then, in order: the saṅkalpa for enjoyment arises; imaginings about the object strengthen it; dwelling on the object’s qualities grows; from that, desire is born, and he cannot give it up. One deluded by rajas has no mastery of the senses and is the servant of desires; though he knows the final fruit of such karmas is sorrow, he still performs them. The discerning person too may feel the disturbance of rajas and tamas, but he sees the fault in sense-enjoyments, stays attentive, restrains the mind and is not caught.

The sādhaka should be attentive, master his āsana, practise prāṇāyāma, offer his mind to Śrī Kṛshṇa and make it steady, doing dhyāna at the proper times, the three times of the day. He must not lose heart when dhyāna does not come right, and there must be no haste in sādhana. “Draw the mind back from every side and fix it on me,” said Śrī Kṛshṇa. “This alone is the restraint of the mind taught by my disciples Sanaka, Sanandana and the others.”

Uddhava asked: “O Śrī Kṛshṇa, when, and in what form, did you teach yoga to Sanaka, Sanandana and the others?”

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13

The question at Satyaloka

The four Sanakādi ṛshis, Sanaka, Sanandana, Sanātana and Sanatkumāra, had come to Satyaloka, the world of Brahmā. Other great yogīs were with them. They put a question to Brahmā that stands at the very edge of what the Vedas discuss.

They said: “The mind, manas, is the one who experiences, the one who is bound and the one who is freed. But what exactly is it? When it turns outward to the objects of the senses, saṃsāra (the cycle of birth and death) arises. When it turns inward to the ātmā, moksha arises. Yet it is the same mind in both cases. What is the true nature of this mind? And what is the best means to turn it towards moksha?”

In Śrī Kṛshṇa‘s own words to Uddhava, Sanaka, Sanandana and the others, the mānasa-putras (mind-born sons) of Brahmā, asked their father about the subtle final limit of yoga, the restraint of the mind: “O father, the mind is attached to the objects such as sound, which are products of the guṇas, and the objects are attached to the mind. For the sādhaka who wishes to cross the ocean of saṃsāra and seeks moksha, what is the means by which they let go of each other?”

Brahmā knows all about creation and the order of the worlds. But he saw that this question belongs to a field of pure consciousness that is beyond his own field. He sat in meditation. Bhagavān Vishṇu appeared before the assembly in the form of a Haṃsa, a great swan, white and shining, moving on an unseen current of supreme stillness.

Śrī Kṛshṇa describes it so: Brahmā is the Deva of devas, Svayambhū, the creator of beings; yet his mind was then drawn outward by karmas, and however much he thought, he could not reach the root doubt in the question. Wishing to know the answer, he thought of Śrī Kṛshṇa. “Then I went to him in the form of a haṃsa.” As a haṃsa separates milk from water, so in this teaching he separated the Ātmā from the guṇas. The Sanakādis saw him, came near, bowed at his feet and, keeping Brahmā in front of them, asked: “Who are you?” “O Uddhava,” said Śrī Kṛshṇa, “learn from me the teaching I then gave those maharshis who wished to know the tattva.”

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13

The nature of the mind

The Haṃsa spoke: “The mind, manas, arises from the sattva-guṇa (the quality of clarity) of ahaṅkāra (the sense of ‘I’). It is the meeting point of consciousness and matter. It is the place where the reflection of the ātmā, which is pure light, falls on the substance of prakṛti (nature). In itself the mind has no light. It borrows its seeming consciousness from the ātmā, as a mirror borrows the light of the sun.

“When the mind moves towards the objects of the senses, it takes the shape of those objects and seems to become them. When the jīva (the embodied being) takes itself to be this movement of the mind, it believes: ‘I am hungry,’ ‘I am grieving,’ ‘I am joyful.’ But these are states of the mind, not of the ātmā. The ātmā is touched by no state.

“So the mind is the cause of saṃsāra when it flows outward. It is the cause of moksha (liberation) when it turns inward to its own source. This inward turn is what the Vedas call jñāna (knowledge). The clear recognition that one is the witness of the mind, and not the mind itself, is the very attainment of moksha.”

As Śrī Kṛshṇa gives it to Uddhava, Haṃsa began with their own question:

  1. “O maharshis, when the Ātmā is not many, how can your question ‘Who are you?’ be fitting? Taking what as my basis, the body or something else, should I answer it?”
  2. “The five bhūtas are the same in the bodies of all beings. So your question rests only on the usage of words, not on the determination of a real thing.”
  3. “All that is grasped by the mind, by speech, by sight and the other senses is I myself; there is nothing apart from me. Inquire into the tattva and see this truth.”
  4. “O sons, the mind enters the objects such as sound, products of the guṇas, and the objects enter the mind. But the Ātmā of the jīva is I myself. This mind and these objects are only an upādhi of the jīva, not its own nature.”
  5. “By using the objects again and again the citta becomes attached to them, and they settle firmly in it. But the jīva’s own nature is I. So the sādhaka, established in the Ātmā and meditating on me, must give up both, the mind’s attachment and the objects.”

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13

The waking, dreaming and deep-sleep states

The Haṃsa went on: “The ātmā is present in all three states as their witness. The three states are jāgrat (waking), svapna (dream) and sushupti (deep sleep). In the waking state the mind meets outer objects through the ten senses. In the dream state the mind makes its own world from stored impressions. In deep sleep both mind and senses dissolve. Only the ātmā, the pure sākshin (witness), remains.

“A person knows: ‘I was present in deep sleep. I felt its peace. I came out of it refreshed.’ The witness-consciousness that knows this is the ātmā. It is not born with the waking state and it is not destroyed by sleep. It is the fourth, turīya. It is the ground of all three states and is never itself a state.

“Meditation is the practice of resting in this turīya awareness while the three states rise and pass away.”

In the text’s order, Haṃsa taught:

  1. Waking, dream and deep sleep are only states that arise in the buddhi through the guṇas. Because the jīva is their witness, the mahātmās have determined that it is distinct from them.
  2. Bondage is the Ātmā’s identification with this buddhi that wanders in saṃsāra; through it the workings of the guṇas come to the Ātmā. The Ātmā is the fourth, turīya, beyond the three states and their witness. So the sādhaka must practise steadfastness in the Ātmā; then freedom comes at once from both the objects and the citta.
  3. The sādhaka must see that ahaṅkāra, pride in the body, is the bondage that spoils the goal of life. Dispassionate, standing in the Ātmā, the witness of the three states, he should give up the saṅkalpas for enjoyment that bring saṃsāra.
  4. As long as the idea that the many-ness of the world is real does not leave, a person is ajñānī; he is as if in a dream even when awake, as in a dream one feels that one is awake.
  5. Apart from the Ātmā there are in truth no distinctions such as deva and human. Doing karmas and reaching svarga and the other lokas that are their fruits are imagined for the Ātmā, as for one who dreams; the objects of a dream are not different from the dreamer.
  6. The Ātmā, which grants existence and light to the senses, is the witness of the three states born of the three guṇas. As viśva it enjoys in waking, with all the senses, outer things that perish every moment; as taijasa it enjoys in dream, in the heart, things like those of waking; as prājña it withdraws all this into itself in sleep. The Ātmā-tattva that runs through all three as memory, “I who slept and dreamed am now awake”, is non-dual.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13

The means to moksha

The ṛshis asked: “What is the exact means by which the mind is brought under control and the ātmā is realised?”

The Haṃsa answered: “The foremost means is to hear about me, my names, my forms and my deeds, with śraddhā (faith) and growing love. This hearing, śravaṇa, slowly cleans the mind of its tamasic and rajasic impurities, as a vessel is made clean by washing again and again. When the mind has become pure enough through this hearing, manana becomes possible. This is deep reflection on the truth that one has heard. From manana, nididhyāsana arises by itself. This is unbroken contemplation of the ātmā.

“The last obstacle is the sense of being the doer and the enjoyer. These are ahaṅkāra and mamakāra (the sense of ‘mine’). They are cut by the sword of viveka (discrimination), held with the support of bhakti (devotion). Bhakti without jñāna tends to turn into attachment, even to the form of Bhagavān Vishṇu. Jñāna without bhakti tends to turn dry and abstract, and the mind cannot hold to it. Together they are complete.

“I am the ātmā of all beings. I am the knower inside every knower and the witness behind every seeing. To know this, not only as an idea but as a living fact, is moksha.”

In the text, Haṃsa went on:

  1. “Inquiring thus, be certain that the states such as waking are imagined in the mind by my māyā made of the three guṇas. Hearing the teachings of the sat-purushas and practising the discrimination of Ātmā and non-Ātmā, sharpen the sword of discriminating knowledge. With it cut all doubts, the diseases of the mind. Worship me, who dwell in the heart.”
  2. The world is seen, momentary and as restless as a whirling firebrand; it is only the play of the mind, a firm delusion. The one consciousness of the Ātmā, without a second, appears as many forms. The threefold distinction of body, senses and inner organ is the transformation of sattva, rajas and tamas, imagined by ajñāna like a dream.
  3. The sādhaka who dwells on the bliss of the Ātmā gives up the hope of enjoyments and turns his sight back from body and senses, giving up “I” and “mine”. With no thirst for fruits, he does no karma for fruits. At times, as when he goes for bhikshā, the body may come to mind; but since he knows firmly that it is not the supreme reality, it cannot delude him into taking it for the Ātmā. It comes to his memory only as a saṃskāra, until it falls.
  4. As one lost in the intoxication of liquor does not care whether his cloth is on or has slipped off, so the one steadfast in the Ātmā does not care for the body. Whether the perishable body, subject to prārabdha karma, sits, stands, goes or comes back, he takes no notice.
  5. The body with its prāṇas and senses was produced by prārabdha karma, and as long as that karma lasts it waits and moves. The jñānī, established in the yoga of the one-pointed mind, does not take up again the feeling of “mine” towards the dream-like world, or the pride of “I” in the body.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13

Haṃsa reveals himself

Then Haṃsa made himself known: “O maharshis, I have taught you the secret of jñāna-yoga and karma-yoga. Know me to be Śrī Hari, the form of yajña, who came wishing to teach you the dharma of moksha. I am the great support of karma-yoga, jñāna-yoga, satya, the dharma enjoined by the Veda, sweet speech, dharma, tejas, sampad, kīrti and the restraint of the senses, and I am also their fruit. I, who am nirguṇa, have no need of anything. I, who do good to all, am the Ātmā, the treasury of love. Equanimity, non-attachment, satya and all the other virtues serve me.”

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13

Brahmā’s reply

After hearing the Haṃsa‘s teaching, Brahmā folded his hands and said: “Now I understand why I could not answer this question myself. This knowledge is not made by the creator. It is the creator’s source. It comes before all creation. I bow to you, the Haṃsa, who have dissolved my doubt.”

The swan then went away as quietly and as brightly as it had come. The assembly of ṛshis was left in deep stillness.

In Śrī Kṛshṇa‘s words to Uddhava, the doubts of Sanaka, Sanandana and the other maharshis were scattered by this teaching. With great bhakti they worshipped Haṃsa and praised him well. “When those maharshis had worshipped and praised me,” said Śrī Kṛshṇa, “I returned to my dhāma while Brahmā looked on.”

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13

Sources

  • Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 13