Rising and Falling in Varṇa: Śiva’s Teaching in the Anuśāsana Parva
A varṇa is one of the four classes of traditional society: brāhmaṇa, kshatriya, vaiśya and śūdra. In Chapter 143 of the Mahābhārata’s Anuśāsana Parva, part of the conversation between Umā and Maheśvara (the Umā-Maheśvara Saṃvāda), Śiva explains exactly how a person can move between the varṇas. A person may fall from a higher varṇa to a lower one by abandoning svadharma (one’s own duty), through greed, or by eating forbidden food. In the other direction, a śūdra may rise step by step through the vaiśya and kshatriya varṇas to become a dvija (twice-born), and a kshatriya may become a brāhmaṇa by dying honourably for cows and brāhmaṇas.
The high point of the chapter, repeated for emphasis, is that birth, saṃskāra (life-cycle rites), vidyā (learning) and descendants are not the true cause of being a brāhmaṇa. Ācāra (conduct) alone is the cause. So a śūdra of pure conduct is higher than a dvija of impure conduct.
Umā’s Question
Umā addresses Śiva by names that recall how he destroyed Bhaga’s eyes and Pūshan’s teeth and broke up Daksha’s yajña (sacred offering). She asks: since it was Śiva himself, as Svayambhū (the self-born), who set up the fourfold order of varṇas, by what karma-vipāka (ripening of karma) does a vaiśya become a śūdra, a kshatriya a vaiśya, and a brāhmaṇa a kshatriya? How can this pratiloma-dharma (movement downward, against the natural order) be stopped? By what deed is a brāhmaṇa born from the womb of a śūdra woman? And in the other direction, how do the three lower varṇas rise to brāhmaṇatva (the state of a brāhmaṇa)?
Falling from a Varṇa
Śiva begins by affirming that brāhmaṇatva is not easily won. It is prakṛti-siddha (established by inner nature), and in the same way the state of kshatriya, vaiśya and śūdra is janma-siddha (established by birth). Yet a dvija born into the first varṇa who abandons his station through pāpa-karma (wrong deeds) becomes bhrashṭa (fallen) from it. That is why one must guard one’s station. In the other direction, a kshatriya or śūdra who becomes firmly established in brāhmaṇa-dharma reaches brahmatva, the brāhmaṇa state itself.
Falling Through Conduct
- A brāhmaṇa who gives up the marks of a brāhmaṇa (brāhmaṇa-lakshaṇa) and takes up kshatriya-dharma falls from the brāhmaṇa state and is born in a kshatriya womb (in a later life).
- A brāhmaṇa who has won the rare gift of brāhmaṇatva but cannot give up lobha (greed) and moha (delusion), and takes up the livelihood of a vaiśya (vaiśya-vṛtti), becomes a vaiśya. A vaiśya who abandons his dharma in the same way becomes a śūdra. And a brāhmaṇa who abandons his svadharma completely falls all the way to the state of a śūdra, loses his place in the brāhmaṇa community (brāhmaṇa-samudāya), and becomes bahishkṛta (excluded, outcast).
- A kshatriya or vaiśya who abandons his own work and takes up śūdra work likewise falls to the state of a śūdra through varṇa-sāṅkarya (mixing of varṇas). Whether he began as brāhmaṇa, kshatriya or vaiśya, this is his gati (destination).
- Whatever a person’s varṇa, if he has buddhi-bala (strength of mind), gains jñāna-vijñāna (knowledge and realised wisdom) through his own dharma, is pariśuddha (pure), knows dharma, and is firmly resolved to uphold it, he enjoys the fruit of that dharma whatever varṇa he was born into. This statement qualifies the whole teaching on moving between varṇas: conduct comes first.
Forbidden Food and Its Karmic Result
A further teaching, said to come from Brahmā himself, is about food. Dvijas must never eat ugra-anna (food gained through violence or harshness), stale or badly prepared food, food from a house in a state of birth or death impurity (śrāddha-sūtaka), dushṭa-anna (spoiled or tainted food) or śūdra-anna (food from a śūdra). The great devas themselves call śūdra-anna nindya (to be condemned). This was spoken from Brahmā’s own mouth and so carries authority.
A dvija who dies with śūdra-anna still undigested in his stomach reaches the gati of a śūdra, even if he was āhitāgni (one who keeps the sacred fires) and a performer of yajñas. He falls from the station of a brāhmaṇa (brahma-sthāna) precisely because of that remaining śūdra-anna, “and there is no question about this.” More generally, whatever varṇa’s food remains undigested in a dvija’s stomach at the moment of death, he is reborn in a womb of that varṇa and lives by that food.
One who has gained the rare gift of brāhmaṇatva, then disrespects it and eats forbidden foods, will surely fall from the state of a dvija. Eating from a shared cooking pot (kuṇāśī), trading in soma improperly and serving base people (hīna) all make a vipra (brāhmaṇa) fall from his brāhmaṇa birth.
Acts That Cause a Fall Despite Learning
A brāhmaṇa falls from brāhmaṇatva, even if he is a brahma-vettā (knower of Brahman), if he: drinks liquor; commits brahmahatyā (killing of a brāhmaṇa); is mean or a thief; breaks a vrata (vow); lacks śuddhi (purity); has not studied the Veda; is pāpātmā (wicked), lobhī (greedy), without dayā (compassion) or stubborn; lives without vows and rules (vrata-niyama); is the husband of a śūdra woman; approaches his guru’s wife; commits guru-droha (betrayal of the guru); or takes pleasure in nindā (speaking ill) of the guru.
Rising Through the Varṇas
Śiva then teaches the exact, step-by-step path by which the lower varṇas rise.
From Śūdra to Vaiśya
A śūdra reaches the state of a vaiśya (vaiśyatva) by these means:
- Doing a śūdra’s work without fault, according to nyāya (fairness) and śāstra
- Giving śuśrūshā and paricaryā (service and attendance) to the first varṇas with effort
- Always walking the good path without letting his mind be corrupted
- Doing as he is told
- Honouring devas and brāhmaṇas
- Holding firmly to sarva-ātithya (hospitality to all)
- Approaching his wife only in the proper season (ṛtu-kāla)
- Keeping rules (niyamas) about food
- Remaining pariśuddha (pure)
- Seeking the company of the pure
- Eating only what his atithis (guests) leave
From Vaiśya to Kshatriya
A vaiśya who seeks the state of a kshatriya must: not eat meat without need; speak only satya (truth); not speak with ahaṅkāra (ego); stay unmoved by dvandvas (pairs of opposites such as heat and cold, joy and sorrow); be discerning in śama (inner calm); offer pūjā to the devas with daily yajñas; be devoted to the branches of learning set for him; be śuci (clean) and practise indriya-nigraha (control of the senses); hold brāhmaṇas in honour; and show respect to all varṇas.
Firm in the vow of the householder (gṛhastha-vrata), he eats only twice a day, eats what remains after his guests have eaten, is not restless or greedy about food, is not a slave to kāma (desire), and never speaks with ahaṅkāra. He tends the agnihotra (daily fire offering), performs homa according to vidhi (rule), gives full hospitality (ātithya) and eats what remains. By using the mantras of the three sacred fires (tretāgni) according to śāstra, the vaiśya becomes a dvija and is born into a noble kshatriya family (kshatriya-kula).
Born as a kshatriya from the start of life, receiving the proper saṃskāras and upanayana (sacred-thread initiation), and firm in his vows, he becomes a dvija through the strength of saṃskāra. He gives dāna (gifts), performs yajñas with generous dakshiṇā (offerings to the officiants), studies the Veda, and seeks svarga (the heavenly realm), while his home blazes with the three sacred fires.
From Kshatriya to Brāhmaṇa
A kshatriya becomes a brāhmaṇa if he:
- Always gives his hand to those in distress and rules the people with dharma
- Stands in satya, lives by truthful conduct and sees only sukha (happiness)
- Gives just daṇḍa (punishment), punishes the guilty without fail, directs dharmic works, and stays bound to what must be done (kārya) and the means of doing it (karaṇa)
- Rules the kingdom taking only a sixth part as tax
- Does not perform dharmic acts without the proper saṃskāras, is skilled in the right use of wealth, and approaches his wife with a dharmic mind (dharma-buddhi) only in ṛtu-kāla
- Is a sadopavāsī (one who fasts except at the set times), holds to niyama (discipline), is devoted to study of the Veda, is pariśuddha, and sleeps in the house of the agnihotra on a bed strewn with darbha grass
- Above all, stands before the enemy and dies for the sake of cows and brāhmaṇas, his buddhi purified by the mantras of the three sacred fires
So a kshatriya who, through his own karma, gains the wealth of jñāna-vijñāna, receives the proper saṃskāras and is dharmātmā (righteous) becomes a vipra. And through this same fruit of karma, even a śūdra born in a lower jāti (birth-group) who gains the wealth of the āgamas (sacred teachings) and receives the saṃskāras becomes a dvija.
The Heart of the Teaching: Conduct Alone Makes the Brāhmaṇa
Śiva then states the central principle of the teaching in its most direct form:
“A śūdra who is pariśuddha in buddhi through pure karmas, and who has achieved victory over the indriyas, deserves to be served exactly as a dvija is served — Brahmā himself declared this. Wherever svabhāva and śubha-karma are established, that śūdra is to be known as superior to the dvija — this is my own considered view.”
“Birth, saṃskāra, vidyā, and offspring are not the causes of brāhmaṇatva — conduct (ācāra) alone is the cause. Every brāhmaṇa in the world is reckoned a brāhmaṇa by conduct alone; a śūdra firmly established in good conduct likewise attains brāhmaṇatva.”
(Indriyas are the senses; svabhāva is one’s inner nature; śubha-karma means good deeds.)
Śiva puts it another way as well: “Brahman is svabhāva — it does not exist in one uniform way everywhere; it is nirmala, without guṇa-saṃparka.” (Nirmala means spotless; guṇa-saṃparka means contact with the guṇas, the qualities of nature.) “In whomever this Brahman abides, that one is dvija — this is my view.” He notes that these teachings on moving between varṇas concern the fruits of birth (janma-phala) and how station is given, and that they were declared by Brahmā himself, the creator of beings, who gives varas (boons).
The Field and the Seed
Śiva closes with an image. A brāhmaṇa in this world is like a great field with the power of gamana (movement): the seed sown there still grows into a crop even after the sower has died. In other words, teaching and dharma sown in a worthy field bear fruit beyond the life of the one who sowed them.
One who seeks the good must always be a vighasa-bhojī, one who eats only what remains after others are fed, and must reach and travel this brahma-mārga (path to Brahman). In the home, the gṛhastha must never fail in study of the Veda, must never give up his own branch of the Veda (Veda-śākhā), and must never turn Veda study into a mere livelihood. One who is established in this way, whose sanmārga (good path) is firm, who walks the good path, keeps the sacred fires (āhitāgni) and studies the Veda, becomes able to become Brahman.
Last of all: brāhmaṇya (the brāhmaṇa state), once earned through pure birth, pratigraha (receiving gifts rightly) and above all generous dāna, must be actively protected through mano-nigraha (control of the mind), because it can be lost as well as gained.
Sources
- Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapter 143