Transfer of Puṇya and Pāpa

Puṇya is the merit, or good result, that comes from dharmic actions. Pāpa is the harmful result that comes from wrong actions. Chapter 112 of the Uttara Khaṇḍa of the Padma Purāṇa records a careful teaching by Bhagavān Kṛshṇa to his queen Satyabhāmā on how puṇya and pāpa can pass from one person to another even when they are not deliberately given.

Satyabhāmā asked because she had heard how Kalahā was freed by puṇya that another person gave her. Kṛshṇa’s answer sets out a graded scale of shares that pass between people, depending on the kind and closeness of contact or relationship. It also gives special rules for kings, teachers, husbands and lenders.

The Question

Satyabhāmā had heard the story of how the rākshasī Kalahā was freed. The brāhmaṇa Dharmadatta had given her half of the puṇya he had earned by keeping the holy month of Kārtika. Satyabhāmā then asked Bhagavān Kṛshṇa: “If a person can receive the puṇya given by another, then in what way does a person receive puṇya without it being openly given to them?” This question led to the full teaching of Chapter 112.

The Rule for the Kali Age

First comes an important ruling. In the Kali Yuga (the present age), only the doer receives the fruit of his own puṇya or pāpa. In earlier ages, by contrast, a whole region, a village or an entire family shared in the puṇya or pāpa of an act. The sharing by parts described below holds good in every age. It is especially worth understanding because, through contact, it works even within the Kali Yuga, where karma is otherwise personal.

How Much Passes Through Each Kind of Contact

Bhagavān Kṛshṇa lists the shares of puṇya and pāpa that pass to another person through particular kinds of contact:

ShareKind of contact
½ (one-half)Being paired together; travelling together; eating from the same pot
¼ (one-quarter)Teaching; serving as the ṛtvij (officiating brāhmaṇa) at a yajña; eating in the same row
⅙ (one-sixth)Sitting on the same seat; riding in the same vehicle; another person’s breath touching the body
1/10 (one-tenth)Touching; talking; praising another person
1/100 (one-hundredth)Seeing; listening to; thinking of another person in one’s mind

The Rule of Reversal

A person who speaks ill of another, acts wickedly toward another or treats another with disrespect suffers a double loss. He takes on the pāpa committed by the person he criticises, and at the same time he passes his own stored-up puṇya to that person. This makes criticising and disrespecting others among the most spiritually costly acts in this teaching.

Special Rules

Several particular situations have their own rulings:

Service without fair payment: Anyone other than a wife, a hired servant or a disciple who serves a person of puṇya and is not properly paid gets a share of that person’s puṇya in keeping with the service given.

Serving at meals: A server at a meal who fails to serve one person sitting in the same row as the others takes on one-sixth of that person’s pāpa.

During sandhyā and bathing: Someone who touches or speaks to another person while that person is bathing or doing sandhyā (the daily prayers at dawn, noon and dusk) gives away one-sixth of his own puṇya to that person.

Paying for a dharmic act: A person who gives money to someone who uses it for a dharmic purpose receives the fruit of that dharmic act. On the other hand, a person who performs a dharmic act with wealth taken from someone else earns pāpa, while the fruit of the act goes to the person whose wealth was taken.

Debt: If a person borrows money for a dharmic purpose and dies without repaying it, the wealthy lender shares in that person’s puṇya in proportion to the amount left unpaid.

Helping an act happen: The one who gives the idea, the one who approves it, the one who provides the tool and the one who forces another to act all four receive one-sixth of the puṇya or pāpa that comes from the act.

Shares That Flow Upward

The teaching names certain relationships in which puṇya naturally flows to one side:

  • A king takes one-sixth of the puṇya and pāpa of each of his subjects.
  • A guru (teacher) receives half the puṇya of his disciple.
  • A husband receives half the puṇya of his wife.
  • A father receives half the puṇya of his son.
  • A wife also receives half the puṇya of her husband, since by serving and pleasing him she acts in keeping with his wishes.
  • When a gift is given through another person’s hand (other than a hired servant or a son), the go-between takes one-sixth of the puṇya.

What This Teaching Shows

This teaching explains why it is spiritually dangerous to stay close to people who do wrong, since parts of their pāpa pass to those near them. It also explains the great spiritual benefit of being near, serving and keeping company with the virtuous, the Vaishṇavas (devotees of Vishṇu) and the wise. It gives the reason behind the Purāṇic teaching that holy months such as Kārtika and Māgha bring far greater puṇya: every act done in them is more concentrated, and those who keep these months pass their extra puṇya on to those near them.

Sources

  • Padma Purāṇa, Uttara Khaṇḍa, Chapter 112