Gaṇadharma

Gaṇadharma · gaṇa-dharma, “the dharma of communities”

A gaṇa is a state ruled not by a single king but by an assembly of equals, usually kshatriyas (members of the warrior and ruling class) of similar rank. Gaṇadharma is the dharma (right conduct and duty) that governs such an assembly. Bhīshma teaches it in Chapter 107 of the Śānti Parva of the Mahābhārata, as a way of ruling distinct from rājadharma, the dharma of kings.

Bhīshma explains that gaṇas need a dharma of their own. What makes them prosper is quite different from what makes kingdoms prosper, and their weak points are different too.

What Is a Gaṇa?

In the political thought of the Mahābhārata period, a gaṇa is a state built around an assembly (gaṇa or sabhā) of powerful people, usually kshatriya chiefs or nobles, rather than around a king who inherits the throne. Gaṇas known from the history of ancient India include the Vṛjis, the Mallas, the Licchavis and others. They worked as councils or early republics, in which the power to decide was shared, at least in form, among the members of the assembly.

The Mahābhārata accepts the gaṇa as a rightful form of rule. It is different from rājya (kingship) but not lower than it, so long as it keeps the particular dharma that suits its structure.

The Special Dharma of Gaṇas

Bhīshma names several principles that are especially important for gaṇas.

Unity Within

A gaṇa draws its strength from the combined force of its members. If the members are divided, if faction, rivalry and envy wear away the unity of the assembly, the gaṇa becomes open to outside enemies. No outside force can easily defeat a gaṇa whose members truly act together. But a gaṇa divided within is weak even before a fairly small outside enemy.

Holding together is therefore both the gaṇa’s main challenge and, when kept, its main strength. To keep it, the members must:

  • Put down envy (asūyā) toward one another
  • Not seek gain for themselves at the cost of the whole group
  • Settle disputes through the assembly, not through private feuds
  • Keep the agreements made together

Protecting Women and the Weaker Members

A gaṇa that lets its strong members exploit or harm women, the young or the less powerful in the community loses the bond that holds it together. Protecting those who cannot protect themselves is as much a duty of gaṇadharma as defeating outside enemies.

The Danger of One Member Becoming Too Strong

A gaṇa faces a danger from within that kingdoms do not. If one member grows much stronger than the others, he may turn the gaṇa into a kingdom in all but name, with himself as its actual king. When this happens through force or scheming rather than a proper decision of the whole assembly, it breaks gaṇadharma. The assembly must watch closely to stop any one member from gathering too much power.

Keeping Discussions Secret

What the assembly discusses, the policies under debate, the disagreements within the group and the plans being made, must stay within the assembly. If outside enemies learn of the gaṇa’s inner discussions, they can take advantage of the divisions and doubts that come with any decision made by a group.

Gaṇa and Kingdom

The Śānti Parva’s teaching on gaṇadharma and rājadharma can be set out as follows:

AspectKingdomGaṇa
Source of authorityThe king’s personal virtue and daṇḍa (power to punish)Shared agreement and acting together
Main weak pointThe king’s personal failingsFaction and envy within
How decisions are madeThe king with his ministersDiscussion in the assembly
Unit of ruleA kingdom centred on the kingA league of equals

Historical Setting

The age of the Mahābhārata was the last period of the great gaṇa-saṅghas (councils and leagues) of ancient India. The text’s attention to gaṇadharma reflects the political world of the time: these leagues were important powers, and a full teaching on how to rule had to deal with them.

The teaching also fits the story of the Mahābhārata itself. Both the Kauravas and the Pāṇḍavas drew on the support of various gaṇas in the war. Bhīshma’s knowledge of gaṇadharma shows how complete his training in statecraft was.

Sources

  • Mahābhārata, Śānti Parva, Rājadharmānuśāsana Parva, Chapter 107