Bhojyābhojya-Anna: Rules on Whose Food May Be Eaten
Bhojyābhojya-Anna · bhojya-abhojya-anna, “food fit and unfit to eat”
Bhojya means “fit to be eaten” and abhojya means “not fit to be eaten”. The Bhojyābhojya-Anna-Kathanam is a teaching in the Anuśāsana Parva of the Mahābhārata. In it Bhīshma answers Yudhishṭhira’s question: from whom may a person of each of the four varṇas (social classes) properly accept food?
The chapter sets out strict rules, based on varṇa, about sharing food. It then lists a number of ways of earning a living whose food is forbidden, whatever the giver’s varṇa by birth, and it compares eating such food to eating things that are unclean. These rules belong to the text’s own teaching on food and purity.
The Rule by Varṇa
Yudhishṭhira asked Bhīshma who may properly give food to a brāhmaṇa, a kshatriya, a vaiśya and a śūdra. Bhīshma answered:
- A brāhmaṇa may eat food given by brāhmaṇas, kshatriyas and vaiśyas. Śūdras must be left out in this respect.
- A kshatriya may likewise eat food from brāhmaṇas, kshatriyas and vaiśyas. Śūdras, who eat everything without distinction and follow conduct that goes against the rules (viruddha-karma), are to be avoided.
- For both brāhmaṇas and kshatriyas, the food of vaiśyas is acceptable when those vaiśyas are always devoted to pūjā of Agni (the sacred fire), do not mix freely with everyone, and are devoted to the cāturmāsya vratas (the vows of the four months of the rainy season).
The text says that one who eats a śūdra’s food eats the very filth of the earth and drinks the waste of ordinary people. A dvija (twice-born person) who eats śūdra food is likewise said to eat the filth of the earth. It is not only the food of those born śūdras that is forbidden. A brāhmaṇa, kshatriya or vaiśya who takes up śūdra-karma (menial service) as his own work suffers torment in naraka (the lower world of suffering), whatever his birth.
The True Marks of Each Varṇa
Bhīshma makes clear that the varṇas are properly defined by conduct, not by birth alone:
- Those devoted to the welfare of all beings and to Vedic study alone are true brāhmaṇas.
- One devoted to rakshaṇa (protection) is called a kshatriya.
- One devoted to poshaṇa (feeding and supporting others) is rightly a vaiśya.
The vaiśya’s own kinds of work, farming, keeping cattle and trade, followed as a living, are not to be looked down on. But one who gives up the proper work of his own varṇa and takes up śūdra-karma in effect becomes a śūdra himself, and his food must never be eaten in any case.
Forbidden Ways of Living and What Their Food Is Likened To
Bhīshma then lists ways of earning a living whose food carries particular doshas (faults), whatever the person’s formal varṇa. Physicians (vaidyas), town or city guards (nagara-rakshakas), paid purohitas (priests), astrologers (those who live by jyotisha), and those who live by tricks or by empty learning (vṛthā-adhyayana) are all counted as equal to śūdras.
Eating the food of those who shamelessly live by śūdra-vṛtti (the work of a śūdra) brings terrible bhaya (fear) on the eater. He is said to have eaten what should not be eaten (abhojya-bhojana). Such an eater loses kula (family standing), śakti (strength) and tejas (radiance). He is born as an animal or bird, and, having given up dharma, becomes as inert (nishkriya) and wretched as a dog.
The particular comparisons given are:
- A physician’s (vaidya’s) food: like eating excrement (mala).
- A courtesan’s (raṇkuṭāli’s) food: like drinking urine.
- A carpenter’s (vaḍrangi’s) food: like blood.
- The food of one who sells vidyā (learning), that is, who turns learning and teaching into trade: the same as śūdra-anna (śūdra’s food), to be avoided even by ordinary good people (sajjanas).
- A slanderer’s (piśuna’s) food, the food of one guilty of chāḍī (tale-bearing) and of ruining others’ names: like a pool of blood. Eating it carries a fault equal to brahmahatyā (killing a brāhmaṇa).
- Food given without respect, with contempt: never to be eaten. A brāhmaṇa who eats such food suffers disease and the swift ruin of his family line.
- A town guard’s (nagarī-rakshī’s) food: like eating as a caṇḍāla (one outside the varṇa order) eats.
- The food of one guilty of a mahāpātaka (great wrong: go-hatyā, killing a cow; brahma-hatyā, killing a brāhmaṇa; madya-pāna, drinking alcohol; or guru-patnī-gamana, going to the guru’s wife): a brāhmaṇa who eats such a person’s food is born among the rākshasas, adding to their numbers.
- The food of one who seizes pledged or mortgaged wealth for himself, of the kṛtaghna (one who is ungrateful), or of the paṇḍaka (eunuch or impotent man): eating such food leads to birth in the low family line of the śabaras, who are kept outside even by the people of Āryāvarta.
Bhīshma ends by saying that he has told Yudhishṭhira in full the śāstra’s teaching on bhojya (fit) and abhojya (unfit) sources of food, and asks what he wishes to hear next.
Sources
- Mahābhārata, Anuśāsana Parva, Chapter 135