Purushakāra in the Vishṇu Dharmottara Purāṇa

Purushakāra · purusha-kāra, “human effort”

Purushakāra (also called paurusha) means human effort. Daiva means destiny, the stored-up karma of past lives. Chapter 66 of the second part (Dvitīya Khaṇḍa) of the Vishṇu Dharmottara Purāṇa is given over to this old question: how much do destiny and human effort each count in deciding what happens?

Pushkara answers firmly in favour of effort. Bhagavān Vishṇu helps those who help themselves with full intelligence and commitment. This is one of the most important chapters of the Dvitīya Khaṇḍa for its ideas.

The Question

Paraśurāma puts the question to Pushkara. Of the two forces that shape what happens, daiva (destiny, the karma gathered in past lives) and purushakāra (human effort in the present), which is stronger? Is there any point in human effort if destiny is already fixed?

Pushkara’s Answer

Pushkara answers by taking apart the idea that everything is fated.

First argument: what we can see. In this world we see two people of much the same birth, family and way of life reach different results purely because of the effort they make. The one who studies hard learns; the one who does not study does not learn, whatever his “potential” may seem to be. This plain fact alone shows that purushakāra is a real force that decides outcomes.

Second argument: daiva is itself the fruit of past purushakāra. What looks like destiny in this life is really the stored-up result of effort made in past lives. No destiny comes from nowhere; every situation that seems fixed in advance was made by someone’s earlier action. So purushakāra is always the first cause, and daiva is simply older purushakāra.

Third argument: Bhagavān Vishṇu’s grace answers effort. The Vaishṇava tradition makes plain what this means. Bhagavān Vishṇu does not hand out his grace at random or out of favouritism. His grace flows toward those who make a real effort toward dharma and liberation. The devotee who practises with complete sincerity and effort receives the most grace; the one who waits idly for grace to come down receives much less. So the greatest purushakāra is also the way to draw the greatest daiva, in the sense of divine favour.

The Example of Cyavana

Pushkara uses Cyavana Ṛshi as an example. By the circumstances of his birth (daiva), Cyavana was born old and frail. But through his tapas (austerity), which was purushakāra of the highest kind, he became a great ṛshi whose power of tapas was strong enough to create Mada. And through the gift of the Aśvins, which came as a reward for his spiritual effort and for Sukanyā’s pativratā (her devotion as a faithful wife), he received a young body. His daiva gave him a hard start; his purushakāra rose completely above it.

The Lesson for a King

This chapter is placed on purpose just before the section on sāma, dāna, bheda and daṇḍa (Chapters 67 to 70): the methods of conciliation, gifts, division and force. The point is this. A king who believes in fate will sit and wait for victory. A king who believes in purushakāra will use every means he has, sāma, bheda, dāna and daṇḍa, with full intelligence and commitment. The teaching is that the saptopāya (the seven means of statecraft) are the practical form that purushakāra takes in running a state.

Balance: Daiva Is Not Denied

Pushkara is careful not to deny daiva altogether:

  • There are situations where a person’s stored-up karma creates an obstacle that no amount of effort in this life can overcome
  • In such cases, patience and a life of dharma build up the purushakāra of future lives
  • The teaching is not that effort always wins the exact result one wants, but that effort always builds something and is never wasted. Effort that does not bear fruit in one direction is stored up as an advantage in another direction or another life

The balanced teaching is this: make the fullest effort; offer the fruits to Bhagavān Kṛshṇa, as the Bhagavad Gītā teaches; and trust that this union of human effort and divine grace will bring the best result possible in one’s circumstances.

Sources

  • Vishṇu Dharmottara Purāṇa, Uttarārdha (Dvitīya Khaṇḍa), Chapter 66