Dharma Praśaṃsā
Dharma Praśaṃsā, “the praise of dharma”
Dharma Praśaṃsā means “in praise of dharma”. It is the name given here to Bhīshma’s further teaching to Yudhishṭhira in Chapters 163 and 164 of the Mahābhārata’s Anuśāsana Parva. It deals with effort, fate, and the eternal nature of dharma.
The teaching begins from something anyone can see: effort often fails, while good fortune sometimes arrives unearned. It ends with the teaching that kāla (time) is what makes dharma sanātana (eternal). Dharma guarded by time cannot finally be touched by adharma. Even creatures born as animals and birds follow their own dharma without fault, because for them the world itself (loka) is their guru.
Why Effort Fails and Fortune Arrives
Yudhishṭhira opens Chapter 163 with a hard observation. A person without good fortune (adṛshṭa) may be very strong and still fail to gain wealth. A person favoured by fortune may be a weak child and still gain plenty. When the time is against someone, no effort, however great, brings wealth. When the time is right, wealth comes even without effort. Hundreds of people work hard and get nothing; hundreds grow rich without working at all. Some who know nītiśāstra (the science of right policy) act against their own learning, while some who understand nothing become trusted ministers.
Knowledge itself, Yudhishṭhira notes, does not promise a living. Some people study only to earn a living and stay poor anyway. Yet, he adds, once knowledge has borne any fruit at all, it should never be given up. A man whose kāla (time) has run out dies even if struck by a hundred arrows that do not wound him. Put the other way, a man whose time has not run out does not die even from the touch of a blade of grass. Time, not the weapon, is what truly acts.
Bhīshma does not deny this puzzle. He answers it with a call to keep going rather than give up. Someone who wants much and works for it should, if wealth still does not come through effort, turn to tapas (austerity), for “a plant does not sprout without a seed being sown” in the first place. The wise teach that dāna (giving) brings bhoga (enjoyment), service to elders brings medhā (wisdom), and ahiṃsā (non-violence) brings dīrghāyus (long life).
From this Bhīshma draws a practical rule: give, and do not beg; honour those who live by dharma; be gentle in speech, kind in action, calm in temperament, and free from violence towards every being. Birth (janma), one’s nature, and the very experience of joy and sorrow are all governed by karma as their measure. This can be seen even in how flies, worms and ants feel their own pleasure and pain by the same law. Yudhishṭhira is told to see this and to stay sthira (steady) in the light of it.
The same tension between effort and fate is the main subject of a fuller teaching Bhīshma gives earlier in the Anuśāsana Parva, in Chapter 6, through the conversation between Vasishṭha and Brahmā and the picture of the seed and the field. The saying about the arrows and the blade of grass, and the call to tapas, are best read as Bhīshma coming back to that same ground in a shorter, proverb-like way.
Time as the Ground of Dharma’s Eternity
Chapter 164 turns to deeper ground. Bhīshma teaches that whatever is good or bad, whether a person does it or causes it to be done, comes from the same source. Kāla itself, moving forever through all beings, drives them by turns towards niyama (restraint) and its opposite. It is kāla that can rightly be said to make dharma and adharma happen at all.
Conviction is the key to this teaching. Only when a person has seen the fruit of dharma for himself does he become dharma-ātman (one whose very self is dharma) and dṛḍha-buddhi (firm of mind) in it. Without that conviction from experience there is no real śraddhā (faith), only borrowed belief. The wise, having understood both what should be done (kartavya) and what should not (akartavya), should act on what still remains to be done, moving in step with time and not against it.
However far adharma may seem to spread and cover the world, Bhīshma insists that it can never finally touch a dharma that time itself is protecting, just as fire cannot be grasped even by someone determined to grasp it.
The Śūdra, Self-Knowledge and the Oneness Beneath
Bhīshma carries this teaching into the question of varṇa. The śāstras do not give a śūdra formal adhikāra (eligibility) for the four āśramas, the stages of life. But a śūdra should not use this as a chala, an excuse, to turn away from ātma-jñāna, knowledge of the Self. All beings alike are made of the five bhūtas (elements) and share a single ātman (Self). The different varṇa-dharmas the śāstras give to each group do not deny this oneness. They are the very means by which all beings, each following its own path, are in time brought back to it.
Even Animals and Insects Have Their Dharma
Bhīshma ends with a teaching that reaches beyond human life altogether. Beings born as paśu and pakshī (animals and birds) also live out the dharma that fits their condition, according to their pūrva-karma (past karma). There is no dosha (fault) in this. For such beings, “loka”, the world they are born into and its immediate conditions, acts as their guru.
Sources
- Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapters 163–164