Govardhana Pūjā Begins

Every year the gopas of Gokula prepared a great yajña (fire ritual) for Indra, the deva of the rains. When Kṛshṇa saw the preparations, he asked his father Nanda what they were for. He then argued that karma and svabhāva (one’s own nature) decide what beings receive, and that Govardhana, the cows and the brāhmaṇas deserve honour first, because they keep Gokula alive. The gopas gave the Indra yajña to Govardhana, and Kṛshṇa took a second form as Govardhana and ate the offerings.

The Bhāgavata Purāṇa tells this in Skandha 10, Chapter 24, where Śrī Śuka Maharshi tells it to Parīkshit Mahārāja. The Vishṇu Purāṇa tells it in the tenth chapter of its Pañcamāṃśa and adds the four vidyās (branches of knowledge). The storm sent by an angry Indra and the lifting of Govardhana come in the chapters after this one.

Kṛshṇa asks about the Indra yajña

Kṛshṇa saw Nanda and the community getting ready for the yearly Indra yajña. They were gathering large amounts of food, arranging the fire and inviting the brāhmaṇas. He turned to his father with a question that seemed simple but held a deep challenge.

“Father, what is this preparation? For whom is it? What is its purpose, and what result does it bring?”

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Śrī Kṛshṇa, the ātmā of all beings and witness of all, already knew their intention, yet he humbly bowed to the elders headed by Nanda and asked: “O father! What is this undertaking you mean to do with such enthusiasm? What is the fruit of this yajña? Who is its devatā? What is the means, and who is the yajamāna? The good, who see everything as the ātmā, have no ‘own’ and ‘other’, no friend, indifferent one or enemy, and so nothing they must hide; and the elders say a friend is like one’s own self. One who acts knowingly succeeds in his karma; one who acts without knowing does not gain its fruit in the same measure. So have you reflected on this? Is it a Vedic karma, or only a worldly one?”

Nanda answered: “Son, this is our yearly pūjā to Indra, who rules the rains. Indra sends the rain. The rain makes the grass grow. The grass feeds the cows. The cows give us milk and keep us alive. So every year we honour Indra with a great yajña, so that this blessing continues.”

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Nanda said that Indra is the varshādhipati, the master of rain, and the clouds are his own forms; they rain everywhere and sustain the life of beings. “Not only we, but other men too worship Devendra with offerings, and those offerings are themselves produced from the rain he gives. With what is left over from the yāga, people live and attain dharma, artha and kāma. This dharma has come down by tradition. Whoever gives it up out of attachment to pleasures, greed for wealth, fear, or hatred of the devatās does not obtain good.”

Kṛshṇa’s argument

Kṛshṇa answered with a long argument. His points were these.

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, his words were such as to make Indra angry.

Karma and svabhāva are the first causes. All beings receive what they receive, joy and sorrow, wealth and poverty, because of their own karma from earlier actions and their own svabhāva, which decides how they live and act. No deva gives or holds back at will. A being who acts by its svabhāva and uses up the fruits of its karma receives what is due. Indra, or any other deva, is not the real giver. At most he is a nearby instrument in a system that karma and svabhāva wholly govern.

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Śrī Kṛshṇa said: “The jīva is born by karma alone, dies by karma alone, and by karma alone obtains happiness, sorrow, fear and well-being. If there is an Īśvara who gives the fruits of karma, he too gives fruit only to one who has done karma. Indra has no power to change the happiness and sorrow brought by men’s former saṃskāras; what need have they of such an Indra? The whole world, with devatās, rākshasas and men, stands in svabhāva. Enemy, friend, the indifferent one and guru all come as the fruit of karma, and even the grace of Īśvara depends on puṇya-karma. So a man should honour karma, follow his sva-dharma, and take as his daivam that by which he lives happily.”

The nature of rain. Rain does not fall because Indra decides to send it. The sun draws up water, the clouds form by the order Brahmā set for the world, and the rain falls through natural processes. These processes are held in the larger order of Parameśvara. Indra is one instrument within this order, and he does not act on his own.

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, he said: “Sattva-guṇa is the cause of sustaining, rajo-guṇa of creation, tamo-guṇa of dissolution. Impelled by rajo-guṇa, the clouds rain water everywhere, and beings live by that water. What does Devendra do?”

Thanks go first to what truly keeps us alive. Kṛshṇa said the gopas’ thanks should go first and most directly to what keeps their lives going. That is the mountains and forests that give the cows their grass, the cows that give milk, and the brāhmaṇas who keep sacred knowledge. Mount Govardhana in particular gives fresh grass to the cows of Gokula every day, and so it plainly keeps the community alive. A giver who is near and visible deserves honour before a distant and abstract deva.

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, he said: “Like an unworthy young woman who resorts to a paramour, one who lives by one thing and serves another for his living gains no well-being from it. For the brāhmaṇa the Veda, for the kshatriya the protection of the earth, for the vaiśya vārtā, for the śūdra service: these are the proper livelihoods. Vārtā is of four kinds: farming, trade, the protection of cows, and lending at a just interest; our livelihood is always the protection of cows. O father! We have no countries, cities, villages or houses; we always live in the forests and on the mountains.”

The yajña is redirected

Kṛshṇa ended his argument: “Use all the things gathered for this yajña, the food, the fire-offerings and the grains, to honour Govardhana, to feed the brāhmaṇas and to honour the cows. This is more in line with dharma for our community.”

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, he laid out the rite: “Make many kinds of dishes: pāyasa, dal, upmā of wheat, sweet cakes, fried snacks and more, and bring the milk and curd from every house. Let the vedavetta brāhmaṇas perform homa in the fires according to rule; give them many kinds of food, and milk-giving cows as dakshiṇā. Give to all according to their deserving, down to the fallen and even to the street dogs. Give grass to the cows and offer naivedya to the mountain. Then, having eaten, put on fragrances, good clothes and ornaments, and make pradakshiṇa of the cows, the vedavettas, the fires and Govardhana. This is my view; if it pleases you, carry it out. This yāga is dear to the cows, the vedavettas, Govardhana mountain, and to me too.” Śrī Kṛshṇa, who is Kāla in form, said this wishing to subdue Indra‘s pride.

Nanda was persuaded by his son’s reasoning. He spoke with the brāhmaṇas and the other gopas who were gathered. The brāhmaṇas were impressed by Kṛshṇa’s argument and gave their approval. The whole community changed the preparations. The great store of food was offered to Govardhana. The fire yajña was done with prayers to Govardhana instead of Indra. The brāhmaṇas were fed richly. The cows were honoured and fed. The community walked around the mountain in pradakshiṇā (circumambulation).

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Nanda, Sunanda and the others accepted his words, saying “This is good,” and did everything as he had said. They had the vedavettas recite the svasti-vācana; with the very materials of the Indra-yāga they offered dhūpa, dīpa and naivedya to Govardhana, the vedavettas and the cows, and grass to the cows; and then, with the herds of cows walking in front, they made pradakshiṇa of the mountain. The gopālakas received the blessings of the vedavettas, and the gopikās, well adorned, rode in bullock carts singing of Śrī Kṛshṇa’s valour.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 10, Chapter 24

Kṛshṇa as Govardhana

When the offerings were finished, Kṛshṇa left his father’s side for a moment and appeared at the mountain itself, in a second form. He was a vast divine being who said he was Govardhana in person. In this mountain form he said: “I am Govardhana. I accept your offerings, O Nanda. Ask me for a vara (boon).” Then he ate the whole great store of food that had been offered.

Per Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Śrī Kṛshṇa took this huge form on the mountain to create faith in the gopālakas, and saying “I am the mountain,” he ate the abundant naivedya. Then Śrī Kṛshṇa himself, together with the people of Gokula, bowed to that form of his own. The gopas said: “Wonder! Look! This mountain has taken a form and blessed us! This mountain takes any form it wishes, lives in the forest and harms those who dishonour it; let us bow to it for our good and the good of the cows.” So the gopālakas, moved by Śrī Kṛshṇa, worshipped Govardhana, the cows and the vedavettas, and went back to Gokula with him.

Meanwhile the Kṛshṇa who stood beside Nanda pointed to the mountain form and urged his father: “Pray to it! This is Govardhana himself, accepting your offerings.” Nanda was filled with devotion. He prayed for steady bhakti (devotion) to Śrī Hari and for dāsya-mukti, moksha through eternal service. The mountain form granted the vara and withdrew from sight.

In this episode the mountain is shown to be Bhagavān Kṛshṇa’s own svarūpa (own form), not only a sign of him. To honour Govardhana is to honour Bhagavān Kṛshṇa directly.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 10, Chapter 24

What followed

Indra‘s storm, Śrī Kṛshṇa holding up Govardhana for seven days, and Indra’s surrender afterwards are told in Govardhana Dhāraṇa (Skandha 10, Chapters 25–27).

Brahmā Deva recalls the episode briefly to Nārada: when Śrī Kṛshṇa stopped the Indra-yāga that the gopālas performed every year, Indra rained heavily to flood and destroy Gokula (Skandha 2, Chapter 7). Uddhava tells Vidura that Śrī Kṛshṇa, wishing that the abundant wealth be well spent, had Nanda Mahārāja perform go-pūjā with the help of the best of the brāhmaṇas (Skandha 3, Chapter 2).

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapter 7; Skandha 3, Chapter 2; Skandha 10, Chapters 25–27

The Vishṇu Purāṇa account: the four vidyās

The Vishṇu Purāṇa, Pañcamāṃśa, Chapter 10, adds a point to Kṛshṇa‘s argument against the Indra yajña. In this account Kṛshṇa names the four traditional branches of knowledge (vidyā) as the base of his argument:

  1. Anvīkshikī: logical inquiry, which allows correct reasoning about cause and effect and about the nature of dharma.
  2. Trayī: the three Vedas (Ṛk, Sāma and Yajur), which govern sacred duty and ritual action.
  3. Vārtā: the science of livelihood, meaning farming, cattle-keeping and trade, which is the practical base of the gopas’ lives.
  4. Daṇḍanīti: statecraft, the right use of power and rule.

Kṛshṇa said that when these four vidyās are rightly understood, a gopa sees that his wealth, his livelihood and his protection all come from what directly supports him: the mountain, the forest, the rains and the cattle. They do not come from a distant ruler like Indra, who works on a different plane of cosmic rule. When a gopa’s vidyā is sound, he honours Govardhana before Indra.

Sources

  • Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapter 7; Skandha 3, Chapter 2; Skandha 10, Chapters 24–27
  • Vishṇu Purāṇa, Pañcamāṃśa, Chapter 10