Bhikshu Gītā
Bhikshu Gītā, “the song of the mendicant”
In the city of Avantī lived a brāhmaṇa who spent his whole life hoarding wealth. He was lost when all his wealth was taken from him. Out of that loss he turned to renunciation, and when people mocked and hurt him he sang a song about the mind. That song is the Bhikshu Gītā.
Bhagavān Kṛshṇa told this account to Uddhava in the Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 23. Uddhava had asked how a sādhaka (one who follows a spiritual path) can bear the abuse and cruelty of others. Śrī Śuka Maharshi, the son of Vyāsa, gives the chapter. The brāhmaṇa speaks twice in it: first his lament when his wealth is lost, with the fifteen evils that have wealth as their root, and then the gāthā itself, sung on a river bank while wicked people torment him. In the gāthā he sets aside, one by one, the six causes people blame for joy and sorrow (other people, the devatās, the body, the grahas, karma and time) and finds the mind alone to be the cause; he ends by taking refuge at the feet of Śrī Hari, the giver of moksha. Śrī Kṛshṇa then tells Uddhava that the control of the mind is the essence of yoga, and gives the phalaśruti: whoever holds this song in the intellect, recites it or hears it is not overpowered by happiness and sorrow.
Uddhava’s question and Śrī Kṛshṇa’s answer
At the end of Chapter 22 Uddhava said: “O Kṛshṇa, best of teachers, I think it is very hard to bear in the mind the wrongs the wicked do. Except for the peaceful mahātmās who are firm in your dharma and have taken refuge at your feet, even for the learned one’s own nature is very strong. Tell me how to bear it.”
Śrī Kṛshṇa, the giver of moksha, honoured his words and answered, calling him the disciple of Bṛhaspati: “In this world there is surely no good man who can calm a mind shaken by the evil words of the wicked. Harsh words lodge in the vital place called the heart and cause greater pain than arrows striking the vital places. O Uddhava, on this matter the elders tell a sacred account with great regard. Listen with a concentrated mind. A bhikshu was humiliated by wicked people, but he did not lose his courage. Knowing that it was all the fruit of his own karma, he sang a song.”
(Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapters 22–23)
The brāhmaṇa of Avantī
In the city of Avantī there lived a brāhmaṇa who was highly learned but of low conduct. He tormented others; he was lustful, greedy and very quick to anger. He had gathered great wealth through trade and farming, but he spent none of it. He gave nothing to the devas or the pitṛs (ancestors), and nothing for the five great yajñas that every householder must perform. He gave nothing to guests or to the poor, and nothing even for the comfort of his own family. He did not honour his kinsmen or his guests even with a word, and in his empty house he did not enjoy anything himself. He lived like a yaksha, guarding treasure for no purpose, taking no enjoyment from it himself and sharing none with others. So he was ruined for this world and the next, with neither dharma nor kāma in his life.
His wife, sons, daughters and servants all suffered from his miserliness and his sharp temper. In time they drew away from him in feeling and in daily life. Grieved by him, they did nothing to please him and even wronged him. In a man’s wealth five have a share: the devatās, the pitṛs, human beings, other living beings and the ṛshis. The five yajña-devatās were angry with this man, who would not give alms even to a cat. The very devas of the five great yajñas, whom he refused to honour, withdrew their protection. Because he disregarded them, even the little puṇya he had was destroyed, and the wealth he had heaped up with great toil, giving up dharma and kāma, was left to him only as toil.
The fall
His wealth was destroyed from many sides at once.
His angry relatives took a share. Thieves who had been watching the house took more. Disasters of weather, flood and fire, which are spoken of as the work of the devas, destroyed a part. Śrī Kṛshṇa calls this daiva, fate, such as the house catching fire. Other people carried off another part. The government took its share. It went to the king’s treasury. What was left wore away with time: grain stored too long went bad and investments failed.
Soon the brāhmaṇa had nothing. He had no dharma, for he had ignored all religious duties. He had no kāma, for he had denied himself every pleasure. He now had no artha either. And he had no moksha, for he had never asked about it. His relatives took no notice of him, and he fell into a sorrow he could not bear.
He sat in this poverty and wept. Then he thought deeply. Tears flowed from his eyes and his throat was choked, and then a very great vairāgya (dispassion) arose in him. (Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 23)
The turning
What came to him was not self-pity but a true search:
Alas! I spent my life gathering wealth and guarding it. I gave up all dharma to get it. I took no pleasure from it. And now it is all gone. What was the use? Nothing of worth was gained. All I got from this wealth was weariness and worry. I have tormented this body without ceasing, for nothing, and gained neither dharma nor enjoyment. The wealth of those who torment others seldom gives happiness: here they make the body suffer, and when they die they go to naraka. As a white spot spoils a beautiful form, so even a little greed spoils the fame of the famous and the virtues of the virtuous. In gathering wealth, increasing it and guarding it, people suffer toil, fear, anxiety and delusion; in spending it, losing it and enjoying it they suffer anxiety too.
He named the fifteen evils that have wealth as their root. In gathering wealth: stealing the property of others; tormenting others for money; speaking untruth; dambha (hypocrisy); greed for wealth; and the anger when greed is not satisfied. After wealth is gathered: pride; contempt for others; the sense of “great people and lesser people”; enmity; distrust of others; excessive rivalry; and the three vyasanas (vices), lechery, drinking and gambling. “These fifteen are the causes of sorrow for human beings, and wealth alone is their root. So one who desires moksha should keep far from the cause of sorrow called wealth.”
Brothers, wife, parents and friends live as one through the bond of love, yet they quarrel over a quarter-rupee and at once become enemies; for a very little money they burn with anger, cast off love and kinship, and do harm. Even the devatās wish to be born as human beings, and within that birth brāhmaṇa-hood is great; those who gain it and waste their purushārtha go to impure narakas. This human birth is the door both to svarga and to moksha: what mortal who has gained it would cling to wealth, the root of all calamities?
He saw that wealth gathered against dharma and not shared with the five who have a share in it brings only ruin. In his words the five are the devatās, the maharshis, the pitṛs, the other beings and the atithis (guests); the one who gives to none of them, nor to his own kin, nor eats himself, but guards his wealth like a yaksha, falls low. He saw also that his firm resolve to hoard, which he had taken for prudence, was a kind of violence against the world.
The discerning spend wealth rightly and are fulfilled. My wealth is gone, my age and strength are gone; I am old. Why does even a wise man go on suffering to heap up wealth? Surely man is held in a strong delusion by the māyā of Īśvara. For one whom Mṛtyu (Death) is swallowing, what use is wealth, or those who give it, or the enjoyments of the senses, or the karmas that bring more births? Śrī Hari, who is the form of all the devatās, must surely have been pleased with me to bring me to this state. Vairāgya is my boat. With whatever life is left to me I shall perform tapas, dry up this body, be attentive in all the purushārthas and keep contentment in my mind. May the devatās who rule the three worlds bless me in this sādhana. Khaṭvāṅga Mahārāja attained Brahmaloka in the space of an hour.
The only thing that truly purifies and frees is jñāna, the knowledge of the ātmā. The only effort worth making is the effort toward Bhagavān Śrīhari. Everything else, even this body, is borrowed.
With this understanding, vairāgya (detachment) arose in him. He gave up everything, took to the way of saṃnyāsa, and began to wander, owning nothing, owing nothing, and expecting nothing. Śrī Kṛshṇa says that this best of brāhmaṇas gave up ahaṅkāra and mamakāra (“I” and “mine”), the knots of the heart, became peaceful, and became a sannyāsī given to contemplation. (Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 23)
The torments of the townspeople
The former miser now wandered through towns and villages as a bhikshu (a wandering beggar). Controlling his mind, senses and breath, free of attachment, he wandered the earth for alms, entering towns and villages so that no one would know him. He was plainly old, plainly poor, and plainly careless of how he looked. His age and his thin body made him an easy target.
The people of one town knew him as the miser who had gathered so much and kept it all. Now that they saw him as a beggar, they mocked him cruelly. Some stole his staff and begging bowl and hid them, then showed them again and snatched them away, again and again. Some snatched his tridaṇḍa (triple staff), some his begging bowl, some his kamaṇḍalu (water pot), others his seat, others his japamālā, the cloth he wore and his rags; they hid them, showed them, gave them back and snatched them again. When he sat down to eat his bhikshā (the food placed in his bowl), some people passed water on his head and spat on him. Śrī Kṛshṇa calls those who did this mahāpāpīs, doers of great pāpa; the brāhmaṇa was sitting on a river bank. Some tried to make him speak while he kept mauna (silence) and beat him when he did not; others threatened him, calling him a thief. Others called him a fraud and a pretender, a man who had failed at everything and now wore a renunciant’s robes to cover his poverty. “Outwardly he looks like a dharmātmā, but inside he is a cheat,” they said. “He took to begging because his wealth was lost, and his relatives have cast him off.” Some mocked him: “What great strength! A mind as steady as the king of mountains! Keeping silent he gets his work done, firm of resolve like the crane that stands silent and catches fish.” Some broke foul wind at him. They tied him with ropes. They blocked his road and would not let him go on. They tied him up like a toy, crying, “Tie him up!”
Sorrows of every kind, ādhyātmika (from his own body and mind), ādhibhautika (from other beings) and ādhidaivika (from the powers of nature, such as cold and heat), came upon him again and again. He took them as his prārabdha (the karma already set in motion), to be borne. The brāhmaṇa bore all of this without a word of protest, without a flicker of anger, and without leaving his path. Low people tried to make him fall from his sādhu-dharma (the dharma of a renunciant), but he stood firm in it, took up sāttvika dhṛti (steadiness that does not lose courage), and sang his gāthā. (Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 23)
The Bhikshu Gītā
He had borne this abuse again and again. He sat calmly on the bank of a river after his food had been defiled, and he sang:
“Who is the cause of my happiness and sorrow? Is it these people who torment me? Is it fate? Is it the planets? Is it my body? Is it my karma? No. My teachers say that the mind alone is the cause.
The cause of my happiness and sorrow is not these people, nor a devatā, nor the body, nor the grahas, nor karma, nor kāla (time). The mind alone turns the wheel of saṃsāra. The mind, very strong, creates the states that are born of the guṇas; from them come karmas, sāttvika, tāmasa and rājasa, and from those karmas come births to match them, higher, lower and middle.
The Paramātmā, a mass of the light of consciousness untouched by action, the well-wisher of the jīva, stays joined with the mind yet indifferent, a witness. But the jīva, taking the mind as himself, has the mind for his subtle body; clinging to the senses and their objects, he stays bound in saṃsāra.
Dāna (giving), one’s own dharma, yama and niyama, study, karmas and good vratas: the last fruit of them all is the control of the mind, for the one-pointed mind is the highest yoga. What need of charity and dharma has one whose mind is one-pointed and at peace? And what fruit can they bring to one whose mind is scattered or sunk in torpor?
The senses and the devatās are under the mind, but the mind is not under them. The deva called mind, who brings the fear of saṃsāra, is the strongest of the strong; whoever masters him becomes a devatā even to the devatās. The force of the mind in rāga (attachment) and dveśha (aversion) is hard to bear; it is an enemy that pierces the vital places. Fools who do not conquer it fall into useless quarrels with others.
The mind makes all the differences: friend, enemy, one who stands apart. The mind alone throws mitra (friend), udāsīna (neutral) and śatru (enemy) onto other beings, who are in truth none of these. When the mind is conquered, there is no enemy anywhere in the three worlds. And when the mind is not conquered, there is no friend either.
This body is only imagined by the mind. Blind to discernment, people say ‘I’ and ‘mine’ of it, think ‘this body is I and that body is another’, and wander in the ocean of saṃsāra, the ocean of ajñāna that has no farther shore.
Nor are these people the cause of my suffering. They act according to their nature. They cannot truly harm me, for the ātmā within me is beyond the reach of any human act. What they strike is the body. And the body is made of the five bhūtas (elements), so it belongs to them. Let them do with it what they will.
If another person causes my joy and sorrow, what has that to do with the ātmā? The ātmā is neither the doer nor the deed; doing and being done to belong to bodies, which are made of earth. If a man bites his tongue with his own teeth while eating, with whom will he be angry? If the devatās who preside over the senses are the cause, doership and enjoyership belong to them; when one limb of the body strikes another, with what will a man be angry? If the ātmā itself is the cause, then nothing comes from another, and there is nothing other than the ātmā at all; then there is no happiness and no sorrow, so why be angry?
If the grahas are the cause, what have they to do with the ātmā, which is never born? They touch only the body, which is born, and the daivajñas (knowers of the stars) say that one graha afflicts another. With whom then should one be angry? The Purusha is other than the body and the grahas. If karma is the cause, karma arises only in the knot of the inert and the conscious; the body is inert and the ātmā is pure knowledge, so real karma does not exist. At what should one be angry? If Time is the cause, the jīva is an aṃśa (portion) of the Paramātmā, and Time can do nothing to him, as fire is not burned by its own flames nor snow chilled by its own cold. In truth the jīva is beyond the pairs of opposites.
The fault is not in the planets, not in the body, not in fate, not in other jīvas. The fault is the uncontrolled mind, which takes all these shadows for real and answers as if they were threats. The mind that is not mastered drags the sādhaka helplessly from birth to birth. Ahaṅkāra alone sets up saṃsāra, and happiness and sorrow belong to ahaṅkāra. The Paramātmā, beyond even Prakṛti, never takes on the pairs of opposites, for any reason, at any time, in any place. One who has truly seen this fears no being.
So I will master it. Through yoga, through viveka (discernment), through nididhyāsana (deep meditation), through complete śaraṇāgati (taking refuge) at the feet of Śrīhari, I will cross this ocean. The only raft is his feet. As the maharshis of old were established in the ātmā beyond the body and the senses, so shall I be. The ocean of saṃsāra has no farther shore, and I can cross it only by service to the feet of Śrī Hari, the giver of moksha.”
(Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 23)
Kṛshṇa’s closing words
Bhagavān Kṛshṇa ended the account with these words to Uddhava:
“The brāhmaṇa was not broken by those townspeople. He was refined by them. Fate had stripped him of wealth. Now these people were stripping him of the last traces of pride and of the mind that reacts. Without knowing it, they were his last gurus.
When his wealth was destroyed, that bhikshu became dispassionate, took sannyāsa and became a muni given to contemplation. He wandered over the earth singing this song, and though the wicked scorned him he did not waver from his own dharma, and his sorrow left him. It is not others who give a man happiness and sorrow; to think so is a delusion of the mind. From ignorance alone come the division into friends, the indifferent and enemies, and saṃsāra itself. My dear, since saṃsāra is only imagined by the mind, control the mind in every way, with an intellect fixed one-pointedly on me.
One who truly understands the teaching of the Bhikshu Gītā, that neither joy nor sorrow has any cause outside the mind, will not be overcome by the swings of the world. For such a person the pairs of happiness and sorrow lose their power. He walks through all of it like the ākāśa (space), present everywhere and touched by nothing.
The essence of all yoga is this: govern the mind. Everything else, āsana, prāṇāyāma, yajña and dāna (giving), is a support for this one work.”
(Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapter 23)
Phalaśruti
Śrī Kṛshṇa gives the phalaśruti himself. The bhikshu sang this brahma-nishṭhā, the song of one established in Brahman. Whoever holds it in the intellect with one-pointed mind, or makes others hear it, or hears it from another, cannot be overpowered by the pairs of opposites, happiness and sorrow and the rest. In the next chapter Śrī Kṛshṇa goes on, “after the Bhikshu Gītā”, to teach Uddhava the discernment of prakṛti and purusha. (Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapters 23–24)
Sources
- Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 11, Chapters 22–24