Vishṇu’s Command to Rudra: The Origin of Deluding Doctrines

The Uttara Khaṇḍa of the Padma Purāṇa contains an account that explains, from its own Vaishṇava point of view, where the non-Vaishṇava sects and their teachings came from. (Vaishṇavas are those devoted to Bhagavān Vishṇu.) According to this account, Vishṇu told Rudra (Śiva) to create teachings that lead people astray, along with outward marks such as ash, bones and skulls. The purpose was to confuse the asuras (beings opposed to the devas and to dharma), so that they would leave the Vedic path and become easy to defeat.

Rudra obeyed on the outside, but in his heart he always worshipped Vishṇu. Vishṇu gave Rudra the Rāma nāma (the holy name of Rāma) as a secret protection.

Vishṇu’s Plan

This teaching belongs to Vishṇu’s larger plan to protect dharma. The asuras had grown too strong and were too deeply rooted in the Vedic way of life to be defeated easily. So Vishṇu made a plan: he would make them fall away from the Vedic path by giving them teachings that were attractive but misleading. He told Śiva (Rudra) to spread such teachings. They would look religious, yet they would lead people away from Vedic dharma and away from the pūjā of Vishṇu.

Rudra’s Outward Obedience and Inner Devotion

Śiva, as the greatest devotee of Vishṇu, was caught in a hard position. He was asked to preach teachings he did not himself believe, in order to protect the very Vishṇu he worshipped. On the outside he obeyed Vishṇu’s command. He created the marks of ash, bones and skulls that are connected with these practices, and he composed teachings that would draw the asuras in. But in secret, in his heart, Śiva always worshipped Vishṇu. The whole Uttara Khaṇḍa is told by Śiva to Pārvatī, and this form itself reflects that inner devotion.

Vishṇu understood Śiva’s difficulty. He gave him the Rāma nāma as a secret protection: the name of Rāma as a mantra for Śiva to hold in his own heart while he publicly spread the misleading teachings.

What This Account Implies

Within the Padma Purāṇa’s own framework, this account has important consequences:

  1. All non-Vaishṇava sects, including the Śaiva, Pāśupata and others, trace their origin to Vishṇu’s deliberate plan to mislead the asuras, and not to genuine divine revelation.
  2. Śiva himself is a secret Vaishṇava. The Tāmasa Purāṇas, the Purāṇas told by Śiva, were composed under Vishṇu’s direction to mislead those who were not fit for the truth.
  3. Because the Rāma nāma was given to Śiva as protection, Śiva constantly repeats “Rāma, Rāma”. Even Śiva’s deepest personal practice is Vaishṇava.

Sources

  • Padma Purāṇa, Uttara Khaṇḍa, Chapter 235
  • Padma Purāṇa, Uttara Khaṇḍa, Chapter 252