Two Paths to Moksha: Sadyo-Mukti and Krama-Mukti

Sadyo-Mukti Krama-Mukti · sadyas-mukti krama-mukti, “immediate release and gradual release”

Moksha (liberation) is freedom from the cycle of birth and death. The second skandha (book) of the Bhāgavata Purāṇa teaches two paths open to a jīva (individual soul) seeking this freedom. The first is sadyo-mukti, mukti at once, at the moment of death. The second is krama-mukti, mukti by stages, by way of Brahmaloka, the world of Brahmā.

The teaching is given by Śuka Maharshi (Śukadeva) as part of his account of Brahmā meditating on the Virāṭ Purusha (Bhagavān Vishṇu‘s universal form) at the time of creation. It shows that moksha through bhakti (loving devotion) is the highest, while also accepting the yogic path of rising step by step.

The Yoga of Leaving the Body

The second chapter teaches the yogic method for the moment of death. This is the way a yogī leaves the body with full awareness and rises to moksha. The teaching comes from Bhagavān Vāsudeva himself, who gave it to Brahmā when Brahmā worshipped him and asked.

A sādhaka (spiritual practitioner) who has practised dhāraṇā (fixed concentration) on the Virāṭ Purusha, and has refined his inner life step by step, should draw in his prāṇas (life-breaths) at the time of death like this:

  1. Draw all the currents of prāṇa away from the senses and the lower body into the mūlādhāra (the root cakra, at the base of the spine)
  2. From the mūlādhāra, draw the prāṇa upward through the sushumnā-nāḍī (the central channel), passing through each cakra (energy centre) in turn
  3. At the ājñā-cakra (between the eyebrows), pause and fix the attention
  4. Go on upward to the brahma-randhra (sahasrāra) at the crown of the head
  5. With a final gathering of focus, release the prāṇa through the brahma-randhra into the supreme Brahman

A sādhaka who can do this at the moment of death goes straight to Brahman. This is sadyo-mukti.

Sadyo-Mukti: Mukti at Once

Sadyo-mukti means “immediate mukti”. It is the path of the advanced sādhaka, or of the devoted bhakta, who at the moment the body falls away merges straight into Parabrahman (the Supreme Brahman) with no steps in between. The jīva does not pass through any other loka (world). It does not need to stay in Brahmaloka, and it does not wait for the mahāpralaya (the great dissolution of the universe).

This path is open to:

  • The yogī who has fully drawn in the prāṇa along the sushumnā path, as described above
  • The bhakta who has surrendered fully to Bhagavān Vishṇu, and in whose heart no attachment to the body or the world remains
  • The jñānī (one who knows the truth) who has directly seen that ātman (the Self) and Brahman are not different

In the same teaching Śuka gives the example of Khaṭvāṅga Mahārāja. This king learned that he had only one muhūrta (about 48 minutes) left to live. At once he gave up everything: body, family and kingdom. In that single muhūrta he gained moksha. His story is held up as proof that the length of practice is not what matters most. Complete vairāgya (detachment) and surrender, even in a single moment, are enough.

Krama-Mukti: Mukti by Stages

Krama-mukti means “mukti by stages”. It is the path of the sincere sādhaka who has practised yoga and dharma but has not yet let go of all attachment and karma. At death such a jīva rises through the subtle planes and reaches Brahmaloka, the world of Brahmā. It lives there until the mahāpralaya, the great dissolution at the end of Brahmā’s full life.

The lifespan of Brahmaloka: Two parārdhas, an unimaginably long time measured in Brahmā’s days. The jīva who reaches Brahmaloka is not reborn during this time. It lives there with a refined understanding, taking in the highest teachings and slowly cleansing the karma that remains.

Dissolving step by step: As the mahāpralaya draws near, the jīvas in Brahmaloka see, and take part in, the elements dissolving back into their causes one after another. It happens in the reverse order of creation:

  1. The gross elements dissolve into the tanmātras (subtle elements)
  2. The tanmātras dissolve into ahaṃkāra (the sense of “I”)
  3. Ahaṃkāra dissolves into mahat-tattva (cosmic intelligence)
  4. Mahat-tattva dissolves into Prakṛti (primal nature)
  5. Prakṛti dissolves into Parabrahman

With this last dissolution all remaining karma is used up, and the jīva merges into Parabrahman. This is krama-mukti: moksha gained at the mahāpralaya after living in Brahmaloka.

Śuka’s Teaching, Step by Step

Śuka Maharshi gives this teaching to Parīkshit in Skandha 2, Chapter 2, after telling how Brahmā regained his memory of creation by dhāraṇā and how the seeker should meditate on the four-armed form of Śrī Hari in the heart and on the Virāṭ form until bhakti is firm.

Sadyo-mukti

“O Rājā, if a seeker established in yoga wishes to leave this world,” he should sit in a firm, comfortable āsana, do prāṇāyāma with a saṅkalpa (resolve), and draw the senses back from their objects, not fixing his mind on place or time. With his pure buddhi he controls the mind and merges that buddhi into the drashṭā (seer) who witnesses it; he makes the drashṭā one with pure consciousness, the pratyagātmā, and that one with Parabrahman, and attains the bliss of the ātmā. Then nothing remains to be done, and he ceases from effort. Kāla, which rules even the devas, cannot bring that ātmā under its sway; it is beyond sattva, rajas and tamas, and in Parabrahman, not different from the ātmā, prakṛti, the mahat-tattva and ahaṅkāra are only imagined.

Those who seek to know, saying “this is not the real thing, this is not the real thing”, give up the sense of “I” in the body and in all that is not the ātmā. Every moment they hold in the heart the form of Śrī Hari, which is satya, jñāna and ananta (truth, knowledge and the infinite), and are attached to nothing else. The maharshis, quoting the Vedas, call the pratyagātmā, where all negation ends, the Vaishṇava parama-pada, the supreme goal.

Through the cakras. The seeker whose desires have been destroyed by knowledge of the śāstra received through the guru withdraws from karmas that bear fruit and stays established in ātma-jñāna. At the time of leaving the body he throws off weariness, presses the anus with the heel, and brings the prāṇa-śakti upward through the six places:

  1. svādhishṭhāna, at the lower belly;
  2. maṇipūra, at the navel;
  3. anāhata, at the heart;
  4. viśuddhi, at the throat;
  5. ājñā, between the eyebrows;
  6. sahasrāra, the brahmarandhra.

The yati makes the prāṇa in the maṇipūra climb to the anāhata, and from there by the path of the udāna-vāyu brings it into the viśuddhi below the throat. Having conquered the mind, he joins it with the buddhi and slowly brings it to the root of the palate. Longing for no svarga or other loka, he closes the seven openings, the two nostrils, the two eyes, the two ears and the mouth, and brings the prāṇa from the root of the palate into the ājñā between the eyebrows. Fixing his buddhi on his goal, Brahman not different from the pratyagātmā, he remains in that state for about half an hour; then he breaks through the brahmarandhra and becomes one with the Paramātmā.

If the yogī wishes to go to a loka

The seeker who goes to Brahmaloka, or to the playgrounds of the siddhas who move through the sky with the eight powers beginning with aṇimā, or to any other place in the brahmāṇḍa, goes with mind and senses, that is, with the subtle body. The best of yogīs, who have perfected upāsana, the dharma of Bhagavān Vishṇu, ashṭāṅga-yoga and right knowledge, have a body subtle as the wind and can move as they wish inside and outside the brahmāṇḍa; no one gains this state by karmas.

Krama-mukti

“O Rājā, the shining sushumnā nāḍī is the path to Brahmaloka.” By it the yogī leaves the body and by the path of the sky reaches Agni Devatā, where the faults still left in him are destroyed. Then he reaches the Śiśumāra circle of lights, which belongs to Śrī Hari and is like the navel of the Virāṭ Purusha. With a very subtle body free of faults he passes beyond it to Maharloka, the loka of those who worship saguṇa Brahman, where the devas whose life lasts until the pralaya take their delight. At the end of the kalpa he sees the lower lokas burnt to ash by the flames from the hoods of Ādiśesha, and he reaches Brahmaloka, where great siddhas roam in vimānas and live for two parārdhas. The text gives the measure: a thousand mahāyugas are one kalpa; two kalpas are one day of Brahmā; and in that measure fifty years are one parārdha. There is no old age there, no death, no pain of body and no anxiety of mind; the only pain the siddhas know is their compassion when they see beings who do not know this meditation on Parameśvara born in low wombs and suffering without end.

The dissolution of the tattvas

Then the siddha, knowing no fear, reaches with his subtle body the earth-principle and dissolves it into water, becoming of the nature of water; that he enters into fire and becomes full of light; after a time, without haste, he dissolves fire into vāyu, and vāyu into ākāśa, which shows forth the infinitude of the Paramātmā. He merges the senses into their tanmātras: smell into gandha, taste into rasa, sight into rūpa, touch into sparśa and hearing into śabda, and each organ of action into its own action. The tanmātras of the five mahābhūtas he merges into tāmasa-ahaṅkāra, the senses into rājasa-ahaṅkāra, and the mind and the devatās of the senses into sāttvika-ahaṅkāra. Ahaṅkāra he merges into the mahat-tattva, and that into the māyā-śakti where sattva, rajas and tamas come to rest. When his subtle body has merged into prakṛti, his tie to every upādhi ends, and with prakṛti he merges into the Paramātmā, changeless and a mass of bliss. The jñānī who has thus become one with Bhagavān Vishṇu is not born in this world again.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapter 2

Bhakti as the Highest Path

Having laid out both paths, Śuka, and Brahmā in the teaching he reports, conclude that bhakti to Hari (Vishṇu) is the highest dharma and the most direct road to moksha. The yogic path of rising through the cakras and the gradual road through Brahmaloka are both valid. But the bhakta who is absorbed in the glories of Bhagavān Vishṇu, who weeps on hearing hari-kathā (stories of Hari), and who sees everything as Bhagavān Vishṇu’s own form does not depend on a technically perfect practice at death. Bhagavān Vishṇu himself receives such a devotee.

Śuka tells Parīkshit that these two eternal paths of moksha are praised in the Veda, and that of old, when Brahmā worshipped Bhagavān Vāsudeva and asked him, Vāsudeva himself told Brahmā about them. There is no path more auspicious than the means by which one fallen into saṃsāra gains bhakti to Bhagavān Vāsudeva. Brahmā, without wavering, examined the Veda three times and decided that the highest dharma is that by which love arises for Śrī Hari, who shines in all beings as the witness-consciousness. “So, O Rājā, men should in all places and at all times hear of Śrī Hari with a one-pointed mind; if there is no one to speak, they should sing his glory together with others; if there are no others, they should meditate.” The mahātmās share out the amṛta of the accounts of Śrī Hari, and those who fill the leaf-cups of their ears with it and drink it cleanse their hearts of the desire for enjoyment and come near to the lotus feet of Parameśvara.

Source: Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapter 2

This teaching leads naturally into the theme of Chapter 3 of the second skandha. Even those who cannot practise the demanding yoga of drawing in the prāṇa have a path. Devatā-upāsanā (worship of the devas) can prepare them, and the company of Bhagavān Vishṇu’s bhaktas purifies even those with no training in yoga.

Sources

  • Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Skandha 2, Chapters 1–3